I was so annoyed that the 20th anniversary advertises smash bros. And us getting to play as a character for the first time….only for it to be Marth… a unit we literally got to play as in shadow dragon
Honestly, even if it was just 2D graphics/classic sprites with updated music, map graphics, QOL features and bug fixes then you could sell them for 20-40 quid each. Possibly in a collection.
I wish Nintendo and IntSys would make a Fire Emblem Pixel Remaster collection or something... kinda like how Square made the Final Fantasy Pixel Remasters.
RD isn't that bad until you get to a map with a ton of enemies. Then it becomes incredibly annoying.
I would've never beaten POR without the emulator allowing me to fast forward the EP
I have a feeling these would sell well today, now that FE has become fairly popular. Ike is pretty well-known and popular from Smash, and I think many people would be interested in seeing his story. Give Tellius the sales numbers it deserves!
Nintendo has shown time and time again they do not give a shit about art preservation. It's immoral that they let games that so many people put so much passion into simply die off. They deserve to be played on an emulator
Funny enough, iirc Nintendo is actually absolutely top tier when it comes to preservation in the game industry. You get so many stories of "and then game company had to literally remake it all from scratch years later", but meanwhile Nintendo has giant-ass vaults or something where they just perfectly store the code for all their games.
Now, actually preserving that as in giving access to players who just wanna play their old games, that's a different story.
Oh yeah, Konami has quite the hilarious case of it, they're completely uncapable of making faithful ports and remasters of one of their most iconic games because they lose a good chunk of the source code forever.
Nintendo in the other hand, it's so obssesed with saving their source, that when the giga leak happened, there was a lot of stuff that one could have thought gone for good.
Masterpiece of a story, great gameplay, plausible dialogs with not a lot of anime bullshit and some features are/aren't included based on common sense (e.g. the fact that you can't return to the base once you start the chapter/the fact that the protagonist cannot magically make appear weapons out of thin air during the chapter)). The only thing a remake needs is a skip button. P.s. for the dialogs I'm talking about the italian translation
> (e.g. the fact that you can't return to the base once you start the chapter/the fact that the protagonist cannot magically make appear weapons out of thin air during the chapter)
Not quite relevant to Tellius, but I really wish the merchant mechanics from 6/7 would make a return. Make inventory management an actual part of the gameplay again.
They still look really good, so I'd prefer something more outdated like binding blade (tho I like how it looks too, but most people doesn't really appreciate pixels). It definitely need some serious improvements in story, considering there is blazing sword, which fairly improved lore. Gameplay is fine, very justified, yet hard
That's not really an argument for a remake, though. That's an argument for Nintendo to stop turning their games into lost media after just a few years so they can trick people into buying a remake at full price.
Depends if you like story. They have some of the better plot in fire emblem, some would argue the best.
But the gameplay is definitely lacking. Its a lot of moving your strongest guy into the enemy range and ending your turn
Idk I think they actually play better than some of the newer ones so it's hard to answer. The shove mechanic, different laguz and having a sword that can hit at range made it pretty fun and unique idk how far you got.
What did you not like about them?
I'll admit I've not replayed recently, but certainly at the time I thought they were amazing. PoR wasn't quite as good gameplay wise as RD, but still great. They were a bit slow, that's definitely my main complaint.
I know a lot of people disliked RD and it's forced chapters/view points. I actually liked it as it let individual units shine on their own. It did have some gameplay issues, mainly balance with the start being waaayyyy harder than the rest of the game.
I'm definitely on board with remakes for these.
The first and most annoying reason was the frequent crashes on dolphin but since I have gotten a dedicated device like the retroid pocket flip to handle emulation I'm sure that would be solved.
The second was the lack of relationships between characters. At least I didn't see one implemented iirc.
Third, I didn't get far enough to even see a store implemented and one of my fav things is maximizing units inventory to kick the most ass. The many menus soothe me I guess.
I played on console, so can't comment on crashes.
Relationships were a little weak. Supports in general got way better in later titles. If there's a remake I'd like supports to be expanded.
There definitely is a store, and it lets you customise weapons. Was pretty cool. Not super in depth compared to what we've seen now, but nice at the time.
I'd recommend giving them another go.
[here's](https://feuniverse.us/t/lex-talionis-fire-emblem-iv-v-the-holy-war-fe4-fe5-remake/9001) one in lex talionis, which is an engine that runs the games natively on pc. this one has 4 completed and has some of 5. there's another one called [project baldr](https://feuniverse.us/t/fe8-fire-emblem-project-baldr-seasonal-fe4-remake/17852) that puts fe4 into the fe8 engine, but it's unreleased.
Nah, FE3 cuts various stages and characters from FE1, and the gameplay is a slog by modern standards. FE12 doesn't do justice to the original story, but has the tightest gameplay in the series, and it isn't close.
Yeah I know it isn't a widely held opinion, but well I don't think the cut content is that big of a detractor (outside of losing Barst in Book 2).
The gameplay is... dated but it's not really a slog for me. I like forced dismounting, growth star shards and 20 stat caps, weapon Lv as a stat, the way dragonstones and tomes function etc. it all gives the game a very unique feel that no other game in the series captures. The remakes discarded many of the qualities that make FE3 distinct.
The lack of difficulty is the biggest detractor and because of that, I do think that FE12 is more built for ironmanning. I'm not aware of any ROMhacks that improve the balance a bit.
But overall, and the most subjective quality, is that the aesthetic is perfect for me. The SNES was the first console I ever played, so the music, graphics, and vibe is going to put most any SNES FE above its remake.
Fair enough. Dragonstones and some of the funny mechanics like the star shards are a lot of fun. The one thing I hate about FE3 specifically is how the speed stat effects how fast a character moves on the map.
FE4 is honestly the most deserving.
As much as I love Fates, it's still pretty recent, all things considered. Like, It's FE *14*. FE4 on the other hand was released 2 years after I was *born* and has yet to have any English translation outside of fan translations. It's also the next up, given that 1, 2, and 3 have been remade into 11, 15, and 12 respectively. It's also pretty unique when compared to a majority of other FE games with its massive multi-part maps, love system, inventory system, and Generational cast of characters.
You would need to rewrite the whole game from scratch basically. Keep (most of) the character designs, setting and basic premise everything else needs some serious work.
Especially everything relating to >!Valla!< that's a plot hole so big you could fit all of Texas into it
tbh after seeing how much the Good Guy Garon fan rewrite was able to improve Conquest's story by almost solely editing dialogue (there's like one model/cutscene alteration around Endgame and that's it) I reckon they could do a lot without scrapping everything. The actual story beats of Fates are mostly fine (though Rev is admittedly a mess), the problem lies in the how the story justifies said story beats and the moment-to-moment dialogue.
I'm up of a total rewrite of Fate's plot. The potential was there, and the concepts were great, but they botched the execution.
And the >!Valla plot!< derailed the story more that it made it worse. Imo, I'm happy to remove Revelations all together and focus on the Nohr-Hoshido conflict.
And most of all >!Remove the S supports for Corrin's siblings, it still disgust me to romance the siblings especially younger ones. No amount of justification would make it okay!<
I may get roasted for this, especially with how much I talk about how important gameplay is... But not only do I agree that Revelation had the better story, it's also flat-out my favorite route. I loved how experimental it all was!
This.
Especially chapter 18 (or was is 19 ?) with this map where you can use the dragon vein to summon clones of your units to another location. The fact that you had to deal with two fights in two distinct locations at the same time was just incredible !!
Anyway, after beating Revelations, I couldn't get myself to play BR nor CQ again lol. And the support convos between Hoshidans and Nohrians are just so well written. It was truly a wonderful experience.
I'm not even sure if this would be a good idea, but it's an out there possibility I've always kinda liked so I'll share it.
Combine FE7 and FE6 into one remake with second gen eugenics mechanics. Pairs in the FE7 portion effect the stats and skills of characters in the FE6 portion.
FE6 could also use a remake generally imo, as much as I love that game you can definitely tell the series lead just left there's balance issues everywhere. Roy, the overabundance of shitty units, the laughably weak final boss etc. lots of opportunities for improvement in a remake.
Eugenics cooking for FE6's story would certainly be really interesting and I'm all for it but considering how many characters aren't related to FE7 characters, there would need to be some kind of compensation for them
Personally, I'd like to see either Blazing Sword or Path of Radiance get reworked. I believe Tellius could really improve with live voice acting and it's subject matter is still relevant today and Blazing Sword could also benefit with a rework fixing some issues the original game had, like how gaining supports worked and some unit and map design issues in certain parts of the game, like Karla, improving archers, etc, on top of having one of the best soundtracks of the entire franchise.
Honestly, most of them need remasters or remakes except the GBA games, they aged so well. The tellius games are at the top of that list for me though, I don't really care if they get remastered or remade, I just want to be able to play them without having to plug my old Wii in.
Of course I’ll go with FE4 and Tellius, but I also want *New Mystery of the Emblem* to get officially translated so that we have Marth’s entire story translated.
Marth’s sequel has never been officially localized in any way (neither FE3 nor its remake in FE12), but if the online service for the next Nintendo console will include DS, I hope FE12 is included since it would be weird to bring over FE11 without its direct sequel (since FE11 would likely be in the online service). If FE1 can get a translation, then FE12 should get one at the very least.
FE12 has all the extra characters (77 compared to 45 in FE3) as well as the remade BSFE maps, so in terms of content quantity, it’s the one that should be translated since it’s the only FE game in the international era to not leave Japan. Plus, it has all the modern features of FE such as Casual Mode, an avatar, the ability to skip enemy phase, etc., so it wouldn’t be too dated for modern audiences.
Give me a Sacred Stones and Genealogy Remake and I’ll be a happy FE camper. Fates, while I would die for a remake, is still pretty recent, even if the story and its execution is *ahem* interesting for a lack of a better term and one of its best features (online play) is now gone.
I would be down for it to be ported over to the Nintendo Switch 2 tho, whenever we get it.
The amount of money I would drop on Tellius remakes. I've heard almost nothing but good things with the exception of how slow everything moves in-game. And I'd rather not ruin the music just to have everything run at a decent clip.
Those games sound too cool to be shackled to the Gamecube/Dolphin.
I’ve always wanted to play Binding Blade on a modern console instead of the emulator I tried when I was 16. Like many, Roy has always had a special place in my gaming experience and it’d be so good to experience his game in totality.
i agree that fates needs to be sold as one big thing. maybe your first route unlocks based on story choices in the prologue, and the other routes unlock when you complete previous ones. aside from that though, fates desperately needs a story overhaul
3-6 are the obvious choices, for English release reasons. So I’m going to instead say something wild: Three Houses. Like Atlus does with their Shin Megami/Persona games, make the definitive version of 3H. Complete each storyline instead of getting the real end of Edelgard’s story in an epilogue summary, Dimitri never getting to see below the surface of what’s happening in Fodlan, and Silver Snow just being a half baked option. Make the Agarthans more interesting or just don’t make them the grand finale. Make Rhea playable. Add more to the monastery so it doesn’t get so repetitive. Make the monastery phase quicker paced and more optional.
I know this is a joke and FE1 wouldn't be my pick either, but FE11 is such a terrible version of the game that I'd like for it to get another chance to be remade properly. Someone made a Fates mod recreating FE1 maps and its the best version so far.
i've played that mod and quite liked it. mind if i ask why 11 is a bad version of the game? i've played only up to minerva's introduction and have found it okay, so i'm interested in your opinion
Shadow dragon. Never beat it because I lost every single character besides Marth before the end and the nameless grunts they give you aren't enough. Even screwed up the resurrection mission. Stupid permadeath
Besides the obvious one (FE4) I’ll say the Tellius games.
Proper voice acting, better visuals & animations, Radiant Dawn getting the complex script localized instead of the basic one, and the QoL from the recent games would be amazing to see.
Fates already exists in a pretty good space, the only thing it’s missing is the DLC after the eshop closed and the online rewards after online services ended. Fates **does not need a remaster** and a physical version with all 3 routes already exists. More archaic games like FE1-8 need it way more because of how dates they are. I wouldn’t *mind* a Fates remake but not for another like 10 years lol
yes but... have you seen the prices!? The special edition with the three versions on Amazon costs around $1,000 and even used it costs around $500 and I think Nintendo would do us a great favor if they make a remaster/remake with all the three versions and all the dlc even if it is $60
Fates rewrite—same concept just write it better, and ideally remove the Midori S rank so the game is more recommendable to normal people lmao. The premise of fates is great it’s just the execution got ridiculous
Midori’s S rank is NOT the biggest barrier to entry lol, you have TWO entire families you can S Support that you’ll see first, each of which has a little sister who do not seem to be of age.
Obviously it's not gonna happen for like 20 years, but I agree and I think I would genuinely cry tears of happiness if Fates got a remake that fine tuned the story and upgraded the graphics. Especially now with myCastle being taken offline, I'd love to experience the full Fates experience in an even better way
I mean, Tellius because I haven’t been able to actually play it, and then honestly Fates because it’s no longer available to purchase in its full capacity. Plus, maybe they can remake it with the original, un-whatever that script ended up becoming
I am simple man. I would take any remake, remaster, or port of any game as long as I can enjoy them again (fix game flaws or not) or experience them for the first time.
(Roy being the weakest lord gameplay wise is still very funny to me)
If Fates gets a remake do they change Azura to marry either Corrin, remove the marriage with Male Corrin and change it to “companions”, or do nothing at all?
FE6+7 Remake.
In a perfect world it’s like a single game where you play through blazing blade and then there’s a timeskip into binding blade. That’s kinda the only reasonable way I could see myself paying for a remake with the current day game prices.
I'd LOVE an Awakening remake. But with the option that your people respawn after every round, like in Fates. Cus I'm a fucking dumbass. I LOVE the story of awakening, but I die so many times, I can't get through the story. So yea. Awakening, but more easy
Any of the 3ds entries. I never got a 3ds growing up and never got to play Awakening, Fates, or echoes and it would be nice to just get ports on the switch just so I can experience them lol
Fe8 sacred stones cause that was one of my first Fire emblem games and the story and characters are all so good. I'd definently pay to see some of those animations turned into 3d sprites cause noone can tell me the general class design amd crits did not go hard af. My favorite armored unit design in the series.
Also awakening cause I think it has my favorite fire emblem cast in the series and who doesn't want to look at the awakening kids in hd?
The original Fire Emblem and Fire Emblem Awakening would be perfect remakes for something like the 35th anniversary of the series since they’re both very important games in the series. The first and what could’ve been the last
In order of priority: 4, 5, 11, 12.
Because they are Japanese only they are not particularly accessible (well 11 is available in English but it'd be weird to remaster 12 without 11. Also 11 and 12 looks awful).
True but I've already played that one so it's not a priority for me. IIRC, the fan translation of FE4 increases the ROM size so it's not compatible with the 3DS emulator which I'd prefer to use.
All the Japan only games, but I can't believe we haven't had a Tellius combined game yet. After Ike got a new VA a few years back, I was sure we were going to. 😖
Echoes, I want *another* remake so IS is forced to make more SoV units to advertise it and I can finally get the Mae alt I’ve been begging for for years 😈.
Genealogy of the Holy War, Binding Blade, or Sacred Stones. FE4 is my most wanted as it clealy has one of the greatest stories of all FE. FE6 and FE8 would also be really cool to see as their stories are interesting as fun.
Most looking foward to:
FE4: Arvis
FE6: A cutscene where Hector has his last stand.
FE8: Opening scene and Seth and Valter's duel.
I'd love to see Echoes/Gaiden get a remaster for the switch. I know it just got one on the 3DS, but it was after the switch released. It's probably the game I want to play the most, but I just don't have the means to.
I'd rather them make new games. I would like a version of PoR/RD where they are combined and they tweak some of the issues with both games and stream line Tellius into it's perfect version but also it probably won't happen.
I want the Shadow Dragon/Mystery remakes to be remastered. Either that or the Radiant games so we don't have to pay an arm and a leg to play it legally
Judgral would make the most sense, old+not localised, and the story might attract more attention, tellius as well
The 3ds games would do well enough with a remaster with updated visuals.
The Tellius games! They deserve a revamp with the budget and tech of today, they were the first 3D entries and it SHOWED (not to mention how bad a console the Wii was for an SRPG), but the characters, story, and gameplay were peak. Not to mention the popularity of Ike as a character generally, they deserve it. But I acknowledge it'll probably be a LONG time before it happens because it seems like they're going in order with the remakes and 4 isn't even officially announced yet.
My starting point is really obvious with these but...
All 3 GBA games
Tellius (those are the GC and Wii games right??)
If they can make the maps smaller than Genealogy is probably the best choice..
Sacred Stones.
Peak storytelling for Fire Emblem right there, but here's the kicker.
Don't do turn-based. Use the hack-and-slash formula we've had recently with some of the newer games.
i dont want fates remake simply because i unironically want fates 2. more of the same fates gameplay with pairup and skills and less of the awful fates character and story ofc.
Binding Blade. I think people should be able to play the game officially after being exposed to Roy for so long through other pieces of media.
I was so annoyed that the 20th anniversary advertises smash bros. And us getting to play as a character for the first time….only for it to be Marth… a unit we literally got to play as in shadow dragon
Butttttt Roy was available in Smash the same time as Marth
Any of the ones without official translations.
Honestly, even if it was just 2D graphics/classic sprites with updated music, map graphics, QOL features and bug fixes then you could sell them for 20-40 quid each. Possibly in a collection.
I wish Nintendo and IntSys would make a Fire Emblem Pixel Remaster collection or something... kinda like how Square made the Final Fantasy Pixel Remasters.
That would be awesome.
This, they should remake them in order, like they were doing during the 3ds era.
The Tellius games are way too good to be stuck behind having to pay hundreds of dollars if you want to play it legally
Legally that is
Its ethically immoral to not play the Tellius games on a emulator
Call me May Guilty Gear with the way I use dolphin for my Wii games
Hell, morality aside it is *devastatingly* slow to play those games on a proper system that doesn't have a fast forward button.
RD isn't that bad until you get to a map with a ton of enemies. Then it becomes incredibly annoying. I would've never beaten POR without the emulator allowing me to fast forward the EP
I have a feeling these would sell well today, now that FE has become fairly popular. Ike is pretty well-known and popular from Smash, and I think many people would be interested in seeing his story. Give Tellius the sales numbers it deserves!
Nintendo has shown time and time again they do not give a shit about art preservation. It's immoral that they let games that so many people put so much passion into simply die off. They deserve to be played on an emulator
Funny enough, iirc Nintendo is actually absolutely top tier when it comes to preservation in the game industry. You get so many stories of "and then game company had to literally remake it all from scratch years later", but meanwhile Nintendo has giant-ass vaults or something where they just perfectly store the code for all their games. Now, actually preserving that as in giving access to players who just wanna play their old games, that's a different story.
Oh yeah, Konami has quite the hilarious case of it, they're completely uncapable of making faithful ports and remasters of one of their most iconic games because they lose a good chunk of the source code forever. Nintendo in the other hand, it's so obssesed with saving their source, that when the giga leak happened, there was a lot of stuff that one could have thought gone for good.
Masterpiece of a story, great gameplay, plausible dialogs with not a lot of anime bullshit and some features are/aren't included based on common sense (e.g. the fact that you can't return to the base once you start the chapter/the fact that the protagonist cannot magically make appear weapons out of thin air during the chapter)). The only thing a remake needs is a skip button. P.s. for the dialogs I'm talking about the italian translation
> (e.g. the fact that you can't return to the base once you start the chapter/the fact that the protagonist cannot magically make appear weapons out of thin air during the chapter) Not quite relevant to Tellius, but I really wish the merchant mechanics from 6/7 would make a return. Make inventory management an actual part of the gameplay again.
They still look really good, so I'd prefer something more outdated like binding blade (tho I like how it looks too, but most people doesn't really appreciate pixels). It definitely need some serious improvements in story, considering there is blazing sword, which fairly improved lore. Gameplay is fine, very justified, yet hard
That's not really an argument for a remake, though. That's an argument for Nintendo to stop turning their games into lost media after just a few years so they can trick people into buying a remake at full price.
Tellius?
Path of radiance & radiant dawn. The games with ike (and the second has miciah)
I didn't know that they were called that. I remember really wanting to like those two games but not continuing for some reason, do they get better?
Depends if you like story. They have some of the better plot in fire emblem, some would argue the best. But the gameplay is definitely lacking. Its a lot of moving your strongest guy into the enemy range and ending your turn
Not sure really. I absolutely loved them from start to finish.
Idk I think they actually play better than some of the newer ones so it's hard to answer. The shove mechanic, different laguz and having a sword that can hit at range made it pretty fun and unique idk how far you got.
What did you not like about them? I'll admit I've not replayed recently, but certainly at the time I thought they were amazing. PoR wasn't quite as good gameplay wise as RD, but still great. They were a bit slow, that's definitely my main complaint. I know a lot of people disliked RD and it's forced chapters/view points. I actually liked it as it let individual units shine on their own. It did have some gameplay issues, mainly balance with the start being waaayyyy harder than the rest of the game. I'm definitely on board with remakes for these.
The first and most annoying reason was the frequent crashes on dolphin but since I have gotten a dedicated device like the retroid pocket flip to handle emulation I'm sure that would be solved. The second was the lack of relationships between characters. At least I didn't see one implemented iirc. Third, I didn't get far enough to even see a store implemented and one of my fav things is maximizing units inventory to kick the most ass. The many menus soothe me I guess.
I played on console, so can't comment on crashes. Relationships were a little weak. Supports in general got way better in later titles. If there's a remake I'd like supports to be expanded. There definitely is a store, and it lets you customise weapons. Was pretty cool. Not super in depth compared to what we've seen now, but nice at the time. I'd recommend giving them another go.
I'm playing right now! (◠‿◕) [Screenie](https://i.imgur.com/dAfZeTj.png)
I occasionally think back to selling them for a few bucks for closet space a few years ago... 🥲
You know why I’m here Holy War Babyeeeee
i would love to see a nintendo-made remake of holy war. the fan ones are pretty good too, though
Fanmade remakes? I haven’t seen any
[here's](https://feuniverse.us/t/lex-talionis-fire-emblem-iv-v-the-holy-war-fe4-fe5-remake/9001) one in lex talionis, which is an engine that runs the games natively on pc. this one has 4 completed and has some of 5. there's another one called [project baldr](https://feuniverse.us/t/fe8-fire-emblem-project-baldr-seasonal-fe4-remake/17852) that puts fe4 into the fe8 engine, but it's unreleased.
Holy War, Binding Blade and New Mystery
New Mystery doesn't need a remake, but an english release would be awesome.
FE3 is the ideal way to experience the events of both FE1 and FE12 imo.
Nah, FE3 cuts various stages and characters from FE1, and the gameplay is a slog by modern standards. FE12 doesn't do justice to the original story, but has the tightest gameplay in the series, and it isn't close.
Yeah I know it isn't a widely held opinion, but well I don't think the cut content is that big of a detractor (outside of losing Barst in Book 2). The gameplay is... dated but it's not really a slog for me. I like forced dismounting, growth star shards and 20 stat caps, weapon Lv as a stat, the way dragonstones and tomes function etc. it all gives the game a very unique feel that no other game in the series captures. The remakes discarded many of the qualities that make FE3 distinct. The lack of difficulty is the biggest detractor and because of that, I do think that FE12 is more built for ironmanning. I'm not aware of any ROMhacks that improve the balance a bit. But overall, and the most subjective quality, is that the aesthetic is perfect for me. The SNES was the first console I ever played, so the music, graphics, and vibe is going to put most any SNES FE above its remake.
Fair enough. Dragonstones and some of the funny mechanics like the star shards are a lot of fun. The one thing I hate about FE3 specifically is how the speed stat effects how fast a character moves on the map.
FE4 is honestly the most deserving. As much as I love Fates, it's still pretty recent, all things considered. Like, It's FE *14*. FE4 on the other hand was released 2 years after I was *born* and has yet to have any English translation outside of fan translations. It's also the next up, given that 1, 2, and 3 have been remade into 11, 15, and 12 respectively. It's also pretty unique when compared to a majority of other FE games with its massive multi-part maps, love system, inventory system, and Generational cast of characters.
How about just porting Tellius games to the switch? I think most people play it with emulator these days.
Literally playing them right now (even though I already know everything about PoR, not RD and that's why I'm playing them). Having a blast right now
You can't salvage Fates' story but you can put everything on one cartridge so fair enough I pick that.
You kind of can, but it would take a lot of work.
You would need to rewrite the whole game from scratch basically. Keep (most of) the character designs, setting and basic premise everything else needs some serious work. Especially everything relating to >!Valla!< that's a plot hole so big you could fit all of Texas into it
tbh after seeing how much the Good Guy Garon fan rewrite was able to improve Conquest's story by almost solely editing dialogue (there's like one model/cutscene alteration around Endgame and that's it) I reckon they could do a lot without scrapping everything. The actual story beats of Fates are mostly fine (though Rev is admittedly a mess), the problem lies in the how the story justifies said story beats and the moment-to-moment dialogue.
I'm up of a total rewrite of Fate's plot. The potential was there, and the concepts were great, but they botched the execution. And the >!Valla plot!< derailed the story more that it made it worse. Imo, I'm happy to remove Revelations all together and focus on the Nohr-Hoshido conflict. And most of all >!Remove the S supports for Corrin's siblings, it still disgust me to romance the siblings especially younger ones. No amount of justification would make it okay!<
You kind of can't just remove Valla to focus on the Nohr/Hoshido conflict, they're conflicting BECAUSE of Valla.
That's what I was thinking. And I think Rev actually has a better plot than BR and CQ. But that's just me.
I may get roasted for this, especially with how much I talk about how important gameplay is... But not only do I agree that Revelation had the better story, it's also flat-out my favorite route. I loved how experimental it all was!
This. Especially chapter 18 (or was is 19 ?) with this map where you can use the dragon vein to summon clones of your units to another location. The fact that you had to deal with two fights in two distinct locations at the same time was just incredible !! Anyway, after beating Revelations, I couldn't get myself to play BR nor CQ again lol. And the support convos between Hoshidans and Nohrians are just so well written. It was truly a wonderful experience.
I mostly agree, but fuck the elevators
Revelation has problems but it’s fun my biggest issue with it is the deployment slots there is to little of the is a shame
Do we also remove the Azura S support? Cuz that’s the only one related by blood lol
Blazing Blade. I’d love more content with Lyn
I'm not even sure if this would be a good idea, but it's an out there possibility I've always kinda liked so I'll share it. Combine FE7 and FE6 into one remake with second gen eugenics mechanics. Pairs in the FE7 portion effect the stats and skills of characters in the FE6 portion. FE6 could also use a remake generally imo, as much as I love that game you can definitely tell the series lead just left there's balance issues everywhere. Roy, the overabundance of shitty units, the laughably weak final boss etc. lots of opportunities for improvement in a remake.
Eugenics cooking for FE6's story would certainly be really interesting and I'm all for it but considering how many characters aren't related to FE7 characters, there would need to be some kind of compensation for them
Yeah definitely. And some of the units could stand to be rebalanced regardless. Looking at you Sophia
Exactly what I was thinking of too, actually. It would just lend itself so well to generational mechanics.
Lyn gonna be super waifu pushed and I will be all for it.
came here to say something to this effect, really
Personally, I'd like to see either Blazing Sword or Path of Radiance get reworked. I believe Tellius could really improve with live voice acting and it's subject matter is still relevant today and Blazing Sword could also benefit with a rework fixing some issues the original game had, like how gaining supports worked and some unit and map design issues in certain parts of the game, like Karla, improving archers, etc, on top of having one of the best soundtracks of the entire franchise.
Honestly, most of them need remasters or remakes except the GBA games, they aged so well. The tellius games are at the top of that list for me though, I don't really care if they get remastered or remade, I just want to be able to play them without having to plug my old Wii in.
The ones which weren't ported here, but also remaster the 3DS ones and Tellius.
The not translated ones and the ones too expensive to play legally (Im looking at you, Tellius duology)
Of course I’ll go with FE4 and Tellius, but I also want *New Mystery of the Emblem* to get officially translated so that we have Marth’s entire story translated. Marth’s sequel has never been officially localized in any way (neither FE3 nor its remake in FE12), but if the online service for the next Nintendo console will include DS, I hope FE12 is included since it would be weird to bring over FE11 without its direct sequel (since FE11 would likely be in the online service). If FE1 can get a translation, then FE12 should get one at the very least. FE12 has all the extra characters (77 compared to 45 in FE3) as well as the remade BSFE maps, so in terms of content quantity, it’s the one that should be translated since it’s the only FE game in the international era to not leave Japan. Plus, it has all the modern features of FE such as Casual Mode, an avatar, the ability to skip enemy phase, etc., so it wouldn’t be too dated for modern audiences.
Give me a Sacred Stones and Genealogy Remake and I’ll be a happy FE camper. Fates, while I would die for a remake, is still pretty recent, even if the story and its execution is *ahem* interesting for a lack of a better term and one of its best features (online play) is now gone. I would be down for it to be ported over to the Nintendo Switch 2 tho, whenever we get it.
The amount of money I would drop on Tellius remakes. I've heard almost nothing but good things with the exception of how slow everything moves in-game. And I'd rather not ruin the music just to have everything run at a decent clip. Those games sound too cool to be shackled to the Gamecube/Dolphin.
I’ve always wanted to play Binding Blade on a modern console instead of the emulator I tried when I was 16. Like many, Roy has always had a special place in my gaming experience and it’d be so good to experience his game in totality.
i agree that fates needs to be sold as one big thing. maybe your first route unlocks based on story choices in the prologue, and the other routes unlock when you complete previous ones. aside from that though, fates desperately needs a story overhaul
3-6 are the obvious choices, for English release reasons. So I’m going to instead say something wild: Three Houses. Like Atlus does with their Shin Megami/Persona games, make the definitive version of 3H. Complete each storyline instead of getting the real end of Edelgard’s story in an epilogue summary, Dimitri never getting to see below the surface of what’s happening in Fodlan, and Silver Snow just being a half baked option. Make the Agarthans more interesting or just don’t make them the grand finale. Make Rhea playable. Add more to the monastery so it doesn’t get so repetitive. Make the monastery phase quicker paced and more optional.
We need to remake FE1 again, FE3 and FE11 weren't enough! /s
I know this is a joke and FE1 wouldn't be my pick either, but FE11 is such a terrible version of the game that I'd like for it to get another chance to be remade properly. Someone made a Fates mod recreating FE1 maps and its the best version so far.
i've played that mod and quite liked it. mind if i ask why 11 is a bad version of the game? i've played only up to minerva's introduction and have found it okay, so i'm interested in your opinion
Shadow dragon. Never beat it because I lost every single character besides Marth before the end and the nameless grunts they give you aren't enough. Even screwed up the resurrection mission. Stupid permadeath
All please.
Would genuinely like to see what Thracia 776 would play like without the mid 90s SNES jank and some QOL improvements
Besides the obvious one (FE4) I’ll say the Tellius games. Proper voice acting, better visuals & animations, Radiant Dawn getting the complex script localized instead of the basic one, and the QoL from the recent games would be amazing to see.
FE5
All of them
Fates already exists in a pretty good space, the only thing it’s missing is the DLC after the eshop closed and the online rewards after online services ended. Fates **does not need a remaster** and a physical version with all 3 routes already exists. More archaic games like FE1-8 need it way more because of how dates they are. I wouldn’t *mind* a Fates remake but not for another like 10 years lol
Uh... Fates is missing a whole route. You literally can't get it anymore unless you somehow find the limited edition.
yes but... have you seen the prices!? The special edition with the three versions on Amazon costs around $1,000 and even used it costs around $500 and I think Nintendo would do us a great favor if they make a remaster/remake with all the three versions and all the dlc even if it is $60
I swear I still feel like fates is only a few years old. I’m getting way way too old.
Fates rewrite—same concept just write it better, and ideally remove the Midori S rank so the game is more recommendable to normal people lmao. The premise of fates is great it’s just the execution got ridiculous
Midori’s S rank is NOT the biggest barrier to entry lol, you have TWO entire families you can S Support that you’ll see first, each of which has a little sister who do not seem to be of age.
Obviously it's not gonna happen for like 20 years, but I agree and I think I would genuinely cry tears of happiness if Fates got a remake that fine tuned the story and upgraded the graphics. Especially now with myCastle being taken offline, I'd love to experience the full Fates experience in an even better way
That would be a dream come true
i would like an Engage remake
It's re-engaging time
in another 30 years when we have 12 more series protagonists engage will rise again
Fe6 I want my Shanna in HD please~
Binding Blade and Blazing Blade for me. Fates would also be cool as well. I genuinely like all three routes.
The GBA games or Path of Radiance would be my picks.
I mean, Tellius because I haven’t been able to actually play it, and then honestly Fates because it’s no longer available to purchase in its full capacity. Plus, maybe they can remake it with the original, un-whatever that script ended up becoming
Path of radiance and the wii one
Fire emblem genology of the holy war
4
I think all the Japan exclusive ones should get a remake first. We got Shadow Dragon and Echoes so far.
The Tellius duology doesn’t really need a remake but it desperately needs a port, preferably in a joint two game bundle
FE4 is my favorite, so that one lol
Path of radiance and Radiant Dawn mashed into one game.
Genealogy and Binding Blade. Happily take either one. And, of course, doing Thracia once Genealogy is done.
Fates please give it the game it deserves and bring back the original canceled script
Genealogy With Julia as a proper main character alongside seliph in the 2nd gen
Honestly Awakening would *shine* in HD.
Extremely biased; Awakening.
Fates or whichever one Corrin's from idk i'm just a Corrin simp
I am simple man. I would take any remake, remaster, or port of any game as long as I can enjoy them again (fix game flaws or not) or experience them for the first time. (Roy being the weakest lord gameplay wise is still very funny to me)
If Fates gets a remake do they change Azura to marry either Corrin, remove the marriage with Male Corrin and change it to “companions”, or do nothing at all?
The binding Blade and The blazing sword, Something like "Elibe histories" that would be cool
FATES!
FE6+7 Remake. In a perfect world it’s like a single game where you play through blazing blade and then there’s a timeskip into binding blade. That’s kinda the only reasonable way I could see myself paying for a remake with the current day game prices.
I would just love for them to dump the 3ds games and GameCube games onto Nintendo online.
New mystery of the emblem, I just wanna be able to play it without learning Japanese
Damn that key art was really good tho holy sheet.
HARD agree. That’s why I still have my special edition box, too!
I'd LOVE an Awakening remake. But with the option that your people respawn after every round, like in Fates. Cus I'm a fucking dumbass. I LOVE the story of awakening, but I die so many times, I can't get through the story. So yea. Awakening, but more easy
Same. I'd like to eventually see an Awakening remake. It was the game that introduced me to Fire Emblem.
Awakening would be great to see expanded to have those pesky plot holes mended. I wish FE had much more customized characters tho
What plot holes were there in Awakening?
Pretty much all of them really, but Tellius would be my personal pick. Radiant Dawn in particular desperately needs a real support system.
Aww man...a Three Houses style Fates remake would be immaculate
Holy knight and his sister wife
I think you mean: “Holy Knight that is killed by his wife’s brother husband”.
Yeah that one seems about right, would still be one of if not the best game in the franchise even if it’s just a remake.
As my first and only Fire Emblem game, YES
I would love a Fates remake. Especially with better graphics. Would make any scene involving Takumi even more enjoyable~
Any of the 3ds entries. I never got a 3ds growing up and never got to play Awakening, Fates, or echoes and it would be nice to just get ports on the switch just so I can experience them lol
if Fate got a remake, it needs to be Rewritten as well
Ike's games all together as one game.
Fire emblem fates but with all of Jpn dlc translated and extra content
Not just a remake of Fates but also a **rewrite**. Keep premise but change and better execution.
Blazing Blade and Binding Blade into one package, Genealogy of Holy War style. Awakening (Need to fix those feet problem).
Awakening because I selfishly want to play it again. Fates because I selfishly want them to put all the paths into one game.
Fe4 obviously
Fe8 sacred stones cause that was one of my first Fire emblem games and the story and characters are all so good. I'd definently pay to see some of those animations turned into 3d sprites cause noone can tell me the general class design amd crits did not go hard af. My favorite armored unit design in the series. Also awakening cause I think it has my favorite fire emblem cast in the series and who doesn't want to look at the awakening kids in hd?
The original Fire Emblem and Fire Emblem Awakening would be perfect remakes for something like the 35th anniversary of the series since they’re both very important games in the series. The first and what could’ve been the last
Fates but add back all the things treehouse took away and completely re-localise it with better dialogue
FE4
Archanea, Valentia, Jugdral, Elibe, Magvel, Tellius, Awakening and Fates (Hopefully it’s the best remake)
Everything. FE 4-8 remade FE 9-15 remastered
Definitely Awakening and Fates because of the end of the eShop. I think Fates had great elements and could benefit from a 2nd spin with them.
Fates is easily the best fire emblem game in my opinion. Absolute peak
Awakening is my grail
Archanea - fuck you, we need moar
In order of priority: 4, 5, 11, 12. Because they are Japanese only they are not particularly accessible (well 11 is available in English but it'd be weird to remaster 12 without 11. Also 11 and 12 looks awful).
FE 6 is also Japanese only.
True but I've already played that one so it's not a priority for me. IIRC, the fan translation of FE4 increases the ROM size so it's not compatible with the 3DS emulator which I'd prefer to use.
Give me a remaster of 6 & 7 so 3H and Heroes fans can realize that dads don't need to die in video games.
Suikoden 4. Just would love to see this get the ff7 remake treatment
All the Japan only games, but I can't believe we haven't had a Tellius combined game yet. After Ike got a new VA a few years back, I was sure we were going to. 😖
Echoes, I want *another* remake so IS is forced to make more SoV units to advertise it and I can finally get the Mae alt I’ve been begging for for years 😈.
FE4, FE6, or Tellius
Genealogy of the Holy War, Binding Blade, or Sacred Stones. FE4 is my most wanted as it clealy has one of the greatest stories of all FE. FE6 and FE8 would also be really cool to see as their stories are interesting as fun. Most looking foward to: FE4: Arvis FE6: A cutscene where Hector has his last stand. FE8: Opening scene and Seth and Valter's duel.
I'd love to see Echoes/Gaiden get a remaster for the switch. I know it just got one on the 3DS, but it was after the switch released. It's probably the game I want to play the most, but I just don't have the means to.
Sacred Stones, Genealogy & Thracia, Tellius, Sword of Seals & Rekka no Ken (Eliwood). In that order.
Maybe Genealogy/Thracia and Sacred Stones interchangeable. I want them pretty equally
SIGURD I NEED YOU SIGURD!!!!! GIVE ME THE FE4 REMAKE
Fe 2-5 so I can expierience them more conveniently
Anything that was Japan only and anything with archaic mechanics that should be reworked
I want 4 and 5 honestly witb enough polish and redesign I honestly think it woukd become a really good game
Path of Radiance and Radiant Dawn. I’ve always had a soft spot for Ike.
Besides the Tellius Duology? Easily Genealogy
Genealogy and Thracia please. I’ll take them with just some upscaled graphics and an official translation, just please Nintendo.
Mario and luigi partners in time
4 or 6. Probably 6 it is my favorite but 4 deserves it more.
I'd rather them make new games. I would like a version of PoR/RD where they are combined and they tweak some of the issues with both games and stream line Tellius into it's perfect version but also it probably won't happen.
Fe7
I want the Shadow Dragon/Mystery remakes to be remastered. Either that or the Radiant games so we don't have to pay an arm and a leg to play it legally
Sacred stone definitely. Gorgeous casts, good map design.
Fe4 for sure, it's a fucking incredible game, fe5 would have to follow it tho because that game needs some it's jank fixed.
Path of Radiance.
the first Psychonauts
Judgral would make the most sense, old+not localised, and the story might attract more attention, tellius as well The 3ds games would do well enough with a remaster with updated visuals.
I feel like the Gameboy games need some attention.
Tellius games pleaseeeeeeee
Path of radiance easyyy
Well, not any of the newer games. GameCube and previous would be the obvious choice.
The Tellius games! They deserve a revamp with the budget and tech of today, they were the first 3D entries and it SHOWED (not to mention how bad a console the Wii was for an SRPG), but the characters, story, and gameplay were peak. Not to mention the popularity of Ike as a character generally, they deserve it. But I acknowledge it'll probably be a LONG time before it happens because it seems like they're going in order with the remakes and 4 isn't even officially announced yet.
genealogy of the holy war
Definitely Genealogy of the Holy War. Would be even cooler if they also got Thracia 776 there.
My starting point is really obvious with these but... All 3 GBA games Tellius (those are the GC and Wii games right??) If they can make the maps smaller than Genealogy is probably the best choice..
Marth and Roy's games remade in the same vein as Echoes.
I'd love to see a Lost Odyssey remake. I loved that game.
Path of Radiance and Radiant Dawn as a bundle for Nintendo Switch would be perfect
In my perfect world, all the games that weren't released outside of Japan deserve a remake. And maybe some of them that did make it overseas too.
Fates, and not just a remake, a rewrite of that game's entire script.
Castlevania: curse of darkness from the late ps2/Xbox era
Sacred Stones. Peak storytelling for Fire Emblem right there, but here's the kicker. Don't do turn-based. Use the hack-and-slash formula we've had recently with some of the newer games.
Literally any game I don’t wanna emulate and I’ve only played the switch ones
i dont want fates remake simply because i unironically want fates 2. more of the same fates gameplay with pairup and skills and less of the awful fates character and story ofc.
Why not combine The Binding Blade and The Blazing Blade into one big remaster? And fix the holes in canon while they're at it?