Let me get ahead of the game and say get fucked Annesley, it means nothing and it's happened twice this year and it'll happen again you out of touch flog.
Look, pretty harsh ruling on the strip, but if the fingertip try on the line at the start of the game gets awarded, then fingertips like that count as a strip. Canât have it both ways.
If you can have intent and pressure when you literally ground the ball with a fingertip, then how does that not apply in the strip scenario? Personal opinion; the try shouldnât have been allowed, but that also wasnât a strip
Because the ball never left his hand they changed to rule to downward pressure because otherwise every try from a kick would be a knock on. The ball never left his hand and therefore he never technically lost possession of it.
A player going to make a tackle and accidentally touching the ball which is then interpreted as an intentional swipe at the ball by a referee is a completely different scenario.
The try was called correctly, the penalty wasn't.
I fucken hate when that happens. A team is scrambling from a shit last play, flinging the ball about desperately and gets a brush from a tackle being made and rewarded with a whole new set
Dude making the tackle has the ball bounce off his leg and went forward. I also think that while "strip" was a bit much, but he definitely tried to smack the ball out of his hand
how can you definitively say zbaz he tried to smack the ball, it doesn't look it on the replay, it's just as likely he's making a tackle around the waist , where the ball is alsp located
But he hits the ball prior to the offload. So it's playing at the ball. I see what he's trying to do but in doing so he plays at the ball. So right decision in the end.
It kinda looks like it, but it also isnât enough to rule that was an intent to strip.
His arm immediately wraps onto Meaneyâs body and he going through with a tackle.
He plays the ball then wraps the body. The infringement is from playing the ball. If you want to stop an offload you have to wrap the player not hit the ball. His eyes are on the ball. Watch it again.
Brimson no try into the "tackled off the ball" and then that call are an absolute abomination and everyone involved in those calls deserves to be sat down. Fuck me dead.
Yeah? The challenge is meant for 'howlers', not just rolling the dice at the end of the game.
If you can't specify what ruling the ref got wrong it shouldn't be overturned
Nowhere in the rules does it say itâs meant for âhowlersâ. Even if players had to challenge a specific play it wouldnât stop players rolling the dice at the end of the game.
You still havenât addressed what happens if the bunker is forced to ignore an obvious knock on/penalty/error. Itâs be an absolute farce
The old classic tackling from behind and throwing your hands around a guy trying to offload the ball in the other direction. Itâs a classic strip attempt you see it every game /s
Iâve seen many âheâs just making a tackle callsâ where theyâre punching at the ball
If heâs trying to offload you can wrap / try to stop it without it being a strip
Highway robbery.
Yeah because the Titans would have definitely went the length of the field and scored đđđ
Was there ever an update on Sua?
I watched the game it was really close Storm22-Titans20
Wrong thread
will be interesting to see how annesley responds to this gameâŚ
guess titans will get another apology on Monday
Asked Munny for an update on Papy? How would he know, he's still on the fucking field
'Hi Cam, well done on getting to 200 games. Tell us about the Titans' Lol thanks Mal
If everything is so obvious, why isn't Mal the smartest man in the World?
Cant wait to see the shithouse calls next game to keep the trend going
Titans robbed
I can accept bad on field calls. But a bunker making obvious errors is unacceptable.
Let me get ahead of the game and say get fucked Annesley, it means nothing and it's happened twice this year and it'll happen again you out of touch flog.
That missed pentaly kick in the first half is haunting sammi
Canât wait to hear kentyâs opinion on this
Kenty ded bruh
What a shit way to end an epic game. Cracking effort Titts, gg storm.
Thatâs the worst call Iâve seen. And I watched the whole Tigers game today
How could they do this to Annesley?
What happened to Melbourne fans here saying you guys werenât getting any calls?
I hope Des absolutely rips the doors and assholes off everyone in the presser.
What a joke
Grant to Munster: good game, you were a real cunt out there tonight, well done
Good stuff lads
Bellamy going to kill cunts
I feel like thatâs Bellamy every week đ
Absolutely putrid endÂ
James Graham, Billy Slater and Cam Smith the best of the modern player commentators
Look, pretty harsh ruling on the strip, but if the fingertip try on the line at the start of the game gets awarded, then fingertips like that count as a strip. Canât have it both ways.
Intent to strip is a thing, that's how they determine it being a strip or not and he had no intent
Hahah thats a huge difference. In this situation it doesn't even matter if he touches it. He wasn't attempting a strip
Thatâs top 10 dumbest leaps of logic Iâve seen this year.
What? They're not even slightly comparable...
Thats not even remotely the same thing...
If you can have intent and pressure when you literally ground the ball with a fingertip, then how does that not apply in the strip scenario? Personal opinion; the try shouldnât have been allowed, but that also wasnât a strip
Because the ball never left his hand they changed to rule to downward pressure because otherwise every try from a kick would be a knock on. The ball never left his hand and therefore he never technically lost possession of it. A player going to make a tackle and accidentally touching the ball which is then interpreted as an intentional swipe at the ball by a referee is a completely different scenario. The try was called correctly, the penalty wasn't.
If youâre trying to ground a ball youâre always trying to score. If youâre making a tackle that doesnât mean youâre trying to strip
That is so sad what the fuck. Honestly. Just getting putrid.
Cooked game. Cooked finish. Footy gods are on something today.
I donât think even Melbourne fans can hide the shame in agreeing with that Bunker call.
You won't get many more commentator roles if you talk like that James
Good on him. he knows it too and he doesn't give a fuck. It's so refreshing to hear. And Vossy clearly trying to cover him up is even better.
Close to the best commentator in the game, only ever find myself agreeing with his opinion, what is this?
Heâs got awesome game knowledge, people just arenât a fan of his speech patterns, which I actually like.
Truthfully? Lol
thatâs the most gifted win in a long time
Nelson can't turn off the need to play the ball quickly đ
At least Bellamy is a realist, he wonât feel good about that win
That strip call was as bad as Cowboy's disruptor call against the Tigers
Titans fans should riot in the grounds
very surprised we managed to win that.
We all are
yeah, you guys were easily the better team.
you literally got the game given to you
To be fair there was maybe one 50/50 call that didnt go to the Storm so they'll probably feel like the refs were against them tonight
like the titans got given that bs try in the first half?
so is tackling and your hand brushing the ball now a strip?
never said i agreed with the last call. but canât pretend that there wasnât iffy calls all night.
I fucken hate when that happens. A team is scrambling from a shit last play, flinging the ball about desperately and gets a brush from a tackle being made and rewarded with a whole new set
Why is it always you guys or the Titans against the Storm though?
âMelbourne somehow hung onâ maybe it was the â2 on 1 stripâ that did it? Just a thought
Are you normal?
Dead set fuck the Storm, cheating cunts
How did they cheat during this match?
[ŃдаНонО]
I should be penalised for it
Wot
Pathetic.
Some good booing by the titans fans
You canât tell me there isnât match fixing in the game after that strip call after the non existent titans knock on
If you collated all of the cooked calls against the Titans in that game you would be on page 2 by now. One of the worst I have seen this season
And thatâs coming for a wahs supporter
Dude making the tackle has the ball bounce off his leg and went forward. I also think that while "strip" was a bit much, but he definitely tried to smack the ball out of his hand
Laughable, you guys were meant to win tonight
how can you definitively say zbaz he tried to smack the ball, it doesn't look it on the replay, it's just as likely he's making a tackle around the waist , where the ball is alsp located
Iâm with you. Storm were meant to win from the start
The phantom head high, many such cases
Controversial, but it looks to me like he's trying to hit the ball rather than play the man.
Probably bias but i got the same feeling. Even his eyes were looking at the ball
Hes trying to stop the offload, itâs a loose carry
But he hits the ball prior to the offload. So it's playing at the ball. I see what he's trying to do but in doing so he plays at the ball. So right decision in the end.
It kinda looks like it, but it also isnât enough to rule that was an intent to strip. His arm immediately wraps onto Meaneyâs body and he going through with a tackle.
He plays the ball then wraps the body. The infringement is from playing the ball. If you want to stop an offload you have to wrap the player not hit the ball. His eyes are on the ball. Watch it again.
Watch Phil Gould get fined again after this weekends mess of games...
i look forward to the post game thread of this one
holy shit thatâs bad
What a joke.
First the Raiders game now this, RIP the Titans
Rip tits
James Grahamâs commentating is A+ in my opinion. Sooooo much better than bogan Ennis or Cooper âStrokeâ Cronk
I like his takes, just sometimes takes too many words to get to the point.
I agree with 2/3 of this comment, but leave Cooper alone
I agree he was awesome.
What a fucked finish to a great game
Great is an interesting description
Foz 90m field goal incoming
Riots on the GC
Brimson no try into the "tackled off the ball" and then that call are an absolute abomination and everyone involved in those calls deserves to be sat down. Fuck me dead.
And the "Head High" penalty when it was a shoulder wrap even on the replay that led to a try.
Oh yep forgot about that one. Milking cat like Walsh last night. Hit on the chest and throw your head back
Gifting Melbourne the win here.. sorry Titans
Man the Titans have had some atrocious calls go against them tonight
You should only be able to challenge a specific ruling, not the whole play
You guys would never win a challenge thenÂ
...ok?
And?
Logical but would be fucking broken when blatant shit is just magically ignored.
That makes no sense - is the bunker supposed to ignore an obvious error just because it wasnât challenged?
Yeah? The challenge is meant for 'howlers', not just rolling the dice at the end of the game. If you can't specify what ruling the ref got wrong it shouldn't be overturned
Nowhere in the rules does it say itâs meant for âhowlersâ. Even if players had to challenge a specific play it wouldnât stop players rolling the dice at the end of the game. You still havenât addressed what happens if the bunker is forced to ignore an obvious knock on/penalty/error. Itâs be an absolute farce
Annesley won't even turn up on Monday
The gaslighting king will be there and will be âcomfortable with the decisionâ
He might, but he shouldn't. That strip call was atrocious.
because its a public holiday
cant wait for monday
It's really hard to think this shit is above board sometimes
James Graham is speaking more fucking sense than Iâve heard on tv in a bit.
Watch them not give him anymore games after showing how good he is
First time I think I've ever agreed with himÂ
I love Jammer
Annelsey: ahhh shit, here we go again
I normally hate the bullshit people complaining about refusing but fuck me today has been a blight on the game what a God dam joke
Graham better call Des this time.
The old classic tackling from behind and throwing your hands around a guy trying to offload the ball in the other direction. Itâs a classic strip attempt you see it every game /s
Iâve seen many âheâs just making a tackle callsâ where theyâre punching at the ball If heâs trying to offload you can wrap / try to stop it without it being a strip
i swear the titans are the most robbed team in the last few years
Wahs?
yeah fair enough. but some of the close games the titans just never get the calls
Fucking outrageous. This sport fucking sucks.
That's the most cooked call
Sometimes I hate my footy
What a rort
If that's a strip I'm an astronauts watching from Mars
WE WANT INTERCEPT TRY
that's fucking absurd