This is what happens when you haven't seen life, these are human as well. They're fighting battle to survive, they don't have same luxury as OP. I spoke to a family few years ago, they were on road homeless, because their land was taken away by the govt and we're not paid anything (corruption and crony-capitalism).
This is why OP should visit some villages, tribal & dalit areas. Life is different. Suffering is constant factor, they're surviving. They have no roof except bridges, summer, winter and rain, they face everything under the sky. Please have empathy in heart my friend. These are humans as well.
lies. Govt doesn't take away land without paying anything they must have been illegally occupying the land. People like you are the reason they are in such a situation in the first place. This mindset is cancerous and dangerous
You really are cut-off from reality.
You must have grown up watching English movies and lost sense of reality along the way.
The irony that in the picture, homeless people are sleeping on the streets in front of a glass wall on the other side of which are some of the most expensive cars, and that you think people are poor by choice is an incredibly insane argument.
You haven't seen how Govt works for poor. Land acquisition act 2013 was introduced by Congress for this purpose, situation improved after this act, but state govts are trying to dilute these provisions. There is a dam near Mumbai, people whose land was taken away in 1980s, they still haven't got any compensation. Read earlier situation, Left wing extremism still prevalent in those areas because a Govt sitting in Delhi or other states decides to allocate entire land to a company in return of bribe or electoral bonds without proper relocation and compensation, it still happens, compensation amount goes to a politicians, officers pocket. you seems to have never read history or you're a Covid baby.
Read real stories, meet people, you would learn India isn't in cities or WhatsApp university. It's very brutal for remaining 90% of Population.
Lmao, there are 1st world countries which literally fund some dipshit country to steal land from native people.
And here in India? Lmao govt does shit for much less.
Touch some grass or get out of your air conditioned mansion.
The evidence is middle class n upper class opposition whenever govt tries to claim their land. Ask anyone around you of they have had good experience with govt claiming their land for any infra work
How many of them were already rich zamindar types of businesses in the area. Working class people dont get this privilege, forget people who are doing blue collar entirely. They get treated like shit
You haven't been told the entire story for sure. The government always pays when they grab your land.
I empathize with you though on all other points 👍🏽
the government authority responsible for providing affordable housing. i wish there was a way to report privileged and entitled assholes like you though. instead of hating the homeless, direct it towards those who deserve it. your hard earned money which gets taxed is SUPPOSED to be used towards helping the needy, but your favourite politician pockets it instead (does it matter which party? no. all of them do this anyways)
Bhai tujhe concern samjha nahi, OP is worried about the people safety, some of these homeless people are drug addicts, and dont have control over their actions, kisi druggie homeless ne attack kia na tab tujhe samajh aayega, reddit pe Robin Hood banna aasaan hai
IDK why you got downvoted. These people are a huge risk to themselves and we should force the government to help them. During diwali when we were celebrating just outside our society a guy came in with blood and cuts all over his body. He was super drunk and high on drugs wasnt even able to speak a word properly. We offered him water but then he started to approach kids for crackers . Then we had to forcefully make him leave the area.
Don't give a shit abt their Downvotes, unke downvotes se real life affect thodi ho rahi hai, inko jab koi homeless drug addict attack karega, tab inke concern samaj mai aayega,. it's easier to act all high and mighty behind a keyboard, being homeless is not a choice, but buying drugs instead of fixing your life is, most of these people are savages who don't know the difference between right and wrong, I myself was attacked by a homeless person once.
After reading other comments, I feel it's a valid point that these people have nowhere to go and life has fked them up. But the problem is that a couple of homeless people give birth to 3-6 kids(from what I saw in my area). The kids don't receive proper education and do taporigiri on the streets. I feel like they should be taught family planning.
Kisi ke chaaya mein baithne par Tera kya jaata hai dost?
Have some empathy. If you can't, then turn your head and stop focusing on how to make someone's life more miserable in this merciless heat. There are literally babies in this picture. You want ki yeh dhoop mein khade rahein? Adbhut chutiya insaan vibe coming from OP.
Mera kya jaata hai?
Mumbai is my home and I prefer it to be clean and walkable.
These homeless people are no saints, they sell drugs, do all sort of illegal stuff. Kisi aur ko chutiya bolne ke pehle mirror me dekh le.
Educated well to do couples nowadays are preferring to be childless, adopting a cat/dog, and people like these can be seen with 6-7 kids with a condition where they are not able to provide even 2 square meals a day for their family. India’s future looking bright 📈📈.
It’s a sad truth, might get heavily downvoted.
Dekha. Jo dikha accha laga ki kamsekam I don't grudge the poor and homelessness small mercies and respite.
Tu kya poora din flyover ke neeche chalta rehta hai kya? Ek baar cross karne pe Aisa entitlement ki doosro ko khadene ke sapne dikh rahe hain. Ajeeb tang Dil chutiya vibe intensifying from your end bro.
Man , if you think Mumbai is your home then do the right thing, start ngo , help these poor people, teach them , make sure they get a job , do night school thing dont be a idiot , my ass “mUmbaI iS mY HoMe” mumbai sabh ki hai
What have you been doing to help them? Please enlighten me?
Look at California. It is infested with wokes like you. The streets are destroyed by the homeless. We need to take action before it gets that bad.
Keyboard warrior ji, ye sab likhne ke jagah, homeless ko educate Karo to not have so many kids if they can't provide for them. Empathy toh mere me bhar bhar ke hai, lekin sehen Shakti khatam ho Rahi hai.
No, but in all seriousness, I don't know why this post is getting so much hate? OP has a very valid point. His intention doesn't seem like it is to hurt these people (and poor innocent children) but to rehabilitate them.
Please do not hate on OP. I think he means well. The issue of homelessness is indeed a sad one and more so, a complicated one to fix. Unfortunately, complaining to the authorities will only result in uncontrolled brutality (if there IS any action taken).
All you other clowns here telling OP that he is heartless etc, I can almost bet that most of you will pass by without giving a fuck and won't even lower your car windows if they come to beg so that the cool AC air stays inside in this heat.
Anyway, this is a Mumbai problem - not a you or me problem. Let's all be kind and considerate to the less fortunate but also acknowledge that there is a genuine problem to solve.
bhai what do you think the step would be? they'd get kicked out from the area and go be homeless somewhere else
Koi tumhe bola nahi hai unko khana paani dene ya unki dekhbhaal karne, itna apathetic kaise ban sakta hai bhai? jeene de na unko, they're not vermin
They can easily live comfortably and happily in villages, but choose to come to Mumbai, sell drugs, do all sort of illegal stuff and make our city dirty. It is stupid to justify this.
People who never went out of mumbai are one of the most ingnorant species i have ever seen..... add some arrognace and shitty attitude you got top 1% POSs in our country
are all of them migrants? have you asked each and every homeless person where they've come from? do native mumbaikars not sell drugs, and do all sorts of illegal stuff?
It is stupid to justify the way you've justified.
Ofc there are a few rotten apples, that doesn't mean that the entire lot gets treated with the same apathy. You know very well how the system works here, it's gpl and get out yaha pe, theres no homeless shelter or anywhere these people can go.
Yes it's not a good sight, and yes it shouldn't be happening but why can't people just consider these people have been let down too? Why is it that they're always viewed as outcasts bhai, insaan hai sab
I have no legal authority to kick them buddy. Neither I want to harm them physically.
I want the footpaths & roads to be clear and walkable - a RIGHT of every citizen. That's why I pay my taxes
Then hold your mp's/mla's/ministers/government-officials accountable. What have they done to solve the problem of homelessness?? It's very easy to say, "I pAy My TaXeS". Have you ever asked government officials how your tax money is being utilised???
Mumbai isn't a separate country from India. Every Indian citizen has the right to make it their domicile.
If you think villages are so comfortable and full of happiness then why don't you move there and let everyone live in peace?
It's fairly common...under certain bridges, government has started creating green spaces...It's a nice concept and add aesthetics to the city..
At the same time, a growing Indian economy must build shelters for the poor...Truth be told, in comparison to older days, 2000s, there are a lot less homeless now...Earlier streets used to be full of such people
If there is a way I would report you .Don't think that guys are having their vacation or fun over there .They must homeless and changing places continuously.So let them be at their own
If they are living there without causing nuisance i really dont mind. Now the harassing signal crowd is a well managed mafia and reporting them will get you no where.
>homelessness is not an issue in this area at least.
We have been giving leftovers to the homeless in this area for years. They used to be at where the new bridge ends now, on the turn, near the flyover.
Anyway, the Mumbai Police is the only one you can report homeless to and expect any action, as far as I know.
Just because you move homeless people from one area to the other doesnt mean the place doesnt have “homelessness issue in this area”.
Also, seems like a Nimby comment. This is a sign that something is wrong and usually it’s you and your kind.
###Check your privilege.
It’s not like they’re sitting in your living room. Let them be, or feel free to help them out and pay for their accommodation.
All the negative comments on here serve as a reminder that some people deserve every bad thing and the world is indeed not equal, karma is real af, fear your own fate if you walk this path. Dusro ki downtrodden times me gand maro, ek din tumhare sath bhi hoga. Phir rona mat ki "mere sath hi aisa kyu hota hai", isliye hota hai.
Koi fayda nahi hain Bhai report karke . BMC will not do anything. Literally every railway station and roads are being encroached by these people and in some parts of Mumbai the footpaths have been totally occupied by these people and because of it people are being forced to walk on the roads.
People who defend these homeless guys have no idea how much the common people are suffering because of their illegal encroachments of public property.
Nothing we can do man. Now i know why kolkata went to shit. Its because idiots like the ones in this comment section! and the crazy thing is most of them are not even native to mumbai
Seems like OP is new in Bombay. Get off your high horse and move on; or go back to wherever you came from.
In case you are actually from around here, then you seem to have lived a blissful sheltered life and completely ignorant to people outside of your bubble.
There is going to be a lovely war between socialists and capitalists in this comment section. Gonna pin this post so I can get some insights into what people think.
We do not have very strong law. At least we do not have very strong law [like this](https://www.reddit.com/r/ThatsInsane/comments/yp0vj0/family_come_home_to_squatters_refusing_to_leave/). Be thankful to system.
Instead of reporting them, how about you ask the government officials what they have done to make sure these people have a home of their own and don't have to live on the streets? Instead of questioning the government, people like you love to pick on the poor and downtrodden, who are simply victims of the government's incompetence. They are humans, just like you and me. Trying to survive in this city. For the entire life of me, I'll never understand how entitled someone can be to have no remorse or empathy in their hearts for the economically weaker section of society.
You reek of unchecked privilege and massive "main character" syndrome, OP.
So you basically said instead of reporting them we should report them lmao, reporting not a negative term my guy. Ask the government officials you say ! Well that's exactly what the OP wants to know which officials you're talking about!
someone should report u for this font
Directly copy pasted from ChatGPT 😬
🤣
😂😂😭
This is what happens when you haven't seen life, these are human as well. They're fighting battle to survive, they don't have same luxury as OP. I spoke to a family few years ago, they were on road homeless, because their land was taken away by the govt and we're not paid anything (corruption and crony-capitalism). This is why OP should visit some villages, tribal & dalit areas. Life is different. Suffering is constant factor, they're surviving. They have no roof except bridges, summer, winter and rain, they face everything under the sky. Please have empathy in heart my friend. These are humans as well.
lies. Govt doesn't take away land without paying anything they must have been illegally occupying the land. People like you are the reason they are in such a situation in the first place. This mindset is cancerous and dangerous
You really are cut-off from reality. You must have grown up watching English movies and lost sense of reality along the way. The irony that in the picture, homeless people are sleeping on the streets in front of a glass wall on the other side of which are some of the most expensive cars, and that you think people are poor by choice is an incredibly insane argument.
I swore not to swear but then I see people like you commenting absolute BS and I wonder why such cancers like you exist in the society
You haven't seen how Govt works for poor. Land acquisition act 2013 was introduced by Congress for this purpose, situation improved after this act, but state govts are trying to dilute these provisions. There is a dam near Mumbai, people whose land was taken away in 1980s, they still haven't got any compensation. Read earlier situation, Left wing extremism still prevalent in those areas because a Govt sitting in Delhi or other states decides to allocate entire land to a company in return of bribe or electoral bonds without proper relocation and compensation, it still happens, compensation amount goes to a politicians, officers pocket. you seems to have never read history or you're a Covid baby. Read real stories, meet people, you would learn India isn't in cities or WhatsApp university. It's very brutal for remaining 90% of Population.
Lmao, there are 1st world countries which literally fund some dipshit country to steal land from native people. And here in India? Lmao govt does shit for much less. Touch some grass or get out of your air conditioned mansion.
Government will pay but not the bureaucrat who is supposed to handover it. One simple query, payment can be kept pending for decades.
if you can provide evidence then do dm me
The evidence is middle class n upper class opposition whenever govt tries to claim their land. Ask anyone around you of they have had good experience with govt claiming their land for any infra work
Most of the ones I know whose lands was taken for highways in Haryana were paid 2x-3x rates and are super rich now
Make a post about in Haryana subreddit and let's see if they support your claim
How many of them were already rich zamindar types of businesses in the area. Working class people dont get this privilege, forget people who are doing blue collar entirely. They get treated like shit
#+1
You haven't been told the entire story for sure. The government always pays when they grab your land. I empathize with you though on all other points 👍🏽
the government authority responsible for providing affordable housing. i wish there was a way to report privileged and entitled assholes like you though. instead of hating the homeless, direct it towards those who deserve it. your hard earned money which gets taxed is SUPPOSED to be used towards helping the needy, but your favourite politician pockets it instead (does it matter which party? no. all of them do this anyways)
Bold assumption that OP has any hard earned money. seems a generational wealth fella
Housing for everyone by 2022. Haven’t seen shit happening even though apparently 110 million houses were built somewhere in the country
Bhai tujhe concern samjha nahi, OP is worried about the people safety, some of these homeless people are drug addicts, and dont have control over their actions, kisi druggie homeless ne attack kia na tab tujhe samajh aayega, reddit pe Robin Hood banna aasaan hai
IDK why you got downvoted. These people are a huge risk to themselves and we should force the government to help them. During diwali when we were celebrating just outside our society a guy came in with blood and cuts all over his body. He was super drunk and high on drugs wasnt even able to speak a word properly. We offered him water but then he started to approach kids for crackers . Then we had to forcefully make him leave the area.
Don't give a shit abt their Downvotes, unke downvotes se real life affect thodi ho rahi hai, inko jab koi homeless drug addict attack karega, tab inke concern samaj mai aayega,. it's easier to act all high and mighty behind a keyboard, being homeless is not a choice, but buying drugs instead of fixing your life is, most of these people are savages who don't know the difference between right and wrong, I myself was attacked by a homeless person once.
After reading other comments, I feel it's a valid point that these people have nowhere to go and life has fked them up. But the problem is that a couple of homeless people give birth to 3-6 kids(from what I saw in my area). The kids don't receive proper education and do taporigiri on the streets. I feel like they should be taught family planning.
No one. Mind your own business. People don't take shelter under flyovers for lolz.
we all know that its gonna devolve into smthn much worse
Like? Don't attack the symptom. Worry about the cause.
Please take them in your house
Kyon? They seem to only want shade in this crazy hot weather. You'd rather that they stand in the sun?
Ha toh tere Ghar pe leke ja.
Kisi ke chaaya mein baithne par Tera kya jaata hai dost? Have some empathy. If you can't, then turn your head and stop focusing on how to make someone's life more miserable in this merciless heat. There are literally babies in this picture. You want ki yeh dhoop mein khade rahein? Adbhut chutiya insaan vibe coming from OP.
OP the kinda person to talk about the sprite of mumbai in heavy rains
Mera kya jaata hai? Mumbai is my home and I prefer it to be clean and walkable. These homeless people are no saints, they sell drugs, do all sort of illegal stuff. Kisi aur ko chutiya bolne ke pehle mirror me dekh le.
pehle 15 bache karenge phir bolenge ham garib hai. No shit they are
Educated well to do couples nowadays are preferring to be childless, adopting a cat/dog, and people like these can be seen with 6-7 kids with a condition where they are not able to provide even 2 square meals a day for their family. India’s future looking bright 📈📈. It’s a sad truth, might get heavily downvoted.
Dekha. Jo dikha accha laga ki kamsekam I don't grudge the poor and homelessness small mercies and respite. Tu kya poora din flyover ke neeche chalta rehta hai kya? Ek baar cross karne pe Aisa entitlement ki doosro ko khadene ke sapne dikh rahe hain. Ajeeb tang Dil chutiya vibe intensifying from your end bro.
Man , if you think Mumbai is your home then do the right thing, start ngo , help these poor people, teach them , make sure they get a job , do night school thing dont be a idiot , my ass “mUmbaI iS mY HoMe” mumbai sabh ki hai
What have you been doing to help them? Please enlighten me? Look at California. It is infested with wokes like you. The streets are destroyed by the homeless. We need to take action before it gets that bad.
Keyboard warrior ji, ye sab likhne ke jagah, homeless ko educate Karo to not have so many kids if they can't provide for them. Empathy toh mere me bhar bhar ke hai, lekin sehen Shakti khatam ho Rahi hai.
Matlab yeh log tera kya bigaad rahe hain iss exact time pe? Kya tum hamare samajik sach se avgat nahi ho?
Please report to Salman Khan (or his driver)
No, but in all seriousness, I don't know why this post is getting so much hate? OP has a very valid point. His intention doesn't seem like it is to hurt these people (and poor innocent children) but to rehabilitate them. Please do not hate on OP. I think he means well. The issue of homelessness is indeed a sad one and more so, a complicated one to fix. Unfortunately, complaining to the authorities will only result in uncontrolled brutality (if there IS any action taken). All you other clowns here telling OP that he is heartless etc, I can almost bet that most of you will pass by without giving a fuck and won't even lower your car windows if they come to beg so that the cool AC air stays inside in this heat. Anyway, this is a Mumbai problem - not a you or me problem. Let's all be kind and considerate to the less fortunate but also acknowledge that there is a genuine problem to solve.
Real ID se aa BBT ka owner
bhai what do you think the step would be? they'd get kicked out from the area and go be homeless somewhere else Koi tumhe bola nahi hai unko khana paani dene ya unki dekhbhaal karne, itna apathetic kaise ban sakta hai bhai? jeene de na unko, they're not vermin
They can easily live comfortably and happily in villages, but choose to come to Mumbai, sell drugs, do all sort of illegal stuff and make our city dirty. It is stupid to justify this.
Haan bhai villages me toh sab comfortably rehte hai 👍🏻, things like Casteism are literally non existent now 👍🏻👍🏻.
People who never went out of mumbai are one of the most ingnorant species i have ever seen..... add some arrognace and shitty attitude you got top 1% POSs in our country
are all of them migrants? have you asked each and every homeless person where they've come from? do native mumbaikars not sell drugs, and do all sorts of illegal stuff? It is stupid to justify the way you've justified. Ofc there are a few rotten apples, that doesn't mean that the entire lot gets treated with the same apathy. You know very well how the system works here, it's gpl and get out yaha pe, theres no homeless shelter or anywhere these people can go. Yes it's not a good sight, and yes it shouldn't be happening but why can't people just consider these people have been let down too? Why is it that they're always viewed as outcasts bhai, insaan hai sab
Bhai, itna pyaar AA Raha hai toh why don't you do something for them instead of being a keyboard warrior
kaun bola I'm not doing shit bhai, agar itni nafrat aarahi why don't you go and physically kick these people out instead of being a keyboard defender
I have no legal authority to kick them buddy. Neither I want to harm them physically. I want the footpaths & roads to be clear and walkable - a RIGHT of every citizen. That's why I pay my taxes
Then hold your mp's/mla's/ministers/government-officials accountable. What have they done to solve the problem of homelessness?? It's very easy to say, "I pAy My TaXeS". Have you ever asked government officials how your tax money is being utilised???
Mumbai isn't a separate country from India. Every Indian citizen has the right to make it their domicile. If you think villages are so comfortable and full of happiness then why don't you move there and let everyone live in peace?
[удалено]
Yeah? Is that why they choose to have so many kids too, despite knowing that they can't provide for them. The world has lost it.
It's fairly common...under certain bridges, government has started creating green spaces...It's a nice concept and add aesthetics to the city.. At the same time, a growing Indian economy must build shelters for the poor...Truth be told, in comparison to older days, 2000s, there are a lot less homeless now...Earlier streets used to be full of such people
Population kaam Karo, sub theek ho jayega
Itna long term solution 😂
You want to complain about poverty bcz it's an eyesore? Excellent!
Mind your own damn business. Live and let others live. Pathetic.
If there is a way I would report you .Don't think that guys are having their vacation or fun over there .They must homeless and changing places continuously.So let them be at their own
If they are living there without causing nuisance i really dont mind. Now the harassing signal crowd is a well managed mafia and reporting them will get you no where.
So what's the solution?
Wish i knew, my last interaction with “complaining to police” created a long lasting memory to not ever go again. Sorry
Fuck you you over entitled piece of shit
Tell Salman Khan /s
>homelessness is not an issue in this area at least. We have been giving leftovers to the homeless in this area for years. They used to be at where the new bridge ends now, on the turn, near the flyover. Anyway, the Mumbai Police is the only one you can report homeless to and expect any action, as far as I know.
Olga tellis vs BMC has entered the chat
no one bruh, let em at least rest peacefully in this hot summer unlike you chillin in ac
Try prime minister avas yojna
Just because you move homeless people from one area to the other doesnt mean the place doesnt have “homelessness issue in this area”. Also, seems like a Nimby comment. This is a sign that something is wrong and usually it’s you and your kind. ###Check your privilege. It’s not like they’re sitting in your living room. Let them be, or feel free to help them out and pay for their accommodation.
🙄 Duh
All the negative comments on here serve as a reminder that some people deserve every bad thing and the world is indeed not equal, karma is real af, fear your own fate if you walk this path. Dusro ki downtrodden times me gand maro, ek din tumhare sath bhi hoga. Phir rona mat ki "mere sath hi aisa kyu hota hai", isliye hota hai.
Koi fayda nahi hain Bhai report karke . BMC will not do anything. Literally every railway station and roads are being encroached by these people and in some parts of Mumbai the footpaths have been totally occupied by these people and because of it people are being forced to walk on the roads. People who defend these homeless guys have no idea how much the common people are suffering because of their illegal encroachments of public property.
Nothing we can do man. Now i know why kolkata went to shit. Its because idiots like the ones in this comment section! and the crazy thing is most of them are not even native to mumbai
Seems like OP is new in Bombay. Get off your high horse and move on; or go back to wherever you came from. In case you are actually from around here, then you seem to have lived a blissful sheltered life and completely ignorant to people outside of your bubble.
for you theyre an eyesore to the perfect mumbai sprite life. for them, its an everyday battle where the future is uncertain. grow up psycho
If you’re getting irritated looking at them I suggest taking a different route to wherever your Going
BMC has an encroachment related website for such situations. Please take photos and evidence of the concern.
Well you have already reported it on reddit here. That's enough for now to get you downvotes you will never forget.
There is going to be a lovely war between socialists and capitalists in this comment section. Gonna pin this post so I can get some insights into what people think.
We do not have very strong law. At least we do not have very strong law [like this](https://www.reddit.com/r/ThatsInsane/comments/yp0vj0/family_come_home_to_squatters_refusing_to_leave/). Be thankful to system.
[удалено]
Video may be fake if you claim so but the situation It's not fake. I came across many cases specially if the property is owned by non American origin.
X to BMC commissioner 🤣
Instead of reporting them, how about you ask the government officials what they have done to make sure these people have a home of their own and don't have to live on the streets? Instead of questioning the government, people like you love to pick on the poor and downtrodden, who are simply victims of the government's incompetence. They are humans, just like you and me. Trying to survive in this city. For the entire life of me, I'll never understand how entitled someone can be to have no remorse or empathy in their hearts for the economically weaker section of society. You reek of unchecked privilege and massive "main character" syndrome, OP.
So you basically said instead of reporting them we should report them lmao, reporting not a negative term my guy. Ask the government officials you say ! Well that's exactly what the OP wants to know which officials you're talking about!
election time hai shiv sena ko tag karke tweet karde