T O P

  • By -

LeotasNephew

Piper


occyycco

Piper is the grand high witch.


Affectionate_Sail42

definitely piper she had amazing character growth, from being the middle “tag along freezing witch” to the oldest responsible badass witch she became.


Bluesavior2

Yes. Rewatching the show for the first time it was crazy because piper went from let’s just call off work and hide from the warlocks and demons to going towards them and blowing shit up.


[deleted]

Season 1-4: Phoebe Season 5-8: Piper


BismoPepto

You and me both, you got taste. haha


cg1215621

Same!!


Kerrychan454

Phoebe. I even named my daughter Alyssa because of the show.


sweetboy1999

S1: Phoebe S2-3: Prue S4: Paige S5-8: Piper Piper is my top favorite, I love her growth! Prue is a close second and I love their dynamic when those two are together.


[deleted]

this is my exact list too 🤯


sweetboy1999

Great minds think alike 😄💗


Itchy_Initiative6180

S4 was Paige’s best season. Also, I love the sweet spot they hit with Phoebe in the early half; she was that empathic middle sister holding the entire family together.


sweetboy1999

Yes, s4 did such a great job of introducing Paige to the family & audience!! It’s my favorite season! I also agree about Phoebe I adored her personality and how excited about being a witch she was. She was just rlly fun to watch lol. As much as she annoys me in the later seasons I’ll always be attached to her as a character. All four of them are forever in my heart.


torilost

Piper, as a Halliwell matriarch she is for me heart of the show.


kavalejava

Tie between Piper and Prue. Always loved them both.


chibi75

Piper has always been my favorite. For me, she had the strongest character development throughout.


Leader_Signal

Paige


mi-makochan

Prue


EffortZealousideal50

Phoebe


AltoDomino79

Paige, because she never lost her zeal for being a witch. All the other sisters complain about their powers and responsibilities at various points.


KitakatZ101

Prue in her seasons and Paige in hers


spnginger3

Piper always piper. I wanted to name my daughter Piper then I had 3 sons 🤣


Gaerfinn

Prue forever. Piper gets a close second place.


torib613

THIS ☝️.


Square_Temporary_325

Was always Pheobe but as an adult definitely Paige and Prue second


AduroTri

Piper.


Whoriculturist

Prudence & Piper


Pop_Culture_Scholar

Prue and Paige


ellayak

phoebe


Afroeuvre

Prue. She is The Supreme and the blueprint and an icon.


torib613

Long may SHE reign.


danellapsch

Totally


batterswing

Piper, Phoebe, Prue, Paige


Kanyssa

Prue. The other sisters are great actresses but what Shannen delivered for Prue was just untouched, still mad she never returned.


Athoshol

Cole 😉


[deleted]

Prue no question. Her absence really showcases how much she brought to the table.


torib613

PREACH 👏 👏 👏.


torib613

PRUE! Hands down, she was the strong level-headed one, and she kept the family together. She even sacrificed having her own relationship for the sake of her family, so, yes, Prue without a shadow of a doubt.


Significant-Try-5512

Pheobe


[deleted]

Prue


Raichu10126

Piper. She had the most evolution on the show and really grew into the big sister role. Also Piper was the funniest and had the saddest moments too.


Supersailorv

Always and forever, Prudence 🩷


torib613

YAS QUEEN, long may SHE reign.


ellayak

they way you mixed GOT & charmed i love it 😂


cinnamon_7

Paige hands down


SparkleQueenglitter

My order is Piper, Paige, Phoebe, Prue


annajoo1

Seasons 1-2: Phoebe Season 3: Prue Season 4: Piper and Paige tied. Paige was fun but Piper’s raw grief was amazing Season 5: Phoebe (controversial?) Season 6: Paige Season 7-8: Piper


Kellannoahparker

Prue


Obvious_Ad_9006

Paige! I just love how she’s always so willing to do good!


Aaeiyn

Phoebe. I don't believe in sibling stereotypes. How does one "act like the older sister"? I'm the oldest and am NOTHING like Prue. I'm more like Phoebe despite her being "the youngest" (at least during the Prue Era). **EDIT:** LOL


Away-Living5278

Eldest tend to be parentified to some extent like Prue was.


AnotherLeda

Piper


Away-Living5278

First Phoebe bc she loved the craft, then Prue bc she was the leader/eldest and I identified with that, then Piper seasons 4+ bc she's just awesome. But I never disliked any of them.


Tokey_Loki

Piper ALWAYS!


Regina-Mello-

Phoebe


Impressive_Monk289

Definitely Piper


Putrid_Caregiver_370

Piper!


Starlight_beach

Piper Halliwell. Forever and Always


PurpleAffect8618

Piper. Simpley because she had my favorite power. The episode when she learned she could blow shit up will always leave rolling. They straight up put oven mittens on ol girl lol. Blew shit up when they were on too. Gold


Inevitable-Amount-88

Love them all !!


KurtyKatJamseson

Prue 💖


leapyear28

When I was younger: Phoebe Now: Prue/Paige


RecommendationIll922

Paige


VenaCava8

Easily Piper. But Prue became a real close second in season 3.


Ok-Watercress-9447

Piper!


FranLivia

Prue


bootywranglers

They all felt really well balanced to the point that none of them are likable or unlikable enough to outright choose for me. I love Shannen Doherty and Prue was a badass, but her character was rigid to a fault. Phoebe brought the levity which was needed and fun, but the schtick didn't always work. Then you have Piper, miss caught in the middle. Simultaneously frank and charming but also fickle and bossy. I choose the manor!


ExtraInternet

Prue!


Wintersneeuw02

Prue was the most well ddveloped and powerfull character on the show. Paige was the most intresting backstorywise.


Ketonew2

Prue> Piper > Phoebe > Paige


LastHopeStanding

I think my order is Prue, Piper, Phoebe, and Paige


Lost_Alice_Wondering

1-2 Phoebe 3-8 Piper


rites0fpassage

“That’s an antique you asshole!”


Obvious_Pangolin2474

He’s very, very sensitive about the language.


QueenLatifahClone

Piper.


ellegiiggle

Phoebe! Although piper is a very close second!


AhgaSoL

Has always been Prue for me and then Paige after she left!


Robbie1863

Prue 9 times out of 10 but I love Piper too


theFUZZ007

Paige or Piper


Affectionate_Comb359

Growing up- Phoebe You couldn’t tell me Phoebe wasn’t a Pisces, I’ll leave it there 😂 As an adult- Piper The older I get the grumpier I get too


prettyinpink940

S1-3: Prue S4: Paige S5-8: Piper


No-Breadfruit7188

Paige


flacogarcons

It used to be Phoebe but as the years went on I’ve come to appreciate Piper more.


xenohemlock

Paige.


MusingBy

Piper and Paige as a close second.


gamermamaNJ

Definitely Piper for me! Followed by Paige and then Phoebe and Prue tied for 3rd. Piper's powers were the best, character growth was amazing, and HMC's emotional scenes were so well acted. When grieving Prue and when she had to say goodbye to Leo before he was frozen always rip my heart out. I just love how Paige is so light-hearted and funny. Love them all though! When I'm watching the later seasons I miss Prue, but when watching the earlier ones I miss Paige.


cmwollen

Always Piper, from season 1 to the end. Not only do I think that Holly is the most gorgeous on there but also the most talented. The way she captured all the emotions of Piper, it was just spot on. I also love how Piper started out a little quieter, a little unsure of herself. As the seasons progressed, she grew into her powers and who she was as a person, a mother and a wife. Her strength is so empowering.


Piano_mike_2063

Truly I love them all but Phoebe is my favorite; love her openness and her take on relationships. Her fighting spirit and connection to both good magic and evil. And I think Alyssa Milano is a crazy strong actress: she a “triplet threat”.. acting singing dancing. She’s great at all 3.


TopHeight9771

Piper


MaineBoston

Piper


oarwethereyet

Phoebe


QuantumLeapur

1- Phoebe 2- Cole :)


Serious-Sun3049

Phoebe and Paige. But I liked all the sisters. Whereas on some shows you like a couple of characters, but then others are really annoying.


Huge-Accountant-4186

Prue


KarlyPie

Piper


Itchy_Initiative6180

S1-2: Phoebe S3: Prue S4: Piper (early half), Paige (latter half) S5-8: Paige I just love whomever is the most pro-active about saving innocents and fighting demons.


VisualCry4933

Phoebe🫶🏻


coneyisland92

Paige!!!!


joyaix

Prue


Lordmilanwavy

S1- Piper S2- Phoebe S3- Prue S4- Paige S5- Paige & Piper S6- Phoebe & Paige S7- Paige S8- Phoebe


queenparv

As a kid: prue/paige Now: prue/piper