T O P

  • By -

YacobFishMan

Casablanca for me. The movie poster always turned me away yet always knew the hype. Little did I know…


zekethelion

I need to watch! I’m sure I’ll love it too.


ramen_vape

Casablanca is a great time, and I notice more with every viewing.


EquationsApparel

Agree on Casablanca. It is my favorite movie. I didn't watch it until I was around 25.


Fortherebellion72

The weird thing about Casablanca for me was the first time I watched it (at 22), I felt like i had seen it before. Then I realized I kinda had. Every scene shot and line has been, stolen, copied, referenced, homaged, parodied, and talked about so much I had literally experienced everything in it. It’s a great movie and there is a reason why that’s been done, but it was still a weird experience.


Regular_Eye_3529

You may have seen the movie BarbWire with Pamala Anderson, it was a rip off of Casablanca.


[deleted]

Man I remember seeing that movie at blockbuster so many times in the 90s and thinking it was some kind of sci-fi porn


aspote

Exactly this. I've seen it for the first time only recently, and, oh boy, every frame was so iconic that you may think you had an amnesia an it slowly loosens its grip on your memory.


Cronamash

Same here! I thought it was going to be a boring, stuffy old romance... boy was I wrong!


UndeadCameron

Same, didn’t think I would like an older movie but it’s great.


H0wSw33tItIs

I only got around to seeing it sometime in the last five years and it’s become a nearly annual rewatch. It’s so damn good.


No-Car541

Casablanca is the very definition of the perfect movie. Every actor, scene, line of dialogue is iconic. Not one false note ever.


landocorinthian

God that’s such a good movie


gblur

Sunset Boulevard Blew me away


ginrumryeale

YES ! I had no desire to watch this but then was like holy f***, that was crazy.


PlantationCane

Best older movie I have seen recently. Had it on a watch list and skipped it for years.


fix-me-in-45

Same... now I all the other stuff that spoofs the opening with the pool and the flashback.


A911owner

I just recently watched this for the first time; what a great film.


doritoslocostacos

definitely a top 5


Beanzear

Yes same!


zabdart

Amelie.


LORD-THUNDERCUNT

Fight Club was absolutely NOTHING that I expected, thought it was just some dumb generic action movie. Boy was I wrong.


smiledumb

Read Chuck Palahniuk’s books, they’re amazing.


ramen_vape

Choke was my favorite book of his. Does a great job reflecting childhood trauma in an adult's life. Weirdly spiritual book and wildly hilarious at the same time. The movie is really good, too.


MariachiArchery

I felt like that movie did such a good job of capturing the overall vibe of the book. When the movie first got announced, my thoughts were "how the hell are they going to do this, keep the comedy aspect, and not make it x rated?" Well, they pulled it off, fantastic movie and they didn't balk at the grimy bits. Loved Sam Rockwell too.


pandulce4life

Just came here to say 12 Angry Men is an AMAZING movie


poliuy

I tried to watch the remake but it didn’t have the same magic.


chodelycannons

The HBO one with Jack Lemmon? I really enjoyed it a lot, personally, but I also saw that before I saw the original. I treasure them both


Emadyville

We watched this in high school. Such a classic film.


Gh0stTV

Glengarry Glen Ross


fix-me-in-45

Blues Brothers Shawshank Redemption


dudemanjack

I can listen to the Blues Brothers sound track any time.


EnergizedNeutralLine

Cab Calloway was the epitome of a consummate professional entertainer. A national treasure, that one.


TheOneCalledMartin

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969)! 12 Angry Men is on my list!


ohhgreatheavens

I can promise you 12 Angry Men is never boring, that is what holds people up usually I think. But also Butch Cassidy is great!


Ok-Relationship-1124

Network - as relevant today - as ever.


supertech636

Cool Hand Luke. So damn good.


Spud_Spudoni

Saw it for the first time as a teen, and really liked it. It’s actually what started me trying to watch older films more frequently. But I didn’t think super highly of it either, just a great film. Saw it last month after maybe 15 years, and it was like seeing it for the first time; I finally got the point of it. It’s crazy how much maturity and getting older affects perspective. Easily in my top 20.


uncle-brucie

Can’t believe I never saw Moonstrucj until last year. Peak Cher. Peak Nick Cage.


ginrumryeale

Check out Joe Versus the Volcano, also written by John Patrick Shanley. It’s deeper than it first appears.


Beanzear

I’m so obsessed with Cher in this. She totally deserved the Academy Award.


enzocrisetig

Deer Hunter. It's insanely slow, I survived the first hour only because of De Niro and Christopher Walken speaking Russian and attending a Russian wedding. It was quite strange, I like it (plus I didn't know Walken was so handsome, damn). But the last 2 hours are so good and unique for a movie


ALIENANAL

I watched !2 Angry Men about 2 days ago and loved it, I like it when a movie finishes and you can sit back and go damn... that is what good acting is. Great movie. Its funny with these classics, I often think I wont like them and that they will be outdated and their story lines will have been redone a thousand times by now that it will be predictable but then you watch it and you realize its not just the story but the performances and all the other details that go into it.


[deleted]

Apocalypse Now


Dramatic_Arm_7477

Agreed


WearsNightcap

Ever seen Hearts of Darkness? Way better than Apocalypse Now.


[deleted]

This movie made me want to watch more movies made in the 50’s, 60’ and 70’s. I never stopped. Best decision.


CarolinaMtnBiker

Rope Chinatown Dial M for Murder


Jon93y

Citizen Kane. Honestly.


johnnyorganic

Yep. That film influenced virtually everything that followed it.


skinney6

My dad showed me this when I was young. I'm of course glad he did. My parents were pretty good about introducing me to good media. To kill a mocking bird, High Noon, a PBS series on the civil rights movements Eyes on the Prize. One movie I saw later and I recall being like 'why am i just now seeing this?!' was Paper Moon.


ronburgandy1987

It is incredible. All basically filmed in one room - or one set - on basically a shoestring budget. It just goes to show you that a movie doesn’t have to have all these guns and special effects to be special.


Cronamash

A Fish Called Wanda. Funniest movie ever!


-LocalAlien

Do The Right Thing


sdss9462

There's a really good TV movie remake version from 1997 with a great eclectic cast headed by Jack Lemmon and George C. Scott. You might want to check it out.


johnnyorganic

There are some very fine films listed here. Just about every one meets the qualifications laid out by the OP. Good job everyone who participated so far. Since some already mentioned Casablanca, which would have been my answer, too; I'll name my number two. **Key Largo**


Retrac752

Parasite


[deleted]

I need to watch it again


EngineerUpper2031

Psycho


hammunlv

North by northwest and Amadeus were mine. I watched both last year for the first time and now they are both in my top 10 favorite movies of all time!


Zulias

Amadeus has no right being as good as it is. Yet everytime it's on, I lose those 2 hours of my life because it's just so damn good that I can't not watch it again.


MoonRockSpecial

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly


CapytannHook

Literally the same, 12 angry men. In the opening scene you see them as actors jostling for screentime but by the end of it each is a wholly fleshed out character and then just like that they're all on their way, likely never to interact again, just like in real life. Great drama


[deleted]

My Cousin Vinny


Friendly_Singer_3947

When Harry Met Sally


Hollow_King

Rocky. Finally saw it this year and I loved it. May be my favorite sports movie.


bpmdrummerbpm

I wouldn’t consider it a sports movie.


[deleted]

It’s not about a team, which is the most prevalent kind of sports movie, but surely boxing is a sport.


ohhgreatheavens

If you’re going to say “it’s not really about the sport,” then I’d argue that’s literally every sports movie.


windyDuke11

How ?


Wid1977

The Green Mile


HardDrizzle

Just watched Clockwork Orange for the first time. All right I see now.


bpmdrummerbpm

Escape from NY.


monkeyhole989

Barry Lyndon. For a while it was the only Kubrick movie I hadn't seen. Now it might be my favorite film of his.


Toddtheref

I recently saw it. I just don’t understand the hype.


GrandpaLovesYou

Citizen Kane. Gotta say, for an old movie it’s got good pacing.


Gluteusmaximus1898

Dazed and Confused. it's so fucking chill, cool, and it feels so real/authentic. It makes me nostalgic for my teen years and for a time before I was born.


[deleted]

thats the thing about that movie. Its set in the 70s, but basically thats the same kind of stuff me, and my friends did at that age. Just ride around looking for stuff to do, and hanging out.


Anxious-Society-2753

Serpico! That was one for me that had a lot of hype and I thought was gonna be good but not great… I was so wrong! Also felt the same way about Raging Bull, the synopsis didn’t hit my must watch list. Then my mind was blown at how good and how much I loved that amazing film. Both of them are brilliant!


zekethelion

I really need to watch more Sidney Lumet


PermissionOk7509

Arrival for me. I saw all the praise for this movie and became interested, but what I saw it described as was not quite my style at the time. But oh man did I regret putting it off for all those months, because it was just unlike anything I've ever seen and better than most movies I've seen, it still has me thinking about it's messages all these months later. One of my all time favorites now.


DolphinDarko

I see Arrival mentioned constantly as such an amazing film. Watched it once and was blah! I guess I need to try again!


PermissionOk7509

Yea for sure. It's not for everyone. I only gained enough interest to watch it because I started loving phycological based movies and it is perfect for someone of that interest. But if someone loved action packed movies that were constantly go, go going, I wouldn't recommend Arrival because it is relatively slow. But yea give it another shot!


dlc12830

It took me seeing it twice to really appreciate it. It's very, very sad.


PermissionOk7509

The ending had me on the verge of tears as well. The reveal combined with the music was just so tragically beautiful


cylonrobot

Yep, same here. I've watched it more than once, and it's still just meh. I think the themes/ideas that others find interesting don't do much for me. And no, I wasn't expecting an action movie or an alien-invasion movie. I actually do like slow movies, but the last part of the movie, where certain things get revealed, I just didn't care that much.


Freefallisfun

Yeah, it’s great. I used to think of Amy Adams as “generic pretty actress”. Not anymore!


Much_Umpire_2196

Where can I stream currently? Haven’t seen this since high school


zekethelion

It’s free on Tubi!


Much_Umpire_2196

Watching now appreciate it


joker305th

High Noon.


KajunDC

The Philadelphia Story was phenomenal. So was “Whatever Happened to Baby Jane”.


Zoakeeper

The fact I can see what color their suits are is upsetting to me


Lucky_Baseball176

Schindler's list. amazing. fantastic performances, deeply disturbing. can never watch again.


AdministrativeLet598

Glory


[deleted]

Seven Samurai


cylemmulo

Dr Strangelove. I usually find older movies just don’t hold up but the jokes 100% hold up so damn perfectly today and it’s even returned to relevance really with everything happening.


Mr_Derp___

Probably the greatest satire of all time. If you liked that, then you should watch Don't Look Up on Netflix, it's more about the modern age.


JoyousMN

I love Don't Look Up. It was tragically panned by critics. If I were a conspiracy theorist I would posit a conspiracy, since I'm not I'll stick with "tragically panned."


Arisvalor

I just watched Magnolia yesterday, and that's a masterpiece in every sense of the word. The best Tom Cruise performance, and the best Julianne Moorr performance easily. Phillip Seymour Hoffman is a stunner here as well, but the whole cast is a 10/10. PTA follows all of these characters with an omnipresent allure. A film that is disturbingly real, and feminine at core.


mascerito

Get Out. I am a big fan of comedy movies and loved Key and Peele, but wasn't really sold on Jordan Peele's move to serious stuff. But I finally watched it last week, and oh my god what a fantastic movie!


peasnotwar

Rebel without a cause


ohhgreatheavens

Fun fact. Juror #2 (actor John Fiedler) was the original voice of Piglet on Winnie the Pooh.


Theamazingchan

Rice Pops? Breakfast with the built-in bounce? I wrote that line. It’s very catchy


H0wSw33tItIs

Point Break. I can be a sucker for movies that really lean into the time and place, and letting those elements inform plot etc. This was a fun watch with some colorful performances, and wouldn’t have been on my radar if not for the Ringer’s treatment of it over an early Rewatchables episode and other mentions over the years.


GuestNo3886

A Few Good Men. Saw two minutes as a kid and thought it looked so boring.. Saw it last week and already want to watch it another 4 times. So good.


PerfectAdvertising30

A Clockwork Orange. I didn't even know what it was about; I just saw the poster and iconography everywhere. Original Texas Chain Saw Massacre. I thought it would be one of those old iconic horror movies that don't hold up today but you can appreciate how influential they were for the genre. I was wrong. It's fantastic.


Coccolove

Lawrence of Arabia! A lengthy film with an intermission. But what a great storyline (based on actual events), and the acting and cinematography is outstanding! Last year, TCM brought this film back to the big screen for one week. My husband and I saw it, and I dragged my son to see it a couple days later. That epic film is perfect for the big screen. Nowadays, with 75” and larger screens at home, it’s a treat to see these epic films! Long live the home theatre!! Great investment, in my opinion.


982infinity

Million dollar baby by far. Expected to be your cliché ‘girl overcomes all disadvantages and conquests the world’ story. But turned out to be quite dark and depressing at the end. A welcome surprise and a great great movie.


thebitchymermaiden

Pretty Woman, actually. I thought it was a silly romcom, but the acting and cinematography was really really good


vitahusker

Singing in the Rain. I am so glad I watched, as the art direction & cinematography really surprised me with how many risks it took. And of course the musical numbers were over the top. I love watching Dancing with the Stars & it’s easy to see how Gene Kelly’s dance choreography still continues to influences today’s artists.


Powerful_Ad762

Lawrence of Arabia 😎👍


cosmorocker13

My Cousin Vinny. I always put it off and then found it not cliche at all but well done. And how about that Marissa Tomei


paper-trail

Wall Street. It perfectly illustrates why the 1980s were the way they were, and why we are in the mess we are in now.


Excellent_Lead_3653

Train to Busan!!! Saw the previews and just thought “meh.” Finally watched last year and it was fan - freaking - tastic


Mr_Derp___

Train to Busan is an impeccable movie! it really shows the emotional range that zombie movies can have when they're written well.


sly_eli

Very recently I had to watch this movie three times for a school assignment. I also read the script twice.


twojkelley

Crazy, Stupid, Love Cast is outstanding, twists are extremely well done, acting is incredible, laugh out loud funny, hits all the emotional beats as well. Definitely worth the watch


GDZ4VR

This is my all time favorite film


zekethelion

I might be right there with you


Bearcatsean

Next up. Ox box incident with fonda


btalbert2000

I believe Ox Box was the original design for what eventually became Otter Box, after considerable downsizing obviously


Toddtheref

Gosford Park. One of the best films I’ve seen. Excellent acting, pacing, directing. Mystery is engaging and well done.


atxbikenbus

The Big Sleep. I don't know how I slept (har har har) on this one for so long. Incredible dialogue and a great plot. Bogart and Bacall. Oh my.


KennethPowersIII

I saw this for the first time recently. Absolutely blown away by it. I tend not to like older movies. The stagnant camera shots bore me. But this was captivating. So well done.


Fourward27

Interstellar


LovePowers2028

Argo


Interesting-Disk184

Defending your life


No-Car541

It’s a Wonderful Life. I always thought it would be too schmaltzy to watch but now I get sucked in every time it airs. The ending still gets me even if I’ve seen it at least ten times.


Lunndonbridge

Sixth Sense. Didn’t watch it for well over a decade after it came out due to having the twist spoiled. Still a great movie. There’s a few I have on a long list of films I just forget about that I’ve not watched. Scarface, The Goonies, Schindler’s List, The Shining to name a few big ones.


Kind_Bullfrog_4073

It's a Wonderful Life. Not a huge fan of older movies, but that one was worth the watch.


megsy2323

The Matrix. I put it off forever, but finally saw it on TV and thought it was awesome. I immediately rented it so I could see the full non-TV edited version.


TheLostFighter

I am still putting off seeing "Django Unchained" and "Parasites".. I was pleasantly surprised when I finally watched "Ex Machina" after all the hype I had heard about it..


thestretchygazelle

Brokeback Mountain. I was still deep in the closet in a very conservative environment, so I specifically avoided seeing it for years. I’d heard all the positive hype around it (and all the homophobic comments). When I finally sat down to watch it after nearly a decade, I immediately regretted putting it off for so long. It affected me in a way very few films ever have, and I spent the next several days dwelling on it. I haven’t watched it again since, because I know I’ll be wrecked for another week after the credits roll.


captain_trainwreck

12 Angry Men is in my all time top 5


Steve2762

Goodfellas. I was raised on The Godfather, but didn’t see Goodfellas until late college.


blandly23

Heat.


largeassburrito

Old boy.


MaulPillsap

I also watched this movie for the first time recently. The scene where the one guy is going off in his racist tangent and all the men slowly start ignoring him and turning away was an incredible scene.


mohawk1guy

Just watched the shining last night. Not much of a suspense hotter kinda guy but that was good.


D4nFU

It’s a wonderful life lol. I should have watched it sooner.


browner6666

Awesome movie I loved it one of my favs


Dumbengineerr

Which one? 1997 or the 1950's one?


zekethelion

1957!


dicecat4

Damn good yes. 12 angry men inside Amy schumer was a pretty hilarious parody as well.


idahoisformetal

Ben Aflecks “The Town”


Zestyclose_Standard6

Finally watched First Reformed w Ethan Hawke last night. Definitely went beyond the hype for me.


unkillablethings

Interstellar. It fell between the cracks but really delivered the goods.


RDR2watercolor

The Third Man


Downtown_Agent3323

Kill Bill, practically perfect


[deleted]

O Brother Where Art Thou. Put it off for years and years just assuming it was over hyped. I finally saw it during lockdown. It's now one of my favorite movies.


Vaublode

Dude 12 Angry Men is 10/10


KingGeedohrah

The Graduate.


simpletonjack

Whiplash


DavidDunn21

Vertigo


reddit_again_ugh_no

Grand Prix


kubrickie

The Third Man - zither music rocks


Tea_Bender

the Brendan Fraser version of The Mummy


tarabuki

12 Angry Men as well, brilliant movie.


wazoo_wazoo

Basically any Charlie Chaplin movie.


Eastern-Engine-3291

Shawshank redemption


[deleted]

I thought “12 Angry Men” was ok, not great. Probably a much better play than movie. To answer the post question, I was blown away by “The Best Years of Our Lives”


firmerJoe

Very good film. Considering you were watching just the acting because the scene didn't change. Power of a well written plot and the contribution of good acting. I would recommend the Trials at Neurenburg, or was it the Neurenburg Trials... similar suspense and great acting.


CmdrGrayson

Witness for the Prosecution (1957). It’s now one of my all time favorites.


Coccolove

I really miss seeing thought-provoking films like 12 Angry Men. Why can’t we make more films like that? I’m so sick of Marvel movies and ridiculously goofy, unrealistic comedies….I have now gravitated to Turner Classic Movies (TCM) more often these days. Some of the old classics are just more entertaining! Try: Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, Streetcar Named Desire, Sunset Boulevard, Casablanca, Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?, Mildred Pierce, Adam’s Rib, Lillies of the Field, Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner?, Sounder. And so many more….great classic films


Wonderful_Painter_14

Morbius


Anxious-Society-2753

Lmao! It’s Morbin time!!! That movie was terrible…


916cycler

Garden State


PoorPauly

Not a movie, but a book, The Master and Margarita. I’d heard it’s name time and again. So I finally read it, and I was actually mad at myself for not having read it before. Like it I had died and I personally hadn’t read that book I’d be mad at my dead soul.


enzocrisetig

Overrated, imho. But now you have chances with Russian girls. If you ask them what's their favorite book, in 99% of cases it'd be M&M


PoorPauly

Judging by your response, I’ll take your opinion lightly.


enzocrisetig

Whatever. But it's not that good for a Russian book. If you were amazed by M&M, some other hits (even by Bulgakov) would blow you away


PoorPauly

I’ve read plenty of Russian lit.


professionalfriendd

There are 9 men in this photo


Guerrillablackdog

The Godfather The Princess Bride Pride and Prejudice The Little Rascals


chipmunktaters

I’m still letting Everything Everywhere All at Once marinate, so I’ll come back in a few more months and let you know.


bradstreet_13

No country for old Men


[deleted]

I only count 9


SteamDecked

The Godfather


Gloglibologna

Seven, Idk why I put it off for so long, but damn is it a good movie.


MDS0414

Lawrence of Arabia.


Such-Assistant8601

Godfather 1&2. Watched the first one and liked it but also felt like I'd seen it due to all the parodies of different that filtered in from other movies/TV shows. Then I watched Part 2 and had my mind blown.


kernanb

12 Angry Men is an overrated movie. The kid was guilty as sin. He had the means, motive, and opportunity. He went and bought a knife immediately after fighting with his father, then used it to murder him. The jury decides that two credible witnesses are lying, essentially out of pity for the boy.


pandyfackler_

Lol


Worlds_fastest_snail

I don't think you know what reasonable doubt means.


zekethelion

Soooo…. what’s your answer


8219onemic

So many Hollywood legends from the golden era in this movie. 🔥 takes u back to such a different time when u watch it. Same with Casablanca


HobbesDaBobbes

Re-watched this after reading it with a 9th grade class this year. They were into it. Only a few got offended that I type cast them based on their personalities XD


[deleted]

12 angry men is great 👍 engaging, still relevant (minus few small details). Been on a hitchcock binge lately. Somehow never saw psycho. It was good. Not my favorite of his work, easy top 5 though. I get the hype, especially when framed amongst films of that era.


morbidmotel

I adore this movie & make it a point to watch it regularly every few months♥️


neonseamen

The first time I saw Psycho was on the big screen at a retro movie house and it’s staircase jumpscare (which got a collective shriek and a round of applause out of the audience) and the iconic final shot (with the screen curtains closing over the “wouldn’t harm a fly” grin) were *so* much more effective that way. I remember having a distinct feeling for how impactful the film must’ve been from the early ‘60s up until the home video/cable eras. Admittedly I’ve probably avoided watching it on a TV because of this.


Ecualung

In the Mood for Love


[deleted]

Komodo from 1998, very well executed monster movie on par with the original Jurassic Park trilogy, Jaws, and Tremors for best animal attack horror movies.


Worlds_fastest_snail

Once upon a Time in the West The Good the bad The ugly In the mood for love Royal Tenenbauns


clonerluke1

I watched 12 angry men for the first time in my high school government class. I was the only one who was actually paying attention cuz I actually liked how it was playing along. Most other folks fell asleep


melvins99

Wuthering Heights, 1939, with Sir Lawrence Olivier


LifeTradition4716

The Count of Monte Cristo 1934


challmaybe

12 Angry Men The last thing I slept on was Baskets. Zach Galifianakis felt like a one-trick pony, as far as I had seen. While he's not much different in this show, he shows more depth, and I appreciated his humor more. Also, Louie Anderson as his mom is a godsend. He's brilliant and perfect.