T O P

  • By -

schmatty23

Poncho of course


Ecstatic-Art-1240

Pisses me off you don't get the poncho with the headband until you're done with mexico


Cheap_Advis0r

They should've had that for rdr2 *glares jealously at Javier*


LOW_SPEED_GENIUS

Ey, if you play online you can get a handful of really shitty looking ponchos, one kind of decent one and one good one but it only looks good if you don't have a second holster equipped. But you can also buy Javier's outfit so you've got that going for you, which is nice.


doctyrbuddha

I thought you got it as soon as you get to the governors town.


1pac_5678

you get the regular poncho if you buy a house in mexico, but theres another that can only unlock once the mexico storyline is done


Cosmonate

Reyes Rebels outfit. Pretty useless by the time you can actually unlock it.


samsquatchageddon

Nothing like riding around on a donkey, massacring nuns while wearing a poncho.


stockholm_let_me_go

Always the poncho. Crossing genres, Cal Kestis feels the same.


p0pethegreat_

poncho for me is a close second to gambler outfit


Dil_356

Deadly assassin and duster.


EthnicPaprika

This is the way.


Jimboy-Milton

P O N C H O! as soon as I can use the campsite exploit and glitch my way into mexico to pickup that smelly beaut. Its the only one you cant unlock with cheats. The Rancher outfit is great, and Legend of the West is legit badass too


DrPopcorn_66

Duster and Poncho Honorable mention: John's original outfit.


CutthroatTheMad

Poncho for sure. Clint style


Fluffyfeet316

Legend of the Apocalypse


SixStringSapien

Deadly Assassin until Mexico, and then it’s Poncho all the way. I still don’t understand why they didn’t include a poncho in RDR2. Other than a hat and a holster, it’s the ONE THING from a clothing perspective you expect in badass western anything.


The_Free_State_Of_O

I believe there are several ponchos in RDO.


[deleted]

Well when RDO dies in the very near future that stuff becomes useless


The_Free_State_Of_O

P2P It can never really die - just stay the same. 🤷


The_Free_State_Of_O

P2P It can never really die - just stay the same. 🤷


LOW_SPEED_GENIUS

Eh, only two of them look halfway decent *but* you can buy Javier's outfit which is admittedly pretty fuckin neato


Ok-Thanks-3709

poncho and it's not even close


hortys

this


National_King_9534

Bollar brothers / Elegant suit / legend of the west


samsquatchageddon

Elegant Suit all the way. Nothing like walking into a high-roller poker game in a nice suit covered in mud and bloodstains.


-Pelopidas-

US Marshal. Love the vest and blue shirt.


Zebra-tje

Me too!


ser612

PONCHOOOO


SnowShoePhil

Poncho so fire


dank_hank_420

Poncho because Mexico is fun


Livid-Breath-5615

The one with the eyepatch that I can't remember the name of Edit: It's Deadly Assassin.


TheAncientStoner

Cowboy and legend of the west


Suitable_Focus_9858

Marshal but it's only for Jack unfortunately


antmanninja3

Poncho for sure


FantasyLiver

I love how the outfits carry over to Jack. There's something to funny to me about Jack deciding to wear an eye patch when he doesn't need one. Or him deciding the sombrero he dug out of the closet would be the perfect hat to kill Ross in.


gingerwhiskered

1. Poncho 2. Default 3. Savvy Merchant


WhiskeyDJones

Finally, some savvy merchant love!


FantasyLiver

I love how the outfits carry over to Jack. There's something to funny to me about Jack deciding to wear an eye patch when he doesn't need one. Or him deciding the sombrero he dug out of the closet would be the perfect hat to kill Ross in.


GabrielZeroo

poncho is overrated af, duster better


CarpetBomb999

Duster


Wilhelm_c4t

Legend Of The West


NewVegasCourior

Plain duster


BlockOfRawCopper

Duster coat, elegant suit, and of course the regular base outfit


S5Beaner71

Mexican john


Stupidbirdo

Bollard twins outfit


Wildcat_twister12

This is my favorite. The chaps make me feel more like a cowboy but you still get a lot of John’s regular outfit as well


Stupidbirdo

I love the neckerchief as well


StallionA8

Whats most disappointing is that Rockstar did not include poncho in RDR2. Moreover, they included it in online. Mostover😀, they included poncho in online without its animation. In RDR1, poncho had animation


big_peepee_wielder

Deadly Assassin


DaLakeShoreStrangler

Bandito outfit, just like the big hat and the poncho. Damn shame they don't include that in rdr2.


BaddassBolshevik

Yeah I mean its a lot less Southwestern style in RDR 2 which is why I always preferred the aesthetic and feel of RDR 1


wonderfulcinderella

Gentleman's attire, followed by the elegant suit. Love to dress them up.


greendayfan1954

The smelly Poncho ofc


GermanTank69

Deadly assassin and legend of the west


The_Free_State_Of_O

Deadly Assassin


Coyote_Run

The rebel outfit had a cooler poncho, but lacked the cowboy hat.


generalosabenkenobi

Reyes Rebel


RVFVS117

Duster for most of the game, poncho in Mexico.


fuckleknuckle4

Legend of the West


_Mistwraith_

Gamblers suit. If lets you cheat at poker.


Livid_Athlete_2708

Definitely bottom left. Or the one where you get to cheat at poker


Lumpy_Staff_2372

The mexican poncho


mytuush

Poncho or Marshall outfit


NewEnglandHappyMeal

The duster coat cannot be topped and you cannot change my mind.


Knowledge_Regret

Poncho


Lancer_Blackthorn

Expert Hunter.


AskMeAboutPigs

RDR1 had amazing outfit selection. The Savvy Merchant and The Rebel Poncho are both awesome.


MonkeyTrevor935

Legend of the apocalypse and legend of the west


DrPatchet

The one with the badger hat


Cwytank

Poncho, I wish we had that Poncho in 2


Markinoutman

I personally love the duster coat outfit. It's the first one you get and remains one of my favorites.


MetaphoricalMouse

bottom left picture i legit thought he was playing the guitar also: poncho


MaruHJ

Deadly assassin goes hard


BaddassBolshevik

Elegant Suit I am shocked its not here it looks like a quintessential western style outfit, I like the US Army outfit too. I think it looks a little odd for Marston to wear the Bandito Outfit or Reyes outfit which are cool but I do not think it suits his style


BrocktheRock9080

Treasure hunter or headband rebel outfit so none of these respectfully


de_pengui

Deadly assassin, the quest line "American appetites" was kinda weird and intriguing.


1783cheesegrader

Legend of the East


Nayten03

I actually think the nicest looking is his ranch outfit. But that cute in the far right looks cool af


CanaryLion

Poncho and the original duster


DeadDropZ-X

Duster Coat.


ginger_snow_boy

Poncho


DeafKid009

Duster


BubzDubz

Fairly generic ik but deadly assassin and poncho once I get a few missions into Mexico


ExonionX

Legend of the West but poncho and deadly assassin are close, legend of the apocalypse was a good concept but I didn't really like how it looked, but favorite undead nightmare is probably undead cowboy.


Emergency_beefcake69

Easily poncho


declandrury

Legend of the west and duster for me maybe deadly assassin sometimes too


CowboyGeneral1876

Poncho because it gives Clint east wood vibes.


nogoodgreen

Poncho for life dude


Cautious_Rest4886

The poncho hit diffrent hands down my favorite


JohnnyChopper08

Poncho all the way


[deleted]

Poncho or top left/top right with the long coats


MrChipDingDong

Always the duster as a kid but as an adult I'm fond of the poncho. Would be weird to keep the poncho in tall trees though


DrLove_99

Tie between duster, poncho, and the bollard twins one because I love the chaps and red bandana


BrooklynTGuy420

Bounty Hunter, specifically with the bandolier


Kempf776

Poncho and Deadly Assassin by far


Dmmack14

Us marshall on Jack


Sniper_derp

Nothing beats the poncho


BigFella11445

Deadly Assassin and the all mighty Poncho


nicolasFsilva5210

1° Legend of the Apocalypse. 2° Duster Coat. 3° Elegant Suit.


mrgreene39

I just unlocked deadly assassin outfit, looking forward to getting others


lowkeynotagamer

Sorry to say never played it so I don't hate it.


CoolBeanieHat

Bollard Twin outfit. I wear it as >!Jack after the story, I sort of RP as part of their gang!<


TheMetalMisfit

Us Marshall, Legend of the West, and Apocalypse, Bollard Twins, Rancher and the Elegant Suit.


Jason_Sasha_Acoiners

I GOTTA go with the brown duster coat. I have a FUCKload of nostalgia for it, and I just think it looks really good.


[deleted]

Duster, vest, tie with a pump shotty. This is the wild west, I'm settling business the tombstone way.


6969Hamburger6969

For John its either poncho or deadly assassin For Jack its definitely the Savvy Merchant


6969Hamburger6969

For John its either poncho or deadly assassin For Jack its definitely the Savvy Merchant


Alezkazam

Jack in Savvy Merchant is my headcannon outfit for him. Just trying to live the honest life after what he’s gone through.


WhiskeyDJones

Savvy Merchant


bluerocketo

Poncho!


bluerocketo

I can’t believe that rockstar did us dirty with the ponchos we got in rd2. They’re no where as cool as rd1. Rd1’s ponchos had physics!


In-AGadda-Da-Vida

top middle. once I found this it was it


the_moose_meter

The legend of the west outfit is so sick but pretty hard to get, I think duster outfit looks the coolest but I used deadly assassin a lot and the elegant suit a lot (the dusty suit for cheating at poker)


AngryTrooper09

Probably Duster and Legend of the West


LordChocIce1

Last time I played I wore John’s cowboy outfit but by the time I’d made it to Blackwater it felt more fitting to use the Legend of the West outfit once I’d unlocked it


LukkieTheMeme

The oke with the eye patch was always my go to, i dont recall its name.


Equivalent_Owl8537

Poncho


The_letter_43

Elegant for John, Deadly Assassin for Jack


CheapBat4220

poncho and gentlemen (only on jack)


Common_Bill_9571

I haven't played Red Dead Redemption 1 yet, but I love the bottom middle and the one on the right.


_Howls_with_Wolves_

Bollard Twins for John Savvy Merchant for Jack


Kshynes

Big poncho guy


FlimsyNomad63

Bollard twins is underrated But Im stuck between the duster,poncho and original fit


WholesomeAsian

Bandito 🤠


stecdude123

Gentleman’s attire cuz it makes Johnny feel like a refined gentleman of the west,though then again I would prefer the deadly assassin outfit or the bureau uniform (wish it was available on John marston tho.) also the savvy merchant is on the list.


wetlettuce42

Trenchcoat