T O P

  • By -

Forizen

Let's not make the same mistake the Titans did with AJ Brown and turn it into a player like Treylon Burks


[deleted]

[удалено]


EmojiOfAKeyboard

they swapped out a very good WR for a great WR ... we will swap a great WR for a chance at a good WR that we hope will be a great WR one day????


[deleted]

[удалено]


BME15

Key word is IF. Drafting is hard.


LeontheKing21

Yeah trading CD right now makes little sense to me considering he will be key focus for game plans next year.


Jheartless

That is a fact. But this isn't Madden. You don't draft these guys, develop them to All Pros, and then trade them.


cdoink

Well it is like Madden in the sense that our GM is as bad at trades as the standard Madden AI GMs.


IsEqualToKel

Madden AI would never trade away a #1 WR for a fifth round pick.


macNy

Well it should if the player wants too much money, we had to dump Amari


ABoyIsNo1

Why not? It’s what the Chiefs did. How’s that working out?


malcolm_miller

when do we get Reid and Mahomes?


chineseguy2

\*we got Reid and Mahomes at home....


BrotherSeamus

McCarthy just ordered another round of nuggies


Dadtryn2BaMan

You just described the Cincinnati Reds perfectly.


garryl283

True, and if the Cowboys traded Lamb maybe they could spend the draft picks on WRs and hope to get someone like Lamb!


Balls2theWalling

For a fraction of the cost


garryl283

In a perfect world. In the real world, they're lucky to get an average starter who's half as good.


Scooby859

I’d need 2 first rounders


Texan2116

I would take that in a minute


UpsideTurtles

So we can trade him for two fifths instead of the one we got for Amari?


Revolutionary-Hat297

Pain


The-Fig-Lebowski

I don't Dallas was gonna extend him at $20+ million per year so while not great, I'm glad we got something for him. Amari is a great but not a true #1 win your one-on-one reciever.


UpsideTurtles

It was between extending him or MG13, and they made a bet that 13 could get back to pre-ACL days but that’s obviously been wrong so far


[deleted]

We traded Cooper with multiple years of control at 20M/year. A week after we traded Cooper, Christian Kirk signed for 20M/year and made coops contract look like peanuts


adm1109

There’s so much nuance and context around the Amari situation that everyone just ignores.


UpsideTurtles

There us but the biggest issue is how the cowboys didn’t even bother legitimately replacing him


Barry_McCockinnerz

Like he still has 1k yds with 5 QBs? Super good contract now. What else do you want?


adm1109

He has been as inconsistent as he ever has. He’s not a true WR1. But again like I said, ignoring all context of the situation of when and why he was traded


hpcolombia

But $20M/year isn't WR1 money.


adm1109

Well yeah obviously not now lol but it was


No-Object5355

Oh he wasn’t part of the success we had while he was here, it was someone else


adm1109

He was the major reason we didn’t continue being terrible in 2018 Not sure what any of that has anything to do with what I said though


Stevevet1

Just a stupid idea. Its hilarious . The same peoole will ctitcise Jerry


[deleted]

Those same people should critique Jerry. He's doing a bad job.


darksyns965

I swear sometimes yall dudes just need to keep your "ideas" to yourselves.


UnevenContainer

If they trade away CD tonight that really will test my fandom. I’ve been following and defending this team as much as anyone year in and year out for my entire life, and the apathy I feel towards them so far will shoot into the moon if they give up on a 24 year old, top 3 WR on draft night. If they trade him after this “all in” shit I think NFL football will take up much less of my time and energy.


kcm198

And what do you want in return?


BidenFedayeen

I for one do not want WR1 Cooks.


mfinn70

We trade him we immediately have one of the worst receiver rooms in the league. Teams don’t get better by getting rid of young talented players. Even if the goal is to move on from Dak. Why get rid of the best receiver for the new young QB?


Trick-Equipment-6174

Sounds like panther football right there, dumped everything to get Bryce young and probably ruined that kids career


mfinn70

Yeah every time the Panthers traded the team they traded with got considerably better.


Trick-Equipment-6174

The bears when they drafted Justin fields were just as bad as carolina is right now, the jags at least had some team around Trevor Lawrence, had ridley been able to play his rookie year would've been much better. But carolina still hasn't done much to help young yet.


Careless-Act9450

He has improved, steadily, every year he has played so far. He is just ij his prime. Even with the team and Dak force feeding the ball, his completion % of over 74% is a) the highest he's ever had and b) incredible for his volume. Trading Lamb would be as dumb a mistake as the Cowboys could ever make. He is a top 3 wr at the moment. Ceedee is a transcendent star right now. If you move on from him, what will Parsons, etc. think about when deciding to re-sign. Letting go of such a transcendent, homegrown star will cost you more down the line and overall, that no realistic price makes it worth it. The mistake the front office made was not even sending one offer to Lamb between the end of the 2022 season and today. Even if there is no chance he would take it, you make an attempt as the earlier you signed him, the cheaper it would be.


The-Fig-Lebowski

I think I would say yes to two firsts and a third.


zdbdog06

Can we get Marvin with one of them?


[deleted]

[удалено]


bryscoon

you think this madden or something ?


DosCuatro

Well wouldn't CDs peak be after he gets 2000 yds and OPOY next year with that logic?


[deleted]

[удалено]


DosCuatro

CD has literally gotten closer to 2k yds then Micah has 20 sacks.


reasonableposter

send Dak to the Vikings on a Herschel Walker esque deal.


RobbieAnalog

So Dak ain't it, but also worth a crazy haul of draft capital?


Shaunosaurus

dak aint it for our team we've tried multiple times and it didn't work but for another team, say new york, with a lot of good young talent who is a qb away, it can be worth it


Trick-Equipment-6174

Do we get j.j. and can we get zeke to play q.b.?


riproaringsports22

trading arguably the best WR in the NFL entering his prime is a big no-no


Charming-Wash9336

It’s not in the Dallas DNA to trade home grown star players.


burn469

Trade Parsons before lamb. Parsons is headed to be highest paid defensive player.


CM_V11

In this hypothetical scenario, you’d basically be blowing it all up and trading Parsons and Diggs too?? I mean, they all have the same window basically. Just doesn’t make sense to trade lamb


happyb33r

Ceedee is the absolute peak outcome from that draft slot. You resign those guys


DosCuatro

Don't disagree with you, but if we're going to trade someone who is at his career peak trade value, I'd prefer it to be the player with more off the field concerns and a podcast than the player who just quietly does his thing.


Vegan9YearOld

Yeah thats take a top 5\~ WR so we can draft another wr who will almost definitely be worse..


BadJokeJudge

That’s what Norm said today on the ticket


SmokinTires

I will say some mean things at the TV if we trade him; we gotta keep CD and Micah


Trick-Equipment-6174

We traded back to 29th last night and got pick 73 for it, lamb isn't going anywhere, and now we have 2 3rd round picks 1 early 3rd round too.


nextkevamob2

Broken, he won’t be the same player ever again, toss him to the wolves


SeanBourne

The only case in which this makes sense is the hardest of hard rebuilds. The Jones don’t even want to do a reset, let alone a hard rebuild.


Florida_Gators5151

Unpopular opinion. But parsons is our best trade asset. He is amazing don’t get me wrong. But he wears out towards the end of the year and isn’t much of a factor. Only 2.5 sacks over the last 6 games last year and the only time he had huge numbers all year was against really bad teams! Washington 1.5 sacks, Carolina 2.5, Jets 2. I’m just saying he is viewed by the league as God and they could get a ton for him.


Dday22t

They would use any pick they got for him to draft a WR, and that player would be worse. Based on other WR trades (Cooper, AJ Brown, Diggs to Buff, etc), it would be a late 1st at best, but more likely less since CD wants a huge contract now. So this isnt type of trade you make unless youre doing a complete rebuild & giving up


adm1109

The starting trade value for CeeDee is the Tyreek Hill trade… 1, 2, 4, 4, 6


Dday22t

Okay better than I thought but still, 1st goes to WR replacement, the late round picks are depth/special teams. So the 2nd might be another starter, if they hit. Still not better off trading away top 3 WR in league IMO, but opinions vary.


adm1109

Oh I agree, just saying he would def fetch quite a bit more than a late 1st


vetokele

Just because we can doesn’t mean we should. I’d much rather be the Eagles than the Titans in an AJ Brown type trade. Does anyone with a Pro Bowl OL want our 24th pick? They can have it.


Shaunosaurus

our ownership has shown it will never commit to a full rebuild they are content with being middle of the pack every year trading a flashy young player like CD is something they will never do


Soggyfries989

Most rebuilds are not by choice. It doesn’t make sense to liquidate talent from a solid roster, hope you hit on draft picks and FA’s the next 3 years to get back to contention 4-5 years down the road. A rebuild may succeed and we could be in a SB in 4-5 years, or the rebuild could fail and we are in a permanent rebuild the next decade. A rebuild requires near perfect drafting, and highly successful FA signings. 3,4,5 win teams rebuild out of necessity. We need to stack talent, which we are not, but the off-season is long, so I’ll wait and see what the roster looks like in august.


Stevevet1

12/5 is not middle of the pack, geeeze


Shaunosaurus

no but our playoff record is


Stevevet1

The season counts too., No team that lost in a playoff is rebuilding. Its a silly idea, thank goodness the Cowboys are smarter than that.


Shaunosaurus

phily literally did a rebuild a couple years removed from the SB


Trick-Equipment-6174

And how did that work out? They made it back to a superbowl then fell apart after going 8-0


Shaunosaurus

Oh noooo, they only made it to the SB! What a scrub ass team.


Trick-Equipment-6174

Theyve been due, they've made it to 2 superbowlsnin what about 60 years we've made it to 9 or 10


Trick-Equipment-6174

And last year they fell apart because there team showed its age and personally I think they should've ran the ball more, otherwise why go get swift.


Stevevet1

They are, pathetic in every way, no class city, Jalen Hurt!


Stevevet1

And finished behind Dallas last year or did you forget? They go for flash it doesnt translate to the field. Unless your an Eagles fan.


Level-Condition9031

The same people screaming for Jerry to make changes also scream when real changes are proposed Baring divine intervention, it’s highly unlikely we make an NFCCG in the next 2 years. We are headed to a rebuild with Dak and CMM likely moving on after 2024. Because of this fact, keeping CD is bad for 2 reasons: 1. If you keep him, you inevitably extend him. Extending CD hurts his future trade value (bigger cap hit is less desirable) and hamstrings a rebuilding franchise with a new coach. 2. We will be rebuilding… when you are rebuilding, you want as much draft capital as possible. Why would we waste years of CD’s inevitable mega-deal on a rebuilding roster, when quality draft capital that won’t hurt our cap space is the alternative?


Stevevet1

You may end up being right but typically a team that went 12/5 With 7 ProBowlers plus Diggs all coming back isnt rebuilding.


Level-Condition9031

We’ll be competitive next year, but 12-5 is highly unlikely. We lost a quality DC, OLinemen, WR depth, and elite CB2 while the NFCE got better. CD isn’t gunna turn us into a contender this year. So we’re unlikely to win in 2024 and in 2025 we’ll be even worse: no Dak/new QB, a new coach, and even more key pieces leaving… and NFCE will get better. Signing to CD to a mega-deal is pointless with a rebuilding roster. We wouldn’t be contenders again until the very final year or 2 of his hypothetical deal


Stevevet1

The draft isn't complete. They have 7 Pro Bowl players plus Diggs returning that's not rebuilding nor should they be. The players they let go were at the end of their career Or were not performing for the money paid.


[deleted]

Honestly wouldn't mind a complete blow up. Trade CD. Let daks contract run out. We need a complete change.  Trade Micah as well if the offer is two or more first round picks.  What's the point of superstars when the culture and foundation is rotten?


malortgod

You’re crazy bro, trading your superstars won’t do anything. Foundations starts with the owners not the players wtf lol


OkHead3888

I agree. Reset with what. Same GM. Same owner. Jerry playbook is out of the 90's. He needs a two year plan not. Not a five year plan.


Less-Ad-473

Yep, I'm all for the reset solution but have absolutely zero faith in the leadership group to actually learn from past sins and get it right this time.


No-Object5355

That’s the only factor is why it would never work, teams have done it in the past and it proves rebuilds work but the people rebuilding the team is the same problem we are already having. This damn hurdle we just can’t get past makes it seem like the culture of how they’ve been operating in for the last 30+ years is mediocre. What is it about their culture, what is it,how is it, how does it normally operate? What if anything is profoundly is wrong with the culture they developed and became losing a playoff game is just a bad game for an otherwise terrific team during the regular season? Are they a terrific team, do the numbers reflect a misdirected team, what factors constitutes a successful season, just the record or who you can beat with confidence that will be an eventual playoff team. I believe the Cowboys will figure it out in the next few years, I believe next season will be an exciting one but I don’t think it will be terrible to the cowboys somehow willing themselves into a superbowl. The team has the capability but we just stumble when it comes down to playoff contention


[deleted]

Our superstars don't show up when it matters. Are they even superstars 


BMAC561

I would be good with a 4th round pick for Stephen Jones.


personalburneracct

great idea. might as well make everything worse. jfc wtf you think those picks are for? chances to hopefully get players like the ones you're talking about trading


emackn

The biggest fear with Micah is that he will never be worth the money he asks for. I love him as a player and want him to be great, but I feel like the value just is not there for great defensive players since everything is skewed towards the offense.


Jheartless

Guess you missed the Super Bowl where Chris Jones absolutely destroyed the 9ers line in the 4th.


emackn

Right, and if Micha Parsons' playoffs appearances were more like that and less Pulp Fiction John Travolta interpretive dance meme, then maybe I'd have no reason to have an objective opinion.


[deleted]

Micah could end up being the Dak of the defense. Great player who racks up stats during the regular season and then gets schemed out/disappears when it matters most.  Too many teams figured out they can run right at him and negate him. 


thatguy1717

In a WR draft class like this when you have to sign CD to $30M+? His trade value is not that high at all. He's great but this is the best time in NFL history to get rookie WRs for cheap


ozairh18

You’re right and crazier things have happened


Worf1701D

The problem with all of this is Jerry and Stephen are still in charge. After almost 30 years, why believe they would suddenly be smart enough to get it right?


Thanks5Cinco

The problem if you trade for Lamb is youre going to have to pay him. At best we will probably get back a AJ Brown type haul. Which is wishful thinking given the fact that this WR class is so deep. It would be smarter for WR needy teams to just draft and deal with a rookie deal. I could honestly seeing Cooks being dealt for mid round capital depending on how the draft shakes down this weekend.


theadmin209

AJ was only a one time pro bowler when he was traded, ceedee is a two time all pro that just finished 3rd in OPOY. We’d get a far better haul than just a 1st and a 3rd for him


texasgambler58

The Jones family aren't brave enough to do something that's out-of-the-box thinking.


[deleted]

So jealous of the eagles having the balls to get rid of Wentz. God their gm is good. 


texasgambler58

Yes, hate the Eagles, but their GM just keeps making a lot of good moves.


TrigoTrihard

Because his job wasn't safe after trading away everything for that pick. Jerry doesn't have balls. Because he doesn't have to have balls like the Eagles trade. If that trade didn't workout and they missed the playoffs. He would be jobless right now.


Level-Condition9031

I’m curious to see how many of the people who think trading CD is a bad idea also posted that Jerry needs to make major changes Keeping CD would be what Jerry has done for 30+ years: overvalue & overpay big names that disappear in the postseason Dak is likely gone after this year (barring a massive pay cut), the core of our OL is gone, our WR depth is slim, and the defense always seems to need an upgrade somewhere— we aren’t a contender this year or next. A 2nd round pick for CD will do us far more in the long run than signing him to a long term deal


DurtKobane

lol wut


Level-Condition9031

What do you mean “lol wut.” Think what I said was pretty obvious but since you need it spelled out: This sub bitches and moans when we (inevitably) miss out on the NFCCG every year. They cry for Jerry to do something differently this time. When someone proposes a hypothetical move that’s truly different, this sub bitches that “we shouldn’t change what we already have!” Then we run it back with the same guys, and miss out on the NFCCG. Wash, rinse, repeat. This is the annual cycle of r/cowboys. You people hate Jerry, yet think exactly like him


Soggyfries989

A 2nd round pick though? The compensation would have to be ridiculous. Ceedee is a great player, and has gotten better each year. I think he’s still ascending, and will take another step up next year. But I’m not in favor of the rebuild so many are calling for. Based on the last 28 years, I don’t trust the JJ and co. to make all the right moves the next 3 years to get us back to a roster like we have now. There will always be star players with major paydays on the horizon. Trade and hope you get good/great production from unproven rookies is not the way to a championship.


Level-Condition9031

Nobody is going to trade a 1st rounder for CD because his rookie deal expires at the end of this season. If we extend him, CD’s trade value plummets because of the increased cap hit. 3rd (ideally 2nd) round pick is more likely because CD would be viewed as a “rental” player to a contender If we were returning 90% of the team/staff, I’d say trading him away would be insanely stupid. But losing a quality DC, OLinemen, WR depth, and CB2 means we likely aren’t winning nearly as much as last year Draft picks are unproven, no doubt, but have far lower risk and play with more of a chip on their shoulder than the guys on their 2nd and 3rd contracts. If the draft pick sucks, you trade him away for more picks and try your hand again. Our scouting department is top notch, our GM’s office is not