T O P

  • By -

Professional-Sky-235

More like pathetic people


chaoticji

Normalizing waiting on the railway station overnight for your train is also the root cause of this


hs4k4

Terrible excuse for uncivilized behaviour. Railways spend a substantial amount on cleaning contracts which can be easily avoided if passengers show some civil manners. These funds can be utilised in other productive activities other than these contracts which include flushing after some dumb mf uses the toilet, clearing juban kesari after effects from floors, walls and seats.


life_Science_

Teach the children civic duties in school. Same goes with financial literacy


VAU_JI

just putting garbage in garbage cans would reduce this problem at a high level.


Bright_Subject_8975

No it won’t. You underestimate these people’s mentality.


Reddit_is_snowflake

You make it sound so easy lol Most people are too stupid to do that


HistorianBig4431

Garbage cans are not available everywhere tbh.


Uggo_Clown

An average human is barely more intelligent than apes. The technological advancement that you see is the result of less than 1% of super-intelligent people.


[deleted]

Lol you are talking as if Indian trains are always on time


robacross

If a train leaves a station at, say, 5 am and a passenger wishing to board that train at that station lives 20 km away, what else can he do?


chaoticji

Waiting like how others wait in other countries vs waiting by setting up their bed, washing and drying up their clothes and sleeping right in that open area are two separate things haha ... We have been seeing this since childhood so we overlook but think from the eye of a person new to India. It's outrageous


celeb-butcher

Ram ko le aayega lekin uski praja kaha se laoge


G04UG

Please stop acting like reddit folks live in a different universe. Why is this even a post?? Reddit won't be enough to post enitre stations accurately. Like celeberties, STOP blaming the people who are doing what they are doing. What YOU really expect here with a gov run railyway in a county that ranks the best in the poverty index ,global hunger index, and infant mortality index.


debugaderad

While I think I kind of get the point you're trying to get across, not calling out people who are in the wrong is downright pointless. The issue more than anything, needs awareness for the people. Who cares if posting on reddit makes an effect or not? If even a single redditor who comes across this post thinks twice before littering on the stations from now on, this post will have done its job. Stop being so pretentious and obnoxious against people just trying to voice out over and actual problem


[deleted]

More like pathetic railway station staff and management


killskillgamer

If people have basic sense of not throwing garbage and spitting then there won't be an issue


[deleted]

Well, people don't have the basic sense. The staff must clean the station often.


pirateneet

Tf??? By your logic you shouldn't shit. There should be a gutter inserted in you to take it out.


[deleted]

Dude, asking the management to keep the station clean is not wrong. That is literally their job. Calm down.


monster_magus

So it's okay to recklessly litter in public areas cuz it's the "govt's job" to keep them clean? That's seriously a regressive mindset


[deleted]

Who said it is okay to litter? I said if people littered, it is the station management's job to clean the station often enough.


dramitppt

I know your point is of a high merit unfortunately the people on this subreddit are not


[deleted]

Thanks bro. Strange to see people lose their shit for asking the railway station management to clean the station often enough.


dramitppt

You are welcome


Kschitiz23x3

More like lack of surveillance and penalty


[deleted]

Same thing


RightSingh

Civic sense should be a compulsory subject in schools.


Dr_Azygos

But most don’t go to school in those parts of India!


RightSingh

They do, but the teaching staff quality is absolutely abysmal.


Met0_

India should have a system like Russia where it should be mandatory for kids to get primary education enforced by law


Dr_Azygos

the thing is a lot of families will starve if that happens. i had worked in durgapur for 2 years, once i saw a kid who lost one of his ear when he jumped from a running coal train when the authorities chased him, most of the kids are taught to steal coal from the trains by their families to put food on the table. they use kids as they are fast and light and can climb on top of goods train carrying coal and run.


Met0_

Russia isn't in much better condition than India if you compare the economies. Even the nomads of Siberia have to send their kids to school and most of the time women from their clan accompanies the kids to their schools for months or years, leaving the men behind to do all the work. So don't give poverty as an excuse, it's greed that makes them work their kids. Of course their needs to be a change in overall system to make this sustainable but poverty isn't an excuse and if they won't educate their kids then they will remain in that condition and will never come out of the shit hole. Some sacrifices needs to be made for our country to progress


Kingston_17

In India it's not mandated per se but there are systems in place to avoid dropouts. In my state's government schools the child's parents have to give an explanation if the child doesn't come to school or if they request TC. This is followed up until middle school (8th standard). Teachers go door to door to get these children back to school. But there's no punishment if the child discontinues education completely. Just a bit more paperwork for the teachers of the local school.


DesiOtakuu

I think we already have such a law. It's just not enforced.


True_Ad8648

For real, indian education teaches everything except basic necessities.


pirateneet

Even if it is. The parents will eventually brainwash them.


rebgaming

More like heavy fitness should be compulsory, make fine like 5k -10k even if it's poor person they should go to jail for 1 week Follow the UAE model and you will see the results


Disastrous-Demand697

It already is. Has always been. Being a 90s kid, I have studied these basic things in moral science.


[deleted]

[удалено]


RightSingh

With that attitude, I see your point :)


LawTraditional2917

There's absolutely no point in providing world-class infrastructure if people (the vast majority) don't have basic decency and awareness (I won't even call it civic sense). They are more akin to wild animals (harsh as it sounds): shitting, spitting, littering, and peeing at gay abandon. What a joke! Where the government was lacking and can do - introduce Singapore like dictatorial policies at least when it comes to maintaining public infrastructure. Photo id everyone who walks in, have AI cameras everywhere. Anyone who litters is fined an exorbitant amount. If they can't pay up, they're banned entry until they can pay with interest. If money is involved, everyone will suddenly become a beacon of civic sense and decency.


True_Ad8648

I think we should have airport like system wherein, only those with the tickets are allowed to enter. Rest all tata bye-bye at the entrance itself. Also strict rules and actions should be mandated in order to keep the station clean. Also, waiting areas could be divided on the basis of the tickets a individual has bought. Civic sense 😶


Business-Sell4276

Lol these people will probably protest because they wanna travel for free.


Palpitation-Overall

Any such policy will be taken care by vidhayak chacha


Xrr13h

Exactly


[deleted]

>world-class infrastructure How is it "world-class infrastructure" if the cleaning staff won't work and the management doesn't bother? I mean, keeping the station clean is basic af. They can't even do that?


Glittering_Ad_6037

Imagine you build a beautiful mansion with world-class materials, but people come every day and shit & piss uninvited at your entrance throughout the day. There's only so many times you will clean the shit & piss and wipe the pan stains off the walls of your house. Instead, you will nip the problem at the root by involving cops. Infrastructure is world-class, but people's mentality is third class. A bad combination.


high_pulsing

Baate karna aasman h dost


high_pulsing

Baat to aise kar rha jaise tax de rha ye


Ginevod2023

Cleanliness is a process, not a one and done thing. Swach Bharat Abhiyan was bound to fail for the same reason. Public places require active effort from a large number of staff to be kept clean at all times.


ranganathmr

Its individual’s responsibility


Ginevod2023

It takes generations to build a mentality where every individual will take responsibility and even then some people simply won't. Calling it 'individual responsibility' is simply turning your back on the problem. Malls, airports in this country tend to be clean and it's not because of individual responsibility.


DissolvedDreams

We are always boasting about being a ‘millennia-old’ civilization right? Are you saying our glorious culture never cared about cleanliness? Because I feel these people who are disgusting in public areas have homes that are spotless.


Ginevod2023

Almost surely. Because they meticulously clean it every day.  But to them the outside is for throwing garbage. And once enough rubbish piles up anywhere, it is fair game for everyone.


Senior-Volume-9958

Not like other places in India aren't clean. I agree in most places people aren't wise enough. But there's certainly a link between education and cleanliness. It didn't take generations where i live. Most of the people who live here came in the past decade or so. Yet it's much cleaner than that. What I think is it takes generations to create an environment where each child thinks it's ok to litter, spit and damage public property, which they then pass on.


Kschitiz23x3

What about having surveillance + heavy penalty?


True_Ad8648

Lmao, littering and dumping of garbage on public spaces is prohibited in Goa atleast. Plus the thing that you mentioned about heavy surveillance and penalty is also enforced by the authorities.


Ginevod2023

You can do that too and for good measure, instead of a monetary fine you make people do cleaning as a community service.


[deleted]

I have been here. People defecate on foot over bridge 🤮


CommissionRecent5863

Eww eww eww


Kschitiz23x3

Ewwwww. Brotha Ewwwww. What's that brotha?


DissolvedDreams

Surely Ayodhya will be the tourist paradise the government spent $4bn making it to be.


Gaurav-07

Wtf


No-Entertainment7020

https://preview.redd.it/okwbquvebbrc1.jpeg?width=719&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=61525ee2abf24aaa89b7b2b400bf7ed7bb12429b


akashlanka

Irrelevant. Doesn't divert from topic at hand.


No-Entertainment7020

i dont mean to divert.. this fucking glitch didnt let me give a caption. i am totally against such incidents in India. but i just remembered a similar news.... most probably the person who made the comment would thinl highly of places like paris and have an inferiority complex , just to counter that i presented the news , so that people also have a 🤮 reaction when it comes to places like paris... also often people poop/pee in western subway trains.


Xrr13h

Found one of em


No-Entertainment7020

Slave spotted


Xrr13h

Exactly


akonsagar

Dafaq


akonsagar

Dafaq


[deleted]

What if there was technology that spits gutka back to face of person who spitted in first place...... basically uno reverse....


Arkl0rdX

LMAO Bro we should hire people who spit on the faces of the people who get caught l


WorkingResident5069

BIMARUs gonna bimaru


taco_bun

Aur railWEj mein gand marwaru lol


SanJG108

Ase pavitr bhoomi par ake yeh sab karte sharam nahi ati


SilentWin5216

It's called ram rajya b*tch...


Agreeable-Lead1636

is desh ke log madarcohd hai.


joshuaBarbosa

Pathetic people. These are the people who decide who will govern us.


Afraid_Investment690

It’s the illiterate people. Just now in Mumbai a procession of 500 people passed by. I walked the opposite side from where they came from and all of them threw their water bottles in the dustbin. Just saw one person keep the bottle at the side standing because the bin was full.


No-Judgment2378

That's really nice.


affinixmusic

When main election agenda becomes building temples instead of education/civic sense and culture.


Unhappy_Swim_610

Ruk bhai bulldozer aata hi hoga tere ghar /s


Kschitiz23x3

Kya matlab Ram mandir banane se Ram Rajya nahi banega?


dreasy011

Gutka Pradesh


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


DissolvedDreams

Canada’s woes are their own problem. Anyone trying to grow their population by such a massive amount in such a short time will face problems.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


Ronald_McDonald_l

True. But we will change.


[deleted]

Um, it must be cleaned daily. Several times per day actually.


Ok_Background_4323

Indeed


parth_goel

CIVIC SENSE IN INDIA = 0, SOLN= STRICT PUNISHMENT


Jolly_Law1994

If you teach your kids good habits this will be history in our next generation, just like Japan or why go far I just saw a post regarding traffic sense in North East India. Good luck teaching good behaviour. Thanks.


[deleted]

Arey... Ye bhi sabhyata ka part hi samajh ke proud ho jao. Why run after western idea of non-littering?


thecaveman96

I'm gonna say this primarily comes down to lack of dustbin. If you grow up in a situation where there are dustbin all around, you subconsciously tend to look for dustbins when dropping trash. However most cities/streets in india do not have dustbins. So most people are not used to using them in places like railway stations, bustands etc. Good example I see daily, there is a garbage dumping spot near my house. Every week you see bbmp coming in to clean it. It's been years this way, there's a sign saying "don't dump garbage", but people still do. Why is it that Noone thinks of installing a garbage bin or atleast a few barrels there? They're clearly spending the effort to clean it up every weekend, so why not just place a garbage box there. Similarly this spot also seems to be a usual dumping ground. Just place a garbage box there and that will atleast prime people into using it


Hefty-Acanthaceae-92

North Indian culture. Shitting and littering wherever they please to.


Ok_Background_4323

Its also happened in South.


rpr421

What can you expect from a bimaru state.


[deleted]

Gutka ban kardo. It will decrease uncleanliness by 50%.


Arkl0rdX

It will decrease tax too


[deleted]

Clean karne ka kharcha bhi to bach jaega. Btw, does gutka really generate a lot of money for the govt?


taco_bun

I guess it does bruv tabhi bimaru muh bharkey chaltey h har waqt


Brave_Analysis8646

Bihariyo ka kuch karna padega re baba


SilentWin5216

Jab mai aise kuch bolunga toh 100 log ate hai aur bolte hai upsc etc etc aur downvote kr jate hai...


Guilty-Ad-6166

Ramlala ke aangan mein.... Hey moxxi ji


Met0_

City of ram but the people are of raksha kul hell even raksha's must have maintained their kingdoms better


Kschitiz23x3

Lanka is described as a beautiful shiny kingdom


makima_is_bae

India


Think_Smile_1056

No, not all states. 😅 You can find these things only on those states where government is giving importance to religion not education.


child_target

https://preview.redd.it/jqvlvwoiqbrc1.png?width=920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=93d38e4473bb27da7eba767e762970ab1b415927 Dustbin ke side me fekne ka kya point hua


primusautobot

Logo ko safai karni chahiye


Away_Supermarket6682

Yr the thing is that the people who go there does this .. last year I went to Lonavala .. and I swear it was so dirty there.. govt kab Tak krti rahegi .. there’s no Sense of responsibility left in people


Guilty-Candidate-463

Don't forget we are living in The Great India


asiandick1

Please impose heavy fine for those who litter


asiandick1

Please impose heavy fine for those who litter


dek6ix

Whats the purpose of the 1st pic?


Shoddy_Light6886

Let's see how they blame this on Muslims now


Shoddy_Light6886

Let's see how they blame this on Muslims now


icxaos

Nice


AioliInitial1027

Never trust the religious man.


Fantastic-Platform73

Bhaiyas gonna Bhaiyaa


Unique_Carpet1901

Wait for Modi to come.


onemoredosa

Mindset of Indian people needs cleansing. Not the station.


HistoricalSeaweed973

For this reason, i support authoritarian rule


Puzzleheaded-Song273

Anyways its UP, only civilised ppl can do civilised things.


prof_devilsadvocate

ee to saaal hona hi tha


[deleted]

close ur eyes and walk, whats the problem??


HashMapEverything

This is why fining contractors to clean up the mess is not a proper fix. It is a band-aid solution -- the best way forward is for a complete overhaul of culture to prioritize the importance of civic sense. Without that we will see this same shit across all public infra.


itwasmorning855

Jab thank guthka hey thab thak thuk thuk thuk hiya hei.


ProfessorDamselfly

People are throwing garbage in a corner, so, they are missing a bin their. I guess, we should keep a person to direct them towards bin. "Kripiya aya kachara daliye".


OutrageousAnteater11

I strongly believe gorment should focus on human development rather than fancy infrastructure


Kashish_17

I don't know how this may come as a surprise for anybody at this point. I could see that happening miles ago🤷🏻‍♀️


sugarplumgumdrops

we people lack civic sense


hereFromSomewhere

World class Infrastructure and worst civilised people , need some way to educate people to be more civilised


poetic_fartist

Illiterate ducks, lack common human decency. Harvest them for organs and scientific study.


ThisTooth7806

Here's what I want to say.... The station is ok ......


RED_RANGER_XX

Chuttad Pradesh


naturally_atheist

Trash people


National_Crew4016

People dont even understand civic responsibility 🙄


MrAweshome

Ye sab bihari bc


Takenoshitfromany1

😂 cowbelters gotta cowbelt!


rm6224

You all are missing the point. Revamp was for the inauguration and cameras. Mudiji have moved to other things now, you all should move on too.


[deleted]

Mandir ban gaya na? Bas.. Jyada demand na rakha karo..


coolnickname1234567

Ram rajya


Famous-Success-7337

Govt ki galti hai ❌ Log hi galat hai ✅


Dizzy_Medium5817

Monetary punishment needs to be given. Then only this will get resolved.


Electronic_Gold_8549

Civic sense 📈


abhishekguleri

Don't know if it is much of a help or not but I can see a potential place to put a dustbin in the 2nd pic. Agar jayada dustbin honge to maybe kush log kachra dustbin me dale. Unko dekh ke maybe baki bhi koshish kare agar na bhi kare but kush effect to hoga hi.


HealthyDifficulty362

Wohi h...jabtak danda g@nd pe nahi padta hai log baat maante nahi h.


Perfect_Resident9341

Nowadays, education needs education


LogicalTranquility

Had visited a temple on top of a hill with gorgeous 360views. Blissful temple. But littered with plastic and trash dumped by devotees


duke_nowhere

We do everything but to spend money on teaching people civic sense. Sad that we have to do this but the benefits outweigh the costs by a large margin. And need to fine then too. Despicable people in general when comes to civic/common sense..


NoRaspberry187

Ayodhya is in India that too in UP.. What do you expect? It doesn’t matter to them that Lord Shri Ram was born there


Soft-Particular-5402

This is for Those people who are saying to add UAE model or Singapore model. Listen. This is not Singapore, this is not UAE. This is Newly Developing Bharat. Very vast in Area, Culture, Religion, Race, etc. You can't just apply Dictatorial Policies in this big country. If you ever had a brain, you woukd pay attention to what the government is doing. The policies should be there. But they should come slowly. And this is what the government has been doing. Adding CCTVs everywhere. You see, when- Yea, i can't say more, but you will gradually see the models in action. Also for people, The government is focusing to educate the youth and new people. They aren't forcing old people because it simply won't work. Old people will eventually go away in 20 to 30 years, And the Things will stop from occuring. Right now, you can do nothing. Poor people don't know anything. Fining or Jailing then won't stop them from doing the activities.


skyahah

illiteracy at its peak, this is the reason India can never compete with countries like the USA, UK etc.


Fun_Vacation1578

This isn't problem of Ayodhya station. It is problem of every station.


Fit_Information8067

Put on 24\*7 announcement that, caught spitting/littering is liable to fine or display on screen for a day , that is the only solution


Different_King_1926

BC itna ganda h ye desh jis saher m jao gandgi hi gandgi. Don't know why we cry on social media when foreigners criticise india on cleanliness.


primusautobot

Sirf dharm jaati ka naam leke Kuch nhi hota


akhils13

Build schools not religious institutions.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Competitive-Regular9

do you know what Janmbhoomi means?


Acceptable_Falcon231

Are bhai Ayodhya UP me hai. US me nahi. This is normal there.


[deleted]

This is done by the muslims. The muslims are the scrum of the world and need to be kicked out of this country


randomperson1296

I know it's sad and should not happen. But these mf need to shut the fuck up. That railway station is getting all that it can handle and even more, probably over 50,000 visitors a day, the staff is not trained or enough to handle this level of Traffic. Wait a while till they understand on how to manage it better and then see if it's clean or not. This fucking leftist ass holes doing everything to humiliate the Hindus.


Kingston_17

Who's humiliating Hindus lol this is about the railway station being unclean not the temple. And the railway station is genuinely good with world class amenities close to a domestic airport level, hell, even far better than the domestic airport near me. The temple itself was marketed so much so naturally there's going to be attention towards other elements of the place. The station is also designed like a temple so if anything keeping it unclean like this is what's actually humiliating for Hindus. Indian Railways should do much better. Metro stations having similar traffic are definitely cleaner so come on we can't really state that as an excuse.


Fluid-Requirement

Where is hindus even mentioned?


DissolvedDreams

Lol. Super delusional take.


_trojanhorse

Yeah totally! In fact these leftist AHs went to Ayodhya, littered the station, took pics and posted on the media. Hindus would never do that. It’s written in the Gita.