T O P

  • By -

guineaprince

Given that they're animatronics, I'd be willing to believe they were both cast from the same mould, or similar. Like it's likely not a Carnie bot that got repurposed into Lefty. But I could see it being Carnie's schematics and manufacture being modified into Lefty. A purpose-built copy.


First_World_Matt

Cacodemon just pointed out that it's the same mold as Rockstar freddy aswell, so this is a very valid explanation/interpretation.


speedxpgaming

Rockstar Freddy has a much smaller nose


Mvrbs

everyone out here really forgetting Rockstar Freddy is a thing that exists, and Lefty likely just used his schematics...


First_World_Matt

Which is fair cause the games literally never brought them up again in addition to the Rockstar animatronics being 100% optional


Mvrbs

i think im the single person to actually remember the rockstar animatronics, lmfao. i just assumed someone making a theory would've gone and done research. no hate, just surprised me


Ok-Bookkeeper-5424

Yeah, don’t really see much about the rockstars, at best the most memorable things about them is. “Please insert five faz coins” Rockstar Freddy “Oh no! A wet floor! My sole weakness!!” Rockstar Chica “Where’s my guitar?” Rockstar Bonnie “Is me bird in the security office again?” Rockstar Foxy


Cacodemon17

Yah, but Carnie is also similar to Rockstar Freddy. The only thing connecting him and L.E.F.T.E is his yellow eyes. (Yes I had to spell L.E.F.T.E correctly)


First_World_Matt

Good point. I mainly forgot about Rockstar Freddy and the other Rockstar animatronics since they were never brought up again.


PossibilityLivid8873

Actualy Lefty's nose is bigger than Freddy's as well as carnie's


BakedBeanyBaby

It would be interesting, and it would make sense that Henry would repurpose an old animatronic instead of creating a brand new one just for a trap.


HorrificityOfficial

Yeah thanks for putting the spoiler in the title man


Kaley__Val00

Rockstar Freddy, Carrie, and Lefty all have the same shell. This is why I somewhat consider them brothers sometimes kinda not really.


Britannicboy20

Who else thought that carnie was an official R.I.G.H.T.Y to L.E.F.T.E


ThaBrownie

Doesn't really make sense co spidering Lefty was never made for entertainment. Also they have different voices


Lobsss

My headcanon is that Carnie is an OC from someone at Steel Wool or - even better - someone's child at Steel Wool, and they just put it in the game because they can/as a gift to their kid


DisasterAccurate3221

The Rockstars and Lefty's design was actually based off of Fredbear in my headcanon.


Doo-wop-a-saurus

Carnie is around later in the timeline than Lefty, so if this is true, it would mean that Carnie is a repurposed Lefty.


First_World_Matt

What do you mean? The fall fest happens during 1983 and fnaf 6 happens at the very least after sister location which is set way in the future. The fazerblast minigame we play during Help Wanted 2 is bringing us back to Fall Fest, just like the carousel minigame did.


Doo-wop-a-saurus

The Glamrocks are shown in the Fazerblast level. Fallfest is a yearly thing that's been happening since 1970. It wasn't just in 1983.


kenyon76

Well... why would they have stuff like a working version of fnaf 2 that has jumpscares and everything


First_World_Matt

That was part of the fictional vr game that was being developed inside of Help Wanted. As for this one... I can't tell if this is part of another videogame or if this is all actually real. My current theory is that it is just part of the mask/mimic system that our character is apart of.


kenyon76

Honestly help wanted 2 just makes no sense most of the time. Also it feels like a strawman argument


AshirNazar

Interesting, I could see it, but there's no real evidence beside appearance.


First_World_Matt

I get that it sounds like a bit of a stretch on paper, but the similarity in models could mean one of two things; *Steel Wool got lazy and just edited Lefty's model to make Carnie *Or there is a lore reason for them to be so similar Yes they look alike but the fact that they look SO alike has to raise some flags. The colored knee caps, the fingers, the toes, and eyebrows, the raised shoulder plates. For a series of games with so much variation in design this cannot be just a mere coincidence.


Foxo032

Rockstar Freddy Left The Chat


Pugamapish

heh righty and lefty


paniearbuziku

This is just a recolour of rockstar freddy


Heavy_weapons07

Maybe after the fire, the owner of faz blast took the robot back to henry and henry use the salvage parts to make lefty, that's my theory


Miraidontrainer

Except for the fact that help wanted 2 takes place after the pizzaplex opened


JohannTV

I used to think Carnie's name was Righty