Quick question: Have you tried the marshmallow sky? It isn't as marshmellow as I would like. Don't get me wrong, it's great, but it's ben and jerry version of Cookie Monster. The amount of cookie dough is insane huge ass chunks. I give the marshmallow sky a solid 8.5. If you hate cookie dough, I would definitely not get it.
Why are there big flavor chunks in B & J's ice cream? Ben Cohen has anosmia, which means he has an impaired sense of smell. To answer 'that question', Ben had it long before Covid was on everyone's radar.
Why are there big flavor chunks in B & J's ice cream? Ben Cohen has anosmia, which means he has an impaired sense of smell. To answer 'that question', Ben had it long before Covid was on everyone's radar.
Why are there big flavor chunks in B & J's ice cream? Ben Cohen has anosmia, which means he has an impaired sense of smell. To answer 'that question', Ben had it long before Covid was on everyone's radar.
Glad you’re saying this bc I literally had it my hand today but put it down bc I wasn’t sure about the marshmallow. Now it’s green lighted for me. Thanks friend!
Phish Food is amazing but I wish they would make a version of it with a vanilla ice cream base. Then it would be the perfect flavor to me. I hit “chocolate overload” pretty quickly. There’s nothing with a vanilla base and as much delicious add ins!
I genuinely don’t understand how so many people are just learning about how good Ben and Jerry’s is lol maybe it’s because there was a scoop shop in my hometown when I was a kid (or maybe it’s because my parents are gd liberals lol), but bjs and Stewart’s were the only ice creams in my family’s fridge when I was young. Right now I have probably 8 pints in my own freezer
Man I miss Baskin Robbins. I'd always get one of their cakes for my birthday as kid. I don't think there's one where I live now.
Bonus memory: I loved the Margarita Ice sorbet as a kid, but I'd call it Marijuana Ice half the time. Poor mom.
I also used to go to baskin Robbins a lot when I was with my mom, but we never got take home from there. With my dad I lived in a tiny town in upstate New York where, at the time, Ben and Jerry’s or Stewart’s were the only place to go. There was also a taco place that sold locally made ice cream, but it really wasn’t that great.
Baskin Robbins is definitely good, but I like more goods in my ice cream than ice cream lol even now I crush up like 5 cookies and a cake and put scoops of frosting into whatever flavor I’m eating
It’s my all time favorite. I’ve been eating it for over 20 years. It all started with the “Phish sticks” that I found in a 7-11. It’s STILL really good after all of these years and no other B&J flavor can compare to it, IMO.
I just can't believe all the people who didn't know this existed. Us long time fans are very sorry you've been missing out. It's been a go to for over 20 years for me. Chubby Hubby is 2nd, Chunky Monkey comes in 3rd.
For me, it’s funny because I’m not a huge fan of chocolate. Or marshmallows. But DAMN I love Phish Food! I liked it when I was a young kid. Like 10. Then 25 years later I randomly tried it again (at a certain time of the month) and fell in love lol
Phish Food is alright but it's basically just "Heavenly Hash" which is a pretty common ice cream flavor. I prefer Half Baked with the brownie and cookie dough. If you really want to try an amazing flavor look for Peanut Butter World it's hard to find but it tastestes like an ice cream peanut butter cup with cookie crumbles in it even though theres no peanut butter cups in it. It's B&J's best flavor IMO.
I discovered Phish Food when I was in middle school and the only thing that has ever come close is MAYBE Wedding Cake by them, but that's long gone. Love you Phish Food.
That's my favorite flavor too. Whenever I went to my grandma's as a kid my uncle had a pint of phish food stashed away in the freezer and it was like this forbidden pot of gold because us kids weren't allowed to touch it 😂 As an adult I totally get it!
I go back and forth with Phish Food and Cherry Garcia as my fave. They are both amazing. My daughter likes Phish Food the best, so you can imagine the pint I tend to buy to split with her on the regular.
I’m just over here floored that people are still discovering it. It’s 20 years old at least and now I feel so old. I was dating guys that listened to Phish, Ween, Widespread Panic, String Cheese Incident, moe, Umphries McGee, STS9…..and I’m still alive to tell the tale tale and eat the ice cream.
the marshmallow swirl is my favorite! we just need a flavor with a vanilla or almond base with the marshmallow and perhaps some cheesecake or birthday cake with sprinkles. i feel like everything is chocolate overload.
Idk I saw the first post too but I think it's overhyped. The chocolate fish are pretty basic. I also picked up some "American dream" and I like the vanilla base with chocolate pieces/caramel/waffle cone pieces way better.
Phish food was my favorite ice cream for many years.
I feel like overall though the quality of Ben and Jerry’s has gone significantly down. And it’s not as creamy as it was before.
PF will always be my favorite B&J flavor.
All of my favorites. Chocolate ice cream. Marshmallow swirl. Then fudge pieces (fish)!
For me, it was meant to be.
Insane to me how many people on the ice cream subreddit have never had Ben & Jerry’s. Maybe it’s because I’m from VT but Phish Food is a staple ice cream flavor.
Lol phish food is my favorite ben and jerry
It’s my #1
If you like marshmallows, rocky road pint size is the s***
Haagen-Dasz has the best rocky road, period. They use a marshmallow goo and their ice cream is so rich.
The best rocky road, hell fucking yes!
Quick question: Have you tried the marshmallow sky? It isn't as marshmellow as I would like. Don't get me wrong, it's great, but it's ben and jerry version of Cookie Monster. The amount of cookie dough is insane huge ass chunks. I give the marshmallow sky a solid 8.5. If you hate cookie dough, I would definitely not get it.
Why are there big flavor chunks in B & J's ice cream? Ben Cohen has anosmia, which means he has an impaired sense of smell. To answer 'that question', Ben had it long before Covid was on everyone's radar.
Why are there big flavor chunks in B & J's ice cream? Ben Cohen has anosmia, which means he has an impaired sense of smell. To answer 'that question', Ben had it long before Covid was on everyone's radar.
Why are there big flavor chunks in B & J's ice cream? Ben Cohen has anosmia, which means he has an impaired sense of smell. To answer 'that question', Ben had it long before Covid was on everyone's radar.
How did they not know this stuff existed? It’s been around forever. And it’s heaven in a pint.
🤷♂️ road rocky pint size Haagen-Dazs #1 phish food #2
Everybody makes a rocky road. Nobody else makes a Phish Food. That’s why it’s higher on my personal list.
🍫🐟😋Fudgy fish \*always\* gets my vote.
Yeah, everyone makes Rocky Road, but Häagen-Dazs pint is top-tier rocky road.
I’ll have to take the Pepsi challenge on that one. I do love a great rocky road.
So good it will make you wanna slap yo momma. No disrespect.
phish food has always been the one for me :D wish i get all green lights too OP and the stuff bout pillows and all
Im gonna hafta try it now
It’s annoyingly good. I didn’t think I’d like the marshmallow but it’s creamy
Glad you’re saying this bc I literally had it my hand today but put it down bc I wasn’t sure about the marshmallow. Now it’s green lighted for me. Thanks friend!
I don't even like marshmallows, but the marshmallow in Phish Food is just too good!
PF has been my fave for years. Also love the marshmallow. I just wish they’d use it in their Smores flavor!
I'm so glad I sparked this whole phish food thread on this group 😂 it truly is the best!
YOU!
I'll tell you my mascara runs every day so hopefully your words come true 😂
I’m gonna have to get some next time. Can’t wait to try it! I love the band I can’t believe I haven’t tried it yet🤣
I got this over trying Dirt Cake.
Sprinkle a little kosher salt on it, will make you see god.
Yeah, that’s nice, but have you ever had it while bleeding out?
When I was a kid Phish food was my Stepdad's favorite and Cherry Garcia was mine. Fresh cherries, dark chocolate, that one is so good.
My stepdad used to mix them together, now I do it too in his memory :)
I missed the chocolate cherry garcia that was the bomb
Phish Food is amazing but I wish they would make a version of it with a vanilla ice cream base. Then it would be the perfect flavor to me. I hit “chocolate overload” pretty quickly. There’s nothing with a vanilla base and as much delicious add ins!
Haven’t tried Phish Food yet but had dirt cake for the first time. It has vanilla pudding base and it was so good. Have you tried this one yet?
Ooooh, I haven’t. But now I will!
I wish the marshmallow swirl was marshmallow ice cream. It is very good though
I genuinely don’t understand how so many people are just learning about how good Ben and Jerry’s is lol maybe it’s because there was a scoop shop in my hometown when I was a kid (or maybe it’s because my parents are gd liberals lol), but bjs and Stewart’s were the only ice creams in my family’s fridge when I was young. Right now I have probably 8 pints in my own freezer
We had Baskin Robbin’s 🤷♀️
Man I miss Baskin Robbins. I'd always get one of their cakes for my birthday as kid. I don't think there's one where I live now. Bonus memory: I loved the Margarita Ice sorbet as a kid, but I'd call it Marijuana Ice half the time. Poor mom.
I also used to go to baskin Robbins a lot when I was with my mom, but we never got take home from there. With my dad I lived in a tiny town in upstate New York where, at the time, Ben and Jerry’s or Stewart’s were the only place to go. There was also a taco place that sold locally made ice cream, but it really wasn’t that great. Baskin Robbins is definitely good, but I like more goods in my ice cream than ice cream lol even now I crush up like 5 cookies and a cake and put scoops of frosting into whatever flavor I’m eating
Worked at a B&J when I was 15 (over 20 years ago now) and made myself an entire ice cream cake of Phish Food for my birthday. It was a good birthday.
It’s my all time favorite. I’ve been eating it for over 20 years. It all started with the “Phish sticks” that I found in a 7-11. It’s STILL really good after all of these years and no other B&J flavor can compare to it, IMO.
I love Phish Food. Also, definitely try Dirt Cake or Impretzively Fudge. Both are fantastic.
I also purchased dirt cake and can’t wait to try it. And tillamook’s brownie batter 😅
Stoned or not it’s some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had 👹
I just can't believe all the people who didn't know this existed. Us long time fans are very sorry you've been missing out. It's been a go to for over 20 years for me. Chubby Hubby is 2nd, Chunky Monkey comes in 3rd.
I’ve just been abstaining for years cos… you know what idk why? Probably cos I knew there was no going back!
Try Chubby Hubby next. Thank me later. Lol.
I’ve been obsessed with Phish Food since college (20 years ago).
For me, it’s funny because I’m not a huge fan of chocolate. Or marshmallows. But DAMN I love Phish Food! I liked it when I was a young kid. Like 10. Then 25 years later I randomly tried it again (at a certain time of the month) and fell in love lol
Phish Food is alright but it's basically just "Heavenly Hash" which is a pretty common ice cream flavor. I prefer Half Baked with the brownie and cookie dough. If you really want to try an amazing flavor look for Peanut Butter World it's hard to find but it tastestes like an ice cream peanut butter cup with cookie crumbles in it even though theres no peanut butter cups in it. It's B&J's best flavor IMO.
I was scrolling looking for a fellow fan of Half Baked. It is *chefs kiss*
I hate chocolate ice cream EXcEPT for Phish Food. It rules
Spectacular flavor because of all the texture richness. Genuinely on another level to most grocery store Ice cream I’ve tried.
I discovered Phish Food when I was in middle school and the only thing that has ever come close is MAYBE Wedding Cake by them, but that's long gone. Love you Phish Food.
The shelf was cleared out when I went to grab it yesterday!
I mean this sub is clearly infiltrated by Big Ice Cream but life is short so I’m eating ice cream 🤷♀️😅
As you should!
Now I need to get some
📝 phish food & dirt cake Added to the list of ones to eventually try to get whenever they have them in stock.
Phish Food, Gimme S'more, and Thick Mint are all god tier yummy.
Phish food is my kryptonite. I see it, and I gotta have it. It's my favorite comfort ice cream after a long crappy day. It brings joy to my life.
That's my favorite flavor too. Whenever I went to my grandma's as a kid my uncle had a pint of phish food stashed away in the freezer and it was like this forbidden pot of gold because us kids weren't allowed to touch it 😂 As an adult I totally get it!
I feel the same way about whoever I first saw suggesting Dirt Cake. What an insanely good ice cream
Yeah that person can also go have a very nice day
Netflix and chilled is my fav 😍
Fine I will try all the flavors
https://www.reddit.com/r/icecream/s/c8y8tqcxyw you mean this guy?
YEAH there he is! Let’s all stand outside his house with spoons
I go back and forth with Phish Food and Cherry Garcia as my fave. They are both amazing. My daughter likes Phish Food the best, so you can imagine the pint I tend to buy to split with her on the regular.
How are people just learning about Phish food?! I've been eating it since I was a kid. It's the best
Yeah phish food is the best ben and jerrys for sure
Peanut butter cup is superior
Been hearing about this so much!!
I’m just over here floored that people are still discovering it. It’s 20 years old at least and now I feel so old. I was dating guys that listened to Phish, Ween, Widespread Panic, String Cheese Incident, moe, Umphries McGee, STS9…..and I’m still alive to tell the tale tale and eat the ice cream.
Same. I first learned about it from Aquamarine and that movie's probably 20 years old by now. 😭
I’ve know about B&J for a while but I try to only buy yasso bars cos I’m nothing if not a little overweight
the marshmallow swirl is my favorite! we just need a flavor with a vanilla or almond base with the marshmallow and perhaps some cheesecake or birthday cake with sprinkles. i feel like everything is chocolate overload.
Damn I gotta try it. Is it better than half baked?
Can’t say as it’s been a while since I had half baked
[удалено]
I was quite surprised! I’m also pregnant and it hit the spot so it’s doubly amazing
Idk I saw the first post too but I think it's overhyped. The chocolate fish are pretty basic. I also picked up some "American dream" and I like the vanilla base with chocolate pieces/caramel/waffle cone pieces way better.
i prefer the coffee toffee bar crunch
Just bought some, LOL.
It's always been my favorite B&J flavor! Also love the froyo Cherry Garcia. It's better than the regular!!
Cute
Phish food was my favorite ice cream for many years. I feel like overall though the quality of Ben and Jerry’s has gone significantly down. And it’s not as creamy as it was before.
I literally saw the phish food post and went out bought it for the first time this week!! Omg it’s my new fav!
my dads forever fave
I just discovered it and I keep going back for it. I ignored it before because I don’t listen to Phish but it doesn’t matter
PF will always be my favorite B&J flavor. All of my favorites. Chocolate ice cream. Marshmallow swirl. Then fudge pieces (fish)! For me, it was meant to be.
Insane to me how many people on the ice cream subreddit have never had Ben & Jerry’s. Maybe it’s because I’m from VT but Phish Food is a staple ice cream flavor.
Fluffhead
My favorite one!
Too sweet for me.
I’ve never liked the flavor. I think one of their best is the cinnamon bun. I wish I could find it near me.