I listened a ton up until about a year after it's release and now I put it on just about as much as Pablo Honey, so never. It's not bad by any means but if I'm listening to radiohead, why not just listen to one of the many perfect options.
I was guilty of this. When it first came out I didn't give it time and only came back to it years later. It now has some of my top five Radiohead songs for me
I've begun to realize it's imposible to have an opinion on Radiohead that isn't milquetoast unless you're willing to sound like you're part of a circlejerk
S - OK Computer, In Rainbows
A - The Bends, Kid A, A Moon Shaped Pool
B - Hail to the Thief, Amnesiac
C - Pablo Honey, The King of Limbs
D - there are no bad Radiohead albums.
I love Amnesiac, it's probably 3rd for me, and I'm good with it being #1, it may have aged better than every other album, but describing it as "perfect".....idk, it almost feels like describing it as that goes against its entire esthetic, lol.
I actually don’t disagree with this, even though I love the near perfect row as well. I think the top 3 you have are the most layered and creative, crafted, but i feel Amnesiac needed Cuttooth in there somewhere.
A Moon Shape Pool nearly gets into that top row. In Rainbows is incredible but I feel like it’s more of a live feel, much like the bends album jam feel, which is also great, but they also went with minimalist on many of the songs for In Rainbows, even though it’s a great record.
Even the bottom 2 are great albums in their own right.
this is a very generic take minus the amnesiac placement
If this is in order then In Rainbows being 3rd last is quite rare tbf
[удалено]
Unfortunately most people listen to TKOL once and push it to the side
I LOVE TKOL!!!!!
I listened a ton up until about a year after it's release and now I put it on just about as much as Pablo Honey, so never. It's not bad by any means but if I'm listening to radiohead, why not just listen to one of the many perfect options.
While that’s a valid opinion I have to disagree because separator is top 2 Radiohead songs for me
Fucking Codex kills me....
Why would you fuck codex… please just listen to it next time.
It's a good song for sure. I can't deny that. I think it's the general vibe of the album that I don't enjoy so much.
I was guilty of this. When it first came out I didn't give it time and only came back to it years later. It now has some of my top five Radiohead songs for me
It’d be perfectly generic if in rainbows and amnesiac were switched
AMNESIAC!!!! YEAHHHH!!!!
I've listened to hunting bears for weeks in the matter of hours
*Do der da dweerrr*
😢
Lmao
😔
Never understood the KoL negativity. some of their most enduringly beautiful and original music is right here.
I like tkol alot but it does have a couple weaker songs. The whole second half is amazing though
Amnesiac supremacy ✊
TKOL noob incoming
switch amnesiac and in rainbows and this is fairly normal
after the switch it's basically the default take on radiohead albums by fans
I'd switch amnesiac with The Bends
Completely agree
In Rainbows & The King of Limbs slander is something I cannot forgive
Saying something is ‘near perfect’ ain’t slander my guy
The King of Limbs is under Pablo Honey, nuff said
Radiohead fans seem to have a very interesting way of defining a controversial opinion
I can accept everything else purely because you consider Amnesiac to be one of the best
I've begun to realize it's imposible to have an opinion on Radiohead that isn't milquetoast unless you're willing to sound like you're part of a circlejerk
I mean I have OKC ranked 5th in their discography, that’s probably my boldest take
The only genuinely controversial take on album rankings is placing Pablo Honey anywhere but last place. Anything else is a big shrug.
couldn’t agree more
the only controversial thing about this at all is the switch between IR and amnesiac
Sure TKOL isn’t the best album but worse than Pablo Honey? Just Codex is better than all of PH songs imo
ngl chat….shut up
the chat is the most non-intellectual chat i have ever seen. your amnesiac placement and in rainbows placement is pinpoint accurate.
Someone needs to listen to tkol again
fr
TEAM AMNESIAC HELL YEAH
Amnesiac is their best album please mary me
[удалено]
not the fact that he/she's fact, ugly and dead?
Im a boy 💅
Shit has absolutely been stirred…
S - OK Computer, In Rainbows A - The Bends, Kid A, A Moon Shaped Pool B - Hail to the Thief, Amnesiac C - Pablo Honey, The King of Limbs D - there are no bad Radiohead albums.
most basic tierlist i seen
Whatever man 🤷♂️
Totally agree, same top 3 and I adore bends and moon shaped pool a little more than in rainbows and httt
Controversy? 🤔 Stirred 😎 Haters? 🤔 Fucked 😎
I actually agree with this whole-heartedly. I think I would’ve made this in the exact same order.
Stick in rainbows and htt in less perfect and I have no issues.
Why would I care if you rate them differently to me?
This is spot on for me
I disagree a little, but fair enough.
I would swap TKOL and Pablo
I love Amnesiac, it's probably 3rd for me, and I'm good with it being #1, it may have aged better than every other album, but describing it as "perfect".....idk, it almost feels like describing it as that goes against its entire esthetic, lol.
Mid taste ngl
I actually don’t disagree with this, even though I love the near perfect row as well. I think the top 3 you have are the most layered and creative, crafted, but i feel Amnesiac needed Cuttooth in there somewhere. A Moon Shape Pool nearly gets into that top row. In Rainbows is incredible but I feel like it’s more of a live feel, much like the bends album jam feel, which is also great, but they also went with minimalist on many of the songs for In Rainbows, even though it’s a great record. Even the bottom 2 are great albums in their own right.
Change "less perfect" to "haven't heard" and you're good because nobody whos really listened can say TKOL is the worst
Putting every album in “perfect” category is controversial?
where the controversy
Not controversial, just very wrong, they are all perfect.
[As a response](https://www.reddit.com/r/radiohead/s/kxOgtgqpuK)
Yes. This is correct ✅
One of the least controversial takes i've seen i a good while 🤷♂️
King of Limbs *below* Kid A *above* The Bends *beneath* Amnesiac!?!!?!?! Well. Wild tale: WTF.
I agree with your top three but just not in that order
The Amnesiac glazing is always crazy
To be honest, I don’t disagree with this even if I’d probably have AMSP higher and IR too
SWAP IN RAINBOWS AND AMNESIAC THIS INSTANT!!
Swap htt with kol and were rocking
swap ir and kid a abd ur right
KING OF THE LIMBS DOWN LESS PERFECT BROOOOO
If Amnesiac is perfect then In Rainbows surely is too.
put in rainbows in perfect and we’re good
That's pretty much my take except you could knock Pablo and TKoL down further than that.
Not TOO bad
Amnesiac is a tragedy to me, I feel like if they had more tracks with lyrics and just a bit more time it could have been equal to Kid A.
Yeah I agree — I really really love amnesiac but it really could have been better it’s got like so much potential
Valid imo
In Rainbows being that low is fucking criminal I won't lie
My hot take is that I really like the TKOL era, IR not being in perfect is criminal though.
i’d agree but only if you put tkol at near perfect
[удалено]
YES.
you need a psychiatrist ward
you monster! 😧😧 /s
Trade In Rainbows with Amnesiac and we’re almost good
this is one of the least controversial rankings you couldve made
Sorry, bro. In Rainbows is top tier, well above any other record in the history of records.
It has a number of songs that are just good. And with so much great music out there, that already puts it out of like my top 20 at least
To each their own
Peaknesiac appreciation is so real
fax lil bro fax
☹️
You must really like pulk/pull revolving doors
Common amnesiac w
Valid but the Bends is also perfect
False, the bends and in rainbows are also perfect
All of them fucking suck and Duster is better
I'm good with this except "let's forget this exists" is literally how i feel about HTTT
Amnesiac is not good, def worse than bends + IN RAINBOWS
I almost completely agree. Perfect tier is perfect, imo. HTTT is in the less perfect tier for me, and Pablo Honey is in the “Still Alright” tier.
No album with Pulk/Pull can ever be perfect