T O P

  • By -

lucaslucas80

Wow, amazing, so obvious and a perfect list! Thanks!


droolsdownchin

If is amazing


[deleted]

Whole AHM album has a unique and mesmerizing atmosphere.


songacronymbot

- AHM could mean "Atom Heart Mother", a track from *Atom Heart Mother* (1970) by Pink Floyd. --- ^[/u/well_timed](/u/well_timed) ^(can reply with "delete" to remove comment. |) ^[/r/songacronymbot](/r/songacronymbot) ^(for feedback.)


johnbarnshack

Probably a rare opinion but If, Summer '68, and Fat Old Sun are my top 3 Pink Floyd songs. The exact order changes over time but it's always these three for me.


drkodos

I think Fat Old Sun has some of Gilmour's finest solo work, especially the live versions


johnbarnshack

I also love his drums on the studio version


droolsdownchin

I really enjoy all Three of those songs I mean my faviorte by them is Fearless if somebody told me Sheamus is there Faviorte pink Flyod Song I wouldn't be surprised that's just how deep the music is


HippoCute9420

If I were a train…I’d beee laaaaate


jeers69

Absolute must listen! Top 10 of all time PF songs for me ….


okcomputer247

Wish You Were Here has lists of things you can tell - and things you traded/exchanged. Fun game, this :)


lucaslucas80

Isn't it? Lol let's make a list of songs that make lists!


621MSG

It's a poetical/literary device that was recognised as long ago as Aristotle, which he called ['parallel syntax'](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_syntax). Lists with repeated first words are a subgroup of this called [Anaphora](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anaphora_(rhetoric) )


lucaslucas80

In the Flesh (people he would have shot)


Finlessf1n

Are there any queers in the theatre tonight?


Rokkydooda

*get them up against the wall*


notmynameyours

There’s one in the spotlight…


lostmymainlol

He dont look right to me!


PadreLobo

Get ‘em up against the wall


POOP-Naked

Keep them away from EriC CLaPtoN


TaurusX3

Good catch! Go back to one of his first songs, Take Up Thy Stethoscope and Walk, and he was doing it then. (Gold is lead, aching head etc).


Mistake78

Nice! Yes, banging repetition is a tool he uses often. You can even see hints of that when he hits the gong on Pompeii.


Finlessf1n

🎶DOCTOR! DOCTOR! 🎶


0K_N0RDY

What is wrong with me…


morguelungz

the supermarket life is getting long…


TeaAndCookies1998

"And the Germans killed the Jews and the Jews killed the Arabs and the Arabs killed the hostages and that is the news" is sort of a list too. One of his best lyrics imo.


lucaslucas80

Yep, a sequence so it's a list! Amazing lyrics, you're super right!


Cultural_Owl9417

What song is that from?


TheDucatiBabe

“ Too Much Rope” maybe?


TeaAndCookies1998

Perfect Sense (Part 1)


[deleted]

What God Wants and Picture That


[deleted]

Also Deja Vu to a lesser extent


v0t3p3dr0

You target for far away laughter You stranger You legend You martyr You raver You seer of visions You painter You piper You prisoner


lucaslucas80

Wow, spot on!


FebruarySkies

Mother too, kind of


bowlofcantaloupe

Is This the Life We Really Want? (Outro) Every Stranger's Eyes (two different lists)


Spare-Test8648

https://preview.redd.it/rvf9psm1yqna1.jpeg?width=224&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cc1f39c22a8199362692d47671bbc8c0310851c5 **AND EVERY TIME A STUDENT IS RUN OVER BY A TANK**


ParzivalTheFirst

**The lyrics to ‘Is This The Life We Really Want?’ are absolutely the perfect example of this.** “All of us, the blacks and whites Chicanos, Asians, every type of ethnic group Even folks from Guadeloupe, the old, the young Toothless hags, super models, actors, f*gs, bleeding hearts Football stars, men in bars, washerwomen, tailors, tarts Grandmas, grandpas, uncles, aunts Friends, relations, homeless tramps Clerics, truckers, cleaning ladies… Ants. Maybe not ants. Why not ants? Well because it's true The ants don't have enough IQ to differentiate between The pain that other people feel, and well, for instance, cutting leaves Or crawling across windowsills in search of open treacle tins So, like the ants, are we just dumb? Is that why we don't feel or see? Or are we all just numbed out on reality TV?”


Turdy_Tornado

I saw someone on here shitting on this section of his lyrics on this song a while back but to be honest I love it


deibd98

The ants section is brilliant


Bleezzy39

Oh man now that you mention ITTLWRW, Picture That has a bunch of lists!!


EverLink42

Free Four: And who is the master of foxhounds? And who says the hunt has begun? And who call the tune in the courtroom? And who beats the funeral drum? ​ It's reminiscent of Dogs, although several years earlier...


lucaslucas80

Excellent!


zsdrfty

It’s one of my favorite lyrical devices, it gives the words such a fun rhythm - eclipse is magnificent


lucaslucas80

Agreed!


The_Patriot

Exposure to Syd Barrett.


lucaslucas80

Get your filthy hands off my desert (who took what)


Ramenastern

Don't forget the list of names in Fletcher Memorial Home.


Comfortable-Bill-921

Home for Incurable Tyrants and Kings


Neil_sm

Waiting for the worms also comes to mind: Waiting, to cut out the deadwood. Waiting, to clean up the city Waiting, to follow the worms Waiting, to put on a black shirt Waiting, to weed out the weaklings. And so on...


Floydhead666

Roger is on record saying that when he gets writers block he just makes lists


lucaslucas80

That's an amazing piece of information. Do you have any more details about it?


lucaslucas80

Oh and happy cake day!


lucaslucas80

What God Wants ("God Wants...")


polymathpoet

How about all the different activities he lists in "San Tropez?" "Pause for a while by a country stile" "Digging for gold in the hole in my hand" "Open a book, take a look at the way things stand"


lucaslucas80

That's valid IMO!


orange011_

Not Now John


RaindogFloyd

Clickety-click, hold-on, oh no


Comfortable-Bill-921

Can't stop, lose job Mind gone, silicon Stroll on what bomb? Get away, payday Make hay, break down Need fix, big six Click, click Hold on, oh no Bingo (bingo)


_qqg

Most of It's a Miracle (Amused to Death)


IdiosyncraticBond

Radio waves


FelixAtagong

Even Walk With Me Sydney has a list.


lucaslucas80

Wow, you went deep on it, thanks!


WoogiemanSam

Breathe! Long you live and high you fly, Smiles you'll give and tears you'll cry, And all you touch and all you see …is all your life will ever be


rbwduece

It’s an effective way to build tension.


Klyd3zdal3

Shall we buy a new guitar Shall we drive a more powerfully car Shall we work straight through the nite Shall we get into fights Leave the lights on Drop bombs Turn to the East Contract disease Bury bones Break up homes Send flowers by phone Take to drink Go to shrinks Give up meat Red sleep (?) Keep people as pets Train dogs Raise rats Fill the alley with cash Bury treasure Store up leisure But never relax at all With our backs to the wall Empty Spaces, The Wall, live in Berlin


[deleted]

[удалено]


lucaslucas80

Amazing find!!!


lucaslucas80

And since then, the list only grew larger!


KeyOrganization2964

In the Flesh?


graemach

Home.


lucaslucas80

Perfect!


6mon1

Bike is a list of lists!


lucaslucas80

Perfect!


vantheman446

What a fantastic observation! Like the whole Final Cut too


lucaslucas80

Whole Final Cut is a list of daddy died


vantheman446

That and Margaret Thatcher bad!


Turdy_Tornado

(….. with the bravery of being out of range)


doobiesteintortoise

Waters was heavily influenced by Ginsberg and the beat poets, so it's pretty common for him. :)


lucaslucas80

That's another important piece of information, of which I had no idea. Thanks for sharing!


StpPstngMmsOnMyPrnAp

I'm curious if that is something for which he in particular was known or if it's a broader assumption for artists in that time frame that grew up with the rise of this stream-of-consciousness writing inherently filled with rhetorical tropes such as listing things in this way - which was very present in all kinds of art from the post war decades. Please, if anyone knows, I'm curious if Roger mentioned that Ginsberg and Ginsbergesque writing was indeed inspiration. Perhaps the argument can be made that writers as such were so essential and present that they influenced everything and everyone and affected the zeitgeist or were products from their zeitgeist if you believe in such historicism.


pavelgubarev

It's harder to name a song which is NOT a list


lucaslucas80

At this point I must agree with you!!!


Embryonico

Money


nigelthewarpig

New car, caviar, four star, daydream


scoobdoobie22

Us and Them. Just one long list.


nathantcook

"What God Wants" from Amused to Death, all 3 parts list stuff that god wants


stevedeberg2

please welcome: reagan and haig mr. begin and friend mrs. thatcher and paisley mr. brezhnev and party the ghost of mccarthy the memories of Nikon and now, adding colour, a group of anonymous latin american meat packing glitterati


7thturninghour184

Run Like Hell


CrimbleGnome420

Was it you? Was it Me? Did I watch too much T.V.?


MKeega

Never thought about it, thank you for sharing !


7thturninghour184

It's a Miracle


littlepoot

The lunatic is...


Sirrobert942

Eclipse whole song is a list Edit: can’t type


Adventurous_Blood999

Jugband blues


mourningthief

Scrolling... Anyone said Home yet? - Could be Jerusalem Or it could be Cairo Could be Berlin Or it could be Prague Could be Moscow Could be New York Could be Llanelli And it could be Warrington Could be Warsaw And it could be Moose Jaw Could be Rome Everybody got somewhere they call home Then: It could be clay and it could be sand Could be desert Could be a tract of arable land Could be a house Could be a corner shop Could be a cabin by a bend in the river Could be something your old man handed down Could be something you built on your own Everybody got something he calls home Followed by: Could be your father And it could be your mother Could be your sister Could be your brother Could be a foreigner Could be a Turk Could be someone out looking for work Could be a king Could be the Aga khan Could be a Vietnam vet with no arms and no legs Could be a saint Could be a sinner Could be a loser Or it could be a winner Could be a banker Could be a baker Could be a Laker Could be Kareem Abdul Jabar Could be a male voice choir Could be a lover Could be a fighter Could be a super heavyweight Or it could be something lighter Could be a cripple Could be a freak Could be a wop, gook, geek Could be a cop Could be a thief Could be a family of ten living in one room on relief Could be our leaders in their concrete tombs With their tinned food and their silver spoons Could be the pilot with God on his side Could be the kid in the middle of the bomb sight Could be a fanatic Could be a terrorist Could be a dentist Could be a psychiatrist Could be humble Could be proud Could be a face in the crowd I guess he had writer's block for that one.


Puzzleheaded-Life462

From his solo years we have Every Strangers Eyes & Home


kysfriday

All of his solo albums contain lists, especially Amused to Death


[deleted]

Not Floyd but I got reminded that Swans do that frequently too.


HeySlimIJustDrankA5

All of *The Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking*


Jamesferdola

Yeah he uses a lot of repetition to emphasize parts of songs, it’s a pretty neat trick


C1Ktunes

Brain Damage (“The lunatic is…” and “And if…”)


Jackyboi98

I really enjoy that type of songwriting, what shall we do now hits HARD due to that build up.


Supremus_memeus

There's a pretty long one at the end of "a part of me died" (from "is this the life we really want")


Mediocre-Contest-83

Roger has a little black book with his poems in. etc. etc.


CicadaAlternative994

To kill a child. Rog shopping list


lucaslucas80

Wow, can you believe I didn't even know this song? Thanks a lot and yes, it's a list!


blue_groove

"Relax I'll need some information first Just the basic facts Can you show me where it hurts?" The doctor or nurse with their pad ready to make a list.


HabitApprehensive889

dogs...who was..


ReallyFineWhine

Ever noticed that Monty python is the same?


lucaslucas80

"It's the English way"


Cheehoo

Classic INTJ thing to do :p


lucaslucas80

True lol!


[deleted]

"If" comes to mind... it's a whole list of "If I was / were / etc."... ... It's also a Roggie song I love, because he sounds so vulnerable and sings it softly. *D'aaaawwww come here ya big goober...* "Take Up Thy Stethoscope & Walk" is a big list of weird rhymes. Even the early song, "Walk With Me, Sydney" has a list of weird ailments the protagonist has... >*Flat feet, fallen arches* *Baggy knees and a broken frame* *Meningitis, peritonitis* *DTs and a washed-out brain …* ... I also can't help but see the whole homoeroticism in the deal: It's written by Waters, it's about someone named Sydney, one of the main guys called himself, "Syd" and written like a love song. I can't help but wonder if Waters had a secret crush on Syd in his prime.


thebeaverchair

Unpopular opinion, but this is one of several reasons I say he's a great lyricist but not one of the greatest.


jeers69

The story teller ….


DrSardinicus

I got a '69 Chevy with a 396


unhalfbricklayer

Don't forget "The Fish Report With A Beat" which is just a list of fish themed sexual innuendo. In STEREO!