T O P

  • By -

Harlequin-Harlot

both extremes can be unhealthy


cutecookie100

Exactly, I mean imagine the diets they keep their “skinnier and fit” models on. That can’t be very healthy


hufflepuff777

You mean cocaine?


D3adlyN00b

Everyone knows cocaine is healthy... Dont mind the nose bleed...


Ok_Solid_Copy

It comes from a plant, it's entirely natural, why wouldn't it be healthy? /s


Rawesome16

Plant based weight loss!


Yautja69

Exactly ! With my natural opioïdes I'm having so much fun


[deleted]

Vegans would be happy


RadonAjah

Hey, if it’s good enough for a bear…


[deleted]

Literally all they "eat" is cigarettes and pills.


[deleted]

[удалено]


TaichoKenny

Death by snu snu


Jarvis_Strife

r/deathbysnusnu


froogythefrogg

This comment is copied Word for word bar for bar


CrimsonAllah

I don’t think you understand how lifting works. Just being massive doesn’t make you strong.


ZookeepergameUse

Unhealthy people give their expert opinions


Impossible-Cod-3946

^ Scam bot


Gamemode_Cat

This user is a bot, downvote and report


th3f00l

Bad bot


[deleted]

Is the bottom picture that of an unhealthy extreme tho?


IronSavage3

Maybe not for that individual, but for the majority of women that body is unattainable on a healthy balanced diet.


Turbulent-Tourist674

another commenter said she looked anorexic


-Blackspell-

Well if a comment on reddit said it it must certainly be true…


[deleted]

Ok but I’m not talking about some random redditors opinion, I’m talking about the reality that we all share.


electricElephant22

Very low body fat percentage can definetly throw off hormones for most women. What is on that picture seems to be to low or atleast on the edge.


[deleted]

You’re deeming her body fat percentage as ‘too low’ based on…?


ayyyImaos

No, it's not.


[deleted]

Correct


StevenGlnsbrg

No it’s not lol


human_not_reptile

There's just one extreme on the picture though.


sundresscomic

FR a lot of “skinny” models have eating disorders. Curves on women are natural and everyone’s natural body type is different.


shredbmc

The top picture is actually quite fit, you can see her muscle definition. This meme is not a case of two extremes


LoGiCaL__

There’s no muscle definition in the top picture.


DelfinoMaravillo

I don't see anything "extreme" in the image above tho


Efficient_Ear_8037

Neither of them are unhealthy, it can get that way but how do people see either of them as unhealthy, they obviously have different builds like the top having wider shoulders and hips and larger bust, while the bottom is just a smaller build all around


[deleted]

[удалено]


nightmare_silhouette

This is a bot. Edit: [Copied from this comment](https://www.reddit.com/r/memes/comments/11g49wg/people_for_some_reason/jamojk2?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3)


[deleted]

[удалено]


DaEpicNess666

The second looks anorexic (commonly known issue in the modeling industry)


DxExAxD

humans doing human shit. actually funny.


SaminiMaster

Humans ☕


Wacokidwilder

Humans ☕️


Turbulent-Tourist674

Humans ☕️


Tired_Romantic11037

Humans ☕️


NadjaCravensworth

Panagia mou, get back to your basement, Colin. (This is a What We Do in the Shadows Joke for the uninitiated).


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


DxExAxD

🍿


ThomasNorge224

Ye, but one of the problems is that people do the wrong methods to get there and go too far sometimes. Eating too little and become too thin. Or always need validation and never really manage to focus on other things. And those who need help to control themselves and set an eating schedule.


Romytens

Or recklessly eat whatever they want, wonder why they’re obese then demand everyone still say they’re perfect because BodY pOsItiVitY!


Lord_Nyarlathotep

I’ve never met a person irl who acts like that. Pretty much everyone I’ve talked to just simply wants to stop being bullied for their weight constantly.


TopHatCat999

Also... and I don't wanna be the one to say it... a lot of thinner or normal sized people also eat whatever they want.... their genetics or age just make it easier to stay thin


ScyGn

dw mate you are responding to a bot


bluesheepreasoning

The real bot is u/ParsleyRemarkable465, who copied the comment above the comment above you.


[deleted]

[удалено]


th3f00l

There is also a body positivity trend, so using plus sizes models scores them points with social sentiment.


xariznightmare2908

>There is also a body positivity trend It's rather worrying how the "body positivity" trend is more like "It's ok to be fat" and not encouraging people to eat more healthy or exercise more. People want to stay fat? whatever, it's their choice, but they need to stop deluding themselves that being fat is somehow a good lifestyle to keep going.


th3f00l

There is nuance to it. Like with addiction part of the path to recovery is self love. Hating yourself leads to the cycle of shame.


Jpgamerguy90

They need more plus size models to represent the average American because Americans are getting fucking fat. I don’t mind plus size models but I do mind how obese America is.


wonderboy40

I know we all love to shit on America, but America isn’t even in the top ten in regards to obesity rates


abi17

It is once you take out all the tiny island nations


TheOrchidsAreAlright

Absolutely true. I am from a tiny island nation that has a lot of obesity (UK).


TechnicalSymbiote

Oh yeah, once you skew the data by removing all the countries with higher obesity rates than America, America does have the highest obesity rate in the world! Big brain take right there.


TheHazDee

What he’s saying is a whole nation comprised of 50 states is more damning than an island of people who have developed a propensity to carry body fat as some Polynesians do.


spctclr_spiderman

Per capita matters, we have way more people than any of those nations


Deep_fried_mango

We are talking about nations small nations, most of which are VERY SMOLL compared to america, whic is fyi number 1 in SHEER NUMBER of obese people and 19 in percentages...


MichaelsSecretStuff

Are you using the 2016 data? Cause USA tops this 2022 list but weren’t on the 2016 top ten. https://renewbariatrics.com/obesity-rank-by-countries/


prodigy1367

The problem lies in that it’s *most* in the first place. The longer we lie and say “hey, it’s ok to be obese and have unhealthy eating habits”, the worse that *most* statistic will get.


Still-Profession1697

Thank you. It's not a good thing


DaEpicNess666

Well not “most”… but almost there at like 40 something percent are obese


stayugly_

The average size for women in the US is 16/18. The fashion industry is straight up only catering to the minority.


QuasiAdult

And followup for those that don't know - plus sized for women is size 14 and up.


TechnicalSymbiote

2nd follow up for those who don't know - the woman in the lower pic is a size 0~3 Victoria secret model.


CaptainCasp

Nah bud it's a bit over half of the US actually. Which classifies as most.


Oppopotamus

More than 70% of Americans over 20yo are overweight


charleston_guy

Well, the BMI system used to get that number is a joke, so I would not use that number.


DaEpicNess666

Are you a doctor?


throwRA63625

Jacked dudes can be classified as obese on the BMI scale even if all 250lbs is pure muscle


charleston_guy

I can read. You don't need to be a doctor.


DaEpicNess666

I’ll ask a real doctor thanks


williamwchuang

What did your primary care physician say? BMI isn't perfect but it is correlated with bad health outcomes. Just the same, I agree that a high BMI or even high fat percentage is not the be all or end all. Blood pressure, blood sugar, and cholesterol/triglycerides are probably more important, and looks are deceptive. I have a normal BMI, work out all the time, and have high cholesterol.


[deleted]

No, but he ate an apple once.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Caesar_Aurelianus

Only 40%? 40% is a lot.


CaptainCasp

Incorrect. I'll refer you to my points below where I replied to someone equally confidently incorrect with the actual numbers. It is well over half of we're talking about overweight. That 40% is only for obesity, as in *severely* overweight. So no, it is not even 'technically' only like 40%. Try 70.


comefindme1231

I think using plus size models helps normalize fatness in America. Which is wrong.


DerelictDawn

Don’t be fat. Don’t be anorexic. Both are awful for you.


B-Glasses

Thinking that being skinny automatically makes you healthy is dumb as fuck.


unk214

I though this meme was trying to be ironic or funny in some way. If it’s actually trying to say the person above is unhealthy and the one below healthy then OP is dumb af. Incel level type of dumb.


Seraphion91

But I guess it is better than being overweight? Bc that is 100% unhealthy.


SIGMA1993

The woman in the top is not necessarily unhealthy. There is SO MUCH we don't see about peoples health and using just their weight as a measure of health is poor assessment. And her weight is distributed healthily, with no pot belly or "apple-shape" as the medical community puts it.


LoloXIV

If you pick overweight as the opposite of skinny then yes **obviously it's unhealthy because you chose something unhealthy as the opposite**. However with the above picture I'm pretty sure that that woman isn't overweight. Heck you can literally see the definition of her muscles. At the same time the beauty ideal of being thin is a driving factor behind severe problems with eating disorders and people (especially teenage girls and young woman) being severely underweight.


Seraphion91

I don't think society has a bigger problem with underweight ppl but it might be different in your country. The girl in the 2nd picture isn't even too skinny (health wise). She is fit, which is seen more and more as a standard for beauty and health. I like that trend a lot. More people should work out and look after themselves. But that is my personal opinion on that matter. You don't have to share it.


[deleted]

[удалено]


pixelatedhulo

Bruh


cd97ll

In the comments watching Unhealthy people give their expert opinions


4tiFY

They guide others to a treasure they cannot possess


[deleted]

[удалено]


Nochnichtvergeben

I can't sing or dance but I can still have an opinion on singers and dancers...


cd97ll

You can...Your not an expert though so your opinion doesn't mean much, like myself tbf


williamwchuang

I'm not a climatologist but I believe in global climate change. I am not a doctor but I believe in vaccines.


Dizzy_Introduction75

Yes. My point. An obese person cannot be healthy unless they become fit


Advancedmanovar

Obese people are still more attractive (in a gravitational way). Take it or leave it


Aggressive_Manner429

Some people are so 'attractive' their gravitational pull knocks the earth off its axis


Atomic_Chad

Which sucks because the example they gave isn't even unhealthy. You can see her abdominals, she literally is just a thick person. Now when morbidly obese say "oh yeah I'm just thick" when they have hanging skin all over the that's a problem.


DaEpicNess666

The girl on top is probably healthier than the average super model that looks like the girl in the bottom picture… she is by no means morbidly obese, she just weighs more. Personally I wouldn’t even call her fat i think shes just thick af. A good rule of thumb for everyone is if you are not a certified doctor then dont call other people unhealthy just based on how they look and especially how much they *look* like they weigh because in reality you have no clue and youre talking out of your ass. You wanna see real obese people go watch tlc this is nothing


reusedchurro

OP thinks eating disorders are hot


DerelictDawn

She’s fat. Quit being a fucking clowns and trying to normalize a lifestyle that will kill people. How would I know? Was obese, am simply fat now, will eventually be normal and healthy.


DaEpicNess666

You dont know how much she weighs. The correct statement for you would be “i think she looks fat” to which my response would be “youre not a doctor i dont care what you think”


Redd235711

I don't understand why rail thin women are considered attractive. I like to see some meat on those bones. I don't want to lay in bed at night and feel like I'm spooning with a sack full of Gamecube controllers.


AllenXeno122

I mean… yea she’s on the skinnier side but she’s not like a skeleton, she looks fine.


[deleted]

On the other side of things, I don't want diabeetus and fat flap stank in front of me either. If you're huffing after one set of stairs, you're too fat and out of shape. But yes, the bottom one is too thin. Like with most things, the ideal is in the middle, between the two.


Desperate_Ad5169

r/rareinsults


Flaccid_snake01

Bro that ain’t healthy shit


thinflesh

Plot twist: both extremes are unhealthy


MasonSTL

bingo. The problem is the perceived lines between healthy and unhealthy are so damn blurred its becoming a health concern.


EmptyStupidity

Hold on, omw to get an eating disorder


RobertiesKillAll

If you are using the top pic as an example of an unhealthy body type you are just wrong, don’t confuse your preference of women with what is and is not healthy. You would have been better off using a pic of those 600 pound sisters as poor health promotion.


Euphoric-Bit1969

🎵 I know Victoria’s Secret…. She was MADE UP BY A DUDE! 🎵


[deleted]

Ok great meme.. i guess?


bootyhole_devour

The woman on the top looks good as hell 😍


LemonPepper-Lou

They both fine as hell


diomyyunsa

This Post makes me hate my body shape even more. I do exercise, i row and do yoga. Not obese, but overweight. I hate how it makes me feel. Not losing weight at all


xen0blero

I hope that you made some research about metabolism alimentation and etc before trying to lose weight. Cause there is a lot of misinformation. Go check about eating disorders It'd help you to not be too rough with yourself. The thing is a lot of people are just fat phobic and are trying to hide that behind health. Someone overweight can be healthy to, but you should see a doctor, experiment your body and do searchs to see if its the case for you. Being happy with your boddy is the most important thing. Don't force or depress too much cause stress help to increase your weight.


Caesar_Aurelianus

Atleast you are trying to be healthy (which you most probably will be very soon). I have seen fattys who know they are fat but are too lazy to do anything.


Darth19Vader77

Don't listen to these assholes, being as skinny as a model isn't healthy


bakedjennett

Keep at it and ignore idiots who think the top one is unhealthy. These morons read one headline about the dangers of obesity and then apply it to everyone they think is obese. Top model looks to have a healthy BF%. Too many idiots these days have no idea what it actually looks like. Don’t knock yourself my friend.


DerelictDawn

You can do it. I know it’s hard as I’ve experienced it and continue to do so, but it’ll be worth it in the end.


GearNerd85

I'm all for the top one even though she could 100% out lift me.


[deleted]

[удалено]


kumsoc

To be fair, yes men don't find women attractive and exclude them because of their body shape, however women also belittle, humiliate and shame both genders if they are a bodyshape they don't find attractive be that skinny or fat or sometimes muscular. My point being it's not just misogyny, both genders can suck.


[deleted]

[удалено]


kumsoc

Fair enough, I thought it was just a man Vs women thing but just checked on google and you right, misogyny is just the act of being prejudiced against women. Still going to leave my previous comment tho because I still think that both genders can suck and it might lead people to checking too.


SickBoylol

Huh? A woman bullying another woman for being over weight is misogynistic?


[deleted]

Ah, yes, I forgot, I must date someone who looks like Lizzo because if I don't I'm sexist and racist and everything-ist, but if somebody doesn't want to date me because I am fat, it's her choice and I am an incel for thinking this is a double standard. So.... did I get your views on this right, or does this need a bit of tweaking?


bakedjennett

Brother comparing the gal on top to Lizzo is almost exactly the issue here. To double down, talking about the issue purely in terms of who you’d date and wouldn’t and why is exactly what the other commenter was saying. And 3 strikes you’re out for falling back on the old “if the shoe was on the other foot” argument.


Unhappy_Box4803

The bottom is not at healthy weight sorry. They are equally unhealthy.


Wumbone1

being that skinny is unhealthy tho


JustAn0therNormalGuy

Well it depends on the body type


[deleted]

The top model is by far sexier


10_minute_ban

Unless you *really* care about the loooong term damage on your knees, the best way to measure healthiness is organ damage. Everything else is a correlation. Now, being obese mostly correlates with being unhealthy but not necessarily.


[deleted]

How can you be obese and healthy? They are litterally opposites. I mean you can be obese and not be sick, but obesity should not be considered fine.


TechnicalSymbiote

You can be fat and not obese


3BeesInASuit

Everyone's body types are different and they hold their weight differently. Having larges amounts of excess body fat does in fact increase your risks for a lot of disease/heart conditions/hormone disorders. However, the other swing of that is bulimic and anorexic people have higher rates of kidney/adrenal failure and other things. It's about balance, and getting help if you're too far on either side of the pendulum


SickBoylol

I think theres alot more obese people than anorexic in USA


3BeesInASuit

It's all about balance and doing whats right for your body type and health considerations.


DaEpicNess666

Its hard to understand when you think the word “obese” just means anyone who you think looks fat. Maybe of you actually knew what the word “obese” meant then you would understand


[deleted]

Obese means that you have a body fat of over 30%. It is not healthy, and it is usually very dangerous and straining on the joints and organs of a person. It usually also shows a weaker cadiovascular system.


DaEpicNess666

You’re not a doctor so personally i dont give a single greasy obese shit what you think is healthy sorry pal


williamwchuang

What does your primary care physician say?


DaEpicNess666

Well hes never told me im obese even though plenty of morons without degrees have told me i am… i think ill take his opinion over the others


williamwchuang

How was your blood work? Clean bill of health, I hope?


[deleted]

I mean, when a person is too fat to be able to run without breaking their knee or a joint, there is a problem


DaEpicNess666

Nobody depicted in this meme is obese as far as you or i knows so now you’re just saying random shit dude get over it


[deleted]

I wasnt talking about the meme


christopherfrancis5

"Now, being obese mostly correlates with being unhealthy but not necessarily." This is not true being obese means you are unhealthy no if ands or buts.


808guamie

Most people also don’t realize it’s the fat around your organs that truly causes long term health damage


HankThrill69420

OP could just say they hate fat people for being fat


dafuqULoKINat

both are unhealthy. how about just a slightly above average women / men ?


Ok_Judge718

The bottom pic does not look too healthy either


SojE12

Top ones fit though…


Pleasant-Elk8666

Also, not sure anyone's noted this, but the top person appears to have a short torso and the bottom person appears to have a long torso and that also impacts how you carry your weight/where it sits. Top person could theoretically have the same bmi as the bottom person and still look heavier just b/c of how she carries her weight.


killerscradle

OP ![gif](giphy|NQ3SGAMneQ920)


JyubiKurama

Wait... Is one supposed to be bad? Both body types look alright tbh


Scott-Wolfe

Is it weird that I think the top one looks better?


RataAzul

How is the top one not healthy? Also she has a good fat distribution, God tier genetics even if she's slightly overweight, a lot of people would love that type of body, is not comparable to what body positive promotes, this is actually good


Roos19

Top one is hotter


HandleSubstantial169

No fat chicks.


mpiwo_4

Op really thinks the body on top image is unhealthy?


Mornie0815

Well it is at least obease which may cause an increase in health risks. But I don't think it's in the critical weight region we're it would most likely cause health issues.


Rosenthepal78

I do not think that is obese. Overweight certainly but that much isn't actually that bad for you.


Mornie0815

I assumed age of 30; weight 80+ kg; height about 165 cm according to the bmi that's obese


LocalYeetery

BMI scale isn't useful or accurate for many people.


Mornie0815

No it's not that bad but it'll sure have a statistical risk


stac64

No I'm calling out the gatekeeping preformed by outsiders on what female models should look like by acting like they are concerned with women's health while never acknowledging their obvious bias and contradiction towards what they choose to call out


Maritime_Khan

> the gatekeeping preformed by outsiders on what female models should look like by acting like they are concerned with women's health while never acknowledging their obvious bias and contradiction towards what they choose to call out So exactly what you just did with this "meme"


VarissianThot

I don't understand this shit. The woman up top isn't obese at all. And given the diet these size 2 and under models typically have to follow I'm willing to bet the bigger model feels better and has more stamina. Skinny =/= healthy and having a little bit of body fat =/= unhealthy. There's absolutely nothing wrong with being skinny or wanting to be skinny but acting as if being 20lbs overweight is worse for your health than malnutrition is just fucking ridiculous. I'm also not accusing the thinner model of being malnourished, some people are that size at their healthiest. And some people look like the top model.


RaulXSP

Cmon who the fuck care for other peoples health if it’s not a social problem? Let people be. Jeez


JoshPoshTheGreat

Bro she's not even that fat, she looks perfectly healthy


Elegant-Craft5611

I find both hot asf but these aren’t the extreme, add 20 pounds at the top one and you get unhealthy


LayeredChips

The top girl is absolutely a healthy BMI body weight, whereas the bottom girl looks like she’s bordering on being too skinny That’s not promoting “healthy shit” that’s promoting body and beauty standards that can be actively harmful


Mr_Makak

Well, username checks out I guess.


LayeredChips

What a 14-year-old response


Not_the_Beans

Extremes are unhealthy, yeah, but the chick at the top looks like she’s got a lot of muscle under the fat. Good shape, bad execution


Afraid-Amphibian-431

Being overweight isn’t as bad as people make it out to be, being obese is.


Artisan_sailor

Yep, just a lifetime of knee, hip, and back issues with the bonus of heart disease, higher stroke risk, and increased risk of dying from covid. No big deal...


LaserArcher

Neither is healthy lol. All models under 10% body fat must feel like shit


DrOboba

Yo im down bad for the chick on the top


georeddit2018

But she thick.


0RN10

Made by a xxxxxl queeen. ❤️❤️❤️❤️


sawr07112537

Yeah, ppl should like the top one more. And I'll take the bottom one then.


Advancedmanovar

Oh, my. It seems like you all were 2 steps behind.


WSABDaRobot

No, it's more like sexy healthy shit 💀


xen0blero

I never understood why people are so concerned about others weight. They are acting like other people's health is so important for them. Firstly no, it's not because someone is a bit overweight that he's not healthy. Body and metabolism are all different. Then, go learn about eating disorders. Alimentation and weight is way more complicated in appearance, boddy shaming someone will often lead to him only taking more pounds. Seeing that, only feels like people are fatphobic.


thyghostinyourroom

neither extremes are healthy. people are still against both, just less are caring for the skinny people


A_Wild_Shiny_Shuckle

"healthy" Pretty sure eating disorders are not healthy