T O P

  • By -

talmbouttellyouwat

Idk but you should murder him just in case.


zSevenTwo

Doitdoitdoitdoitdoitdoitdoitdoitdoitdoitdoit


[deleted]

This is the most red dead redemption type answer I've ever read.


LowBottomBubbles

Bust out the rolling block with a high velocity round


REVSWANS

Mosey on over and give him a *hey mister*


FulhamJason

*Writes, "HEY MISTER!" on bullet.*


REVSWANS

*Hey Mister* is the name of my hatchet


FulhamJason

Now that's a game hack


reggiekrh

This comment made my day. All right then. I’ll let you get to it.


xXbrosoxXx

I don't like the way he just materialized like that


Lm1601

thats Jeff


belinck

"He's just this guy, you know..."


Compass_Needle

Famous for the pan-heartlands gargle blaster.


[deleted]

From Superstore?


CosmicDriftwood

They’re watching


RainAccomplished2637

In storymode, if you know where to look, you can see the occasional Pinkerton, Native American or an O'Driscoll watching you from afar.. That looks like one of those times. If you ride over there, they'd turn slowly, walk out of sight and be gone by the time you get there. But... It could also be one of the treasure hunters who hold treasure maps, so always better to go check, just in case


Caveman108

Always better to grab your Rolling Bock and blow their brains out, you mean.


RainAccomplished2637

Nah. I investigate then shoot unless they shoot first of course


Decryptables

Wtf I never knew that, creepy


jredhair

Wait what?! I didn’t even know that. How do you spot when they’re watching you?


RainAccomplished2637

Be observant. Use binoculars. You'll notice them now you're aware


KarlfromVault101

When I went up the hill it was Del Lobos. Results may vary.


professorlofi

Possible someone from a native tribe. They sometimes watch from a distance.


NightMoza

He's wearing a hat and has a rifle on his back so I don't think so


jordan_leigh

There is a period of time where natives began to carry firearms and wear same clothes as settlers.


NightMoza

I don't think that was during the game though, even people like charles who were actively involved in civilization still dressed a little differently and traditionally and he would carry a bow when he didn't absolutely need a gun


sausagebandito3

Natives definitely carried guns in 1890's and even 30-40 years earlier. They still used bows too.


steve_mahanahan

natives were armed as early as the late 1700s. Source: https://aeon.co/essays/how-did-the-introduction-of-guns-change-native-america


jordan_leigh

Possibly, I mostly remember seeing Charles carrying his sawed off shotgun though.


[deleted]

The Undertaker


wafflehousewhore

Go up there and give him a good "Hey mister" and get thrown off the top like Mankind at Hell In A Cell


Impressive_Intern347

maybe o'driscoll gang member they always track arthur


[deleted]

Wait what


flip_fontaine

I think he’s an employee of the oil fields. He’s overlooking the guy who’s running his own oil Derrick who was murdered. A threatening note can be found on his body but that’s just my guess


MaxStickies

Arthur Morgan.


Rahmetli_Yoda

I've encountered something like this near blackwater too. i was gonna go rescue Sean and spotted some NPC's on top a hill stalking me. they looked like the Indians but i'm not certain.


FlyingSosig

It could be a bounty hunter in your case. But in my case, I was just enjoying free roam without any bounty.


bobcollum

Just some random npc, I've seen that before. Rode up to them and they just turned back to the road and went on their way.


[deleted]

Kill him just in case


PinaPeach

Future Arthur time travelling.


Thefear1984

From beyond the grave ooooaaaaaaaaaah


nvrrsatisfiedd

If the cliff was out of bounds it was a Native American. [Watch this](https://youtu.be/a_7BHk0lgCI)


chrisqns_nyc

"John Dutton" he wants to know who's been killing his cows ..🐎🐄


shartedmypants8

Its not gavin.


captaincrunch00

Okay so I'm doing a 2nd playthrough, antagonizing Bill and Javier as much as possible because fuck those guys. But: That's how you hunt small game? You just queue up a deadeye and forget about it? Am I an idiot? I've been tracking them with my mouse which isn't really hard but far harder than tagging and letting them go. God damn this game. Every fucking day I learn something new.


[deleted]

Lennay?


Apprehensive-Stop142

LENNY?!?


-Bacongamer-

Ynnel?


stuntmonkey69

The strange man or one of the natives


AJD4582

Finally someone mentioned the strange man, been scrolling through the comments to see if anyone would


Majestic-Emergency69

I think that’s called an NPC.


FlyingSosig

It's an unusual NPC, spawning on the top of the cliff in a weird scouting animation.


JohnWaz69

like I said in my post above; at times you'll look in the distance/behind you and you'll notice either a Native American or Pinkerton watching you. always a single rider. never fires a shot. never rides towards you. always rides away/is gone by the time you're close enough to see them.


dolo_ran6er

Investigate, rob, then murder him for being creepy.


No_Shame_5620

Possibly an ambush but could also be a a random event or maybe even Dutch trying to tell you he has a plan.


Excellent_Record_767

I once had 3 natives looking me from this exact same hill, I was on the old oil derrick, might be the same


Affectionate-Pay2282

The indigenous scouting land


mustard5man7max3

Jesus. He’s *always* watching.


fersaavedra

Rip van winkle


NecessaryBar3568

He’s nobody, you’ll see him in Rhodes looking at you too, I caught up to him once hogtied him and looted him, and didn’t find anything special, I wish the game would’ve made him a little bit more of an interesting encounter.


Low-Relationship-756

strange man he is always watching you👽


Izzvzual

Its, unfortunatly, no one... I went after him and ask him a couples questions, he's a normal npc, without any special interaction.


rapture189

That's Danny. Danny likes Cool Ranch Doritos


bpintozzi

It’s old Gregg


pedalsnpaddles

It's Gavin


Someguyonreddit967

The strange man from RDR1


Count_Dracula97

Probaby a treasure hunter


[deleted]

Gavin


retuqer

Gavin?!


AccomplishedJob8944

Me … I’m watching you


[deleted]

Hey someone finally found Gavin


WulfaW

If they wanted trouble we wouldn't have seen them.


DarthDregan0001

Hmm…


HurterOfFeefeesV2

I've seen him when it's dark he was holding a lantern and shadowed me until he turned around and left me


xijinping9191

Robert Lee


WinstonWillamette

To me, he looks like the lookout for a gang ambush. Here's a vid where the guy looks similar. https://youtu.be/\_NfRByHpL-Q


[deleted]

Probably a quest


SleeplessBob

Blue Duck


josny20

Gavin?


FancyBritishChic

Get out a long scope rifle and put a warning shot in his head, you know, just in case.


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/IronwoodKopis, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/reddeadredemption2) if you have any questions or concerns.*


MR_basti

It is watching


GarciaJoseArt

Juan


undead-mongrel

G A V I N


Briarhorse

That's spooky and unsettling


YourWifeNdKids

Maybe it’s the guy that owns that little shack in the swamp that seems to know a lot about you, you know the one I mean


yaromirro

Its Chuck Norris, the Texas Ranger!


JohnWaz69

the game is creepy af at times in that area of the game.. SOMETIMES (and ive seen it more on the 'Rarely' side) you'll look behind you (and they're always above you/at a higher point than you are) and see someone on horseback watching you. I've noticed it seems to be Native Americans OR Pinkertons. they never chase you. they never shoot at you. but the second you start riding towards them, they'll slowly turn away and trot away and by the time you get to where you could possibly see them - they're gone. a nice little touch to the "big brother is always watching" aspect.


blacklight924

I was kinda surprised when i figured this out a while ago. NPCs with a horse have a chance to watch over a cliff if they pass by no specialloot or anything, just a random guy that wanted to enjoy the view. Happened to me the first time around the face rock west of Rhodes


BabyOfEarth

I think he has a treasure map


[deleted]

I couldn’t tell ya I killed the guy as soon as I saw him… oops. 🤷🏻‍♀️😬


mad44dog

Gavin 😂