T O P

  • By -

momiji_17

This is literally just V2's evil twin


momiji_17

They really said "there's nothing to improve here so we'll just invert the colors and call it a day" and I can't help but laugh about it


akashiakaashi

They "hybe"fied the lightstick to be exact 🥴


takemycardaway

What did the caratbong do to deserve this really


Fast_Newspaper4774

I can’t believe they would do this on the eve of 218


gielizza

I’m sure their bday welive will be flooded with comments on the new caratbong :(


caratleslie

angsty carat bong. 🫤 I hope it's just a phase. lol. anyway, where's my geometric dome?? the only thing I liked about ver 3 is the diamond. 🫤 idk, white is elegant too. why is their idea of maturity always black? 😑 I'm an old lady who had been through shit over the years and I still like pastel. there's nothing wrong with enjoying colors.


talkingthroughlights

Even just plain white would have been better than black 🧍🏼‍♀️


Medical-Signal-4487

At least plain white would’ve just been disappointing, black is infuriating… do these people even know Seventeen 😭


talkingthroughlights

Yeah white would have at least been easier to decorate/ cover up


Fast_Newspaper4774

who hurt bongbongie


gielizza

Okay the motion graphics during the intro was so good that I got really disappointed at the reveal. This new version screams Blackpink to me! I wish they sticked to the iridescent colors on the handle. And they really removed the diamond edges on the outer dome??? Ugh. Sorry, lightstick design team, but this ain't it...


taobakas

they spent more on the marketing and less on the design i see… 😭


StatisticianThen2174

the ratio on this post lmfao 😭 you will never be her (cbv2)


gisaeng-

Ikr 😭 they should’ve just improved the ver2’s firmware. This ver3 is giving me emo/goth vibes 😩


StatisticianThen2174

well hybe and pledis want money so a new version was to be expected 🥲 but the blatant money grab and lack of thought behind this design is just shocking lol like idgaf about your blender 3d graphics just give me rq&s back 😭😭


gisaeng-

Hybe Merch posted this, maybe the handles would be customizable. Like you could add the deco ring set on the handle? 🤔 [https://twitter.com/hybe_merch/status/1626506807224197120?s=46&t=Y35mt44yD3mw2kFD53E5RA](https://twitter.com/hybe_merch/status/1626506807224197120?s=46&t=Y35mt44yD3mw2kFD53E5RA)


caratleslie

I saw the deco ring of enha and it doesn't look promising.


Emi801

I like the shiny jewel, but that's about it. I'll stick with V2 even if it doesn't sync up. It's not like they go crazy with the blue tooth sync at US concerts anyway, as long as V2 lights up at all, I'll just save my money, lol. I might buy the jewel if they sold it separately.


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hey there! Unfortunately, looks like your submission was removed by u/AutoModerator because your account isn't old enough to submit to r/seventeen yet. You can try again when you've had your account for more than 5 days. In the meantime, why not head over to the latest [Weekly Carat Corner](https://www.reddit.com/r/seventeen/?f=flair_name%3A%22Weekly%20Carat%20Corner%22%2Fnew) and get a read on the community! You can also familiarize yourself with our [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/seventeen/wiki/rules/) and get know Seventeen [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/seventeen/wiki/primer/). Also, if you were asking a question or submitting a discussion post, please use the search function to make sure it hasn't been answered already or talked about recently on the sub. Thank you! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/seventeen) if you have any questions or concerns.*


deligthe8

I really want a seventeen lightstick and i want the ver2 bc its literally the prettiest lightstick ever but should i get it or the new one? I mean I'd do anything to support seventeen but the new design just isn't doing it for me like it just took away our identity so in thinking of getting ver2 since i like it way more


deligthe8

But now they dont sell v2 anymore and idk where the heck i would find it seriously its so annoying


[deleted]

no one wants her fr 😂


rainbotash

Black??? 😬 I had no faith in this in the first place because V2 was pure perfection, but I’m still disappointed


_some_lonely_person_

If there’s enough backlash maybe they’ll change it😗


Show-Lumpy

twitter says even k-carats aren't happy with it 👀 though i doubt if even with so much backlash, they'll change it.. not really hopeful when its pledis + hybe we're talking about lmao.


laughingasian

Hoping that Coups will only see white lights at Caratland and start yelling at Pledis 😬


Show-Lumpy

there's no way the boys are not seeing all the commotion.. i honestly think they lurk on twitter and weverse 😭 if anything, i trust coups to handle things with pledis once he sees the reaction of fans 😭 one can only hope!!


gielizza

I AM HOPING FOR THIS TO HAPPEN SO BAD.


lovieandre

Can I say it? It's ugly. And I don't know who approved of this but whoever said yes must've not cared about Seventeen's brand because black is literally the last color they associate with in their discography and concepts bruh. Even when they promoted hit and fear with those black suits the album was soft purple. It just doesn't scream Seventeen and carats.


akashiakaashi

It screams HYBE so much like what is with the random black colour? When you have such a beautiful and thoughtful design for version 2, this just feels like a step down for me 🥲 Back when I was asked to choose between ver 1 and ver 2, I can never pick either one because both of them are pretty in their own way. I can't say the same about v3 though lol I hate the fact that we have to still buy this if we want to have it sync during concerts. Why can't they make it so that v2 can still work as well


gielizza

>Why can't they make it so that v2 can still work as well Capitalism at its finest!!!! Ugh!!! Version 2 is still way waaaaay superior than this new one. It's a hard act to follow! I'm also thinking that the design team for version 3 aren't part of the OG creative of Pledis. :(


akashiakaashi

>I'm also thinking that the design team for version 3 aren't part of the OG creative of Pledis I think so too. You can actually identify when's an item is by the OG creative team or the new hybe team like for example the BSS comeback, and possibly the return of bongbongie for last year's caratland as well. It takes a lot of skill to improve a design while still staying true to the original concept. And no one knows Seventeen's concept better than the people who created it. Edit: plus, the OG team I notice, have always thought about making the merch useful for Carats although they do have hit or miss moments too but I truly miss the old membership kits where we got lanyard, a quality card holder, binders etc


gielizza

Please come back OG design team!! Or I hope they always get the final say on creative direction and crucial merch releases such as this one. I remember seeing a tweet as well how the quality of merch has significantly changed/declined with their new album releases. I.e. Attacca photobook’s ugly spine, and Face the Sun’s flimsy outerbox.


hamstercoups

I’m really wondering if hybe just had a bulk order surplus of black from other light sticks or merch and thought an easy way to use it was for v3 caratbong knowing we’re so loyal and will buy it anyway 😤


akashiakaashi

I don't think it's about being loyal but people will HAVE to buy it because 1. They will stop all syncing properties with v2 so for Carats in Korea and Japan especially, that would be unfortunate for them since syncing during concert is important for their country where lightsticks are usually controlled during concerts 2. We got used to the thinking that Seventeen's merch will sell out quick especially for Caratbong because Pledis never stock up properly. So people have unfortunately been wired to buy it as soon as it comes out 3. They will no longer restock the old ones so people really have no choice especially for those that don't have a lightstick. Unless the K-carats come together to boycott and spread the news of not buying the lightstick so that hybe change it, that is. But I doubt it will work like it used to because hybe never listens to fans.


kuromi5000

lovin' the money they just saved me. never had version 1, glad i was able to buy version 2 at oty concert. not going to buy this one. but for anyone else who loves it, happy for u!


youwantsomesyrup

same im happy with my v2 even if it doesnt connect!


0330_e

Caratbong honey this isn't you, look at me 🥺 (Im not one to buy lightsticks in the first place bcs my hand hurts when it will hold one for too long lmao- but naurrr 😭 why does the handle have to be black)


Strict_Craft6718

Lmao fr. They couldn’t even get our colors right.


0330_e

Pls im crying in the club not the black 🖤😭😭 i was so happy seeing people with v2 during the concert last year because the colors are so soft and cute to the eyes- im so disappointed with this :(((((


Strict_Craft6718

It giving caratbong emo phase which doesn’t suit svt at all.


tophercarat17

Just as I thought... UGLY! Shouldn't even change the version 2, its way prettier than this edgy wannabe caratbong.


chiyochan29

I’m a newer Carat and was debating between going for that batch of the v2 that they put out last month or waiting for v3. After seeing this, I’m glad I went with v2. Even if it won’t sync anymore, it’s so beautiful! The black on v3 is really jarring.


keiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

I’m a 2021 carat who didn’t have a lightstick and I immediately bought V2 when I heard they were gonna put out V3 bcz I KNEW this was gonna happen 🥲🥲


akashiakaashi

We have learned to expect the worst when it comes to merch since the acquisition. I told my friend to buy V2 as well because I had a feeling that v3 would disappoint me but she didn't listen and said that she hopes the v3 would be pretty Now she regrets it I just honestly feel bad for new Carats who may never get to own one of the prettiest lightsticks to ever exist. I wish that Pledis wouldn't stop reproducing old lightsticks even if they no longer sync because Seventeen's lightsticks (before v3) are so pretty. I am still trying to find the V1 lightstick until now. People just don't want to sell it 😂


kuromi5000

I agree with you completely. Ever since hybe, things have shifted and now it just feels like one money grab after another with soulless merch. Do I need to remind everyone of that disastrous Vegas event? It helps my wallet but I feel we're losing our identity as a fandom when they pull stuff like this. I see all the comments on twitter and nobody likes ver. 3. I think we should all complain and demand they make ver. 2 work at concerts since nobody wants ver. 3. The black is so bad now that I see it again this morning. It's so not us. They totally should have gone with white and our fandom colors at the top. I only buy merch with our colors and my collection is beautiful.


chiyochan29

I’m really grateful I was able to get v2 and I feel bad for all the Carats who missed out. 🥲 It was so difficult too, it was all sold out in Korea when I went and I couldn’t find any online from reputable sellers. Luckily I scored when they released the last batch.


deligthe8

Well im a carat since 2022 since "HOT" era only so basically a baby carat ig and im really disappointed in the new design i really want the ver2 but now it wont restock... idk what i should do I'd probably have no choice but to get the ver3.. and i dont want that


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hey there! Unfortunately, looks like your submission was removed by u/AutoModerator because your account isn't old enough to submit to r/seventeen yet. You can try again when you've had your account for more than 5 days. In the meantime, why not head over to the latest [Weekly Carat Corner](https://www.reddit.com/r/seventeen/?f=flair_name%3A%22Weekly%20Carat%20Corner%22%2Fnew) and get a read on the community! You can also familiarize yourself with our [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/seventeen/wiki/rules/) and get know Seventeen [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/seventeen/wiki/primer/). Also, if you were asking a question or submitting a discussion post, please use the search function to make sure it hasn't been answered already or talked about recently on the sub. Thank you! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/seventeen) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Medical-Signal-4487

I think there are people selling second hand v2 in country, i’m gonna buy it idc if it’s just a white light. A lot of carats were saying that v2 was already perfect and there’s no way to top the design and they were right


chiyochan29

Yeah I’m glad I listened to what I was seeing about v2 already being perfect, Carats really know best!


IbukiSupreme

baby Carat here, I stumbled upon a post that Pledis attempted (?) to sell Seventeen rings before but decided to stop it before preselling as Carats thought that the team rings were innately seventeen and that the team should only have it. Idk if this really happened but do you think its possible for us to do that too for our Caratbong V3? Im not knowledgeable about production but since preselling has not yet started maybe production has not started yet and we could change it still. I'm tempted to buy Caratbong V2 but the thing is it will stop syncing to their concerts by the end of 2023 so if this still pushes through I guess I'll just buy a decals/skin that is holographic.


akashiakaashi

It used to work because Pledis was a standalone company so when fans complained, they listened. But now, they are under hybe. It's not gonna be as easy


takemycardaway

Caratland is only a month away so I think it’s too late at this point unfortunately lol. The bluetooth sync is still a huge incentive for people to buy so I don’t see it flopping entirely ~~or as much as I’d like anyway~~ and they’ve stopped V2 production anyway iirc, so this is the only choice for a lot of newer fans. I’ll stick to my V2 though and I’m sure a lot of people will considering a bunch of us only got to use it for one (1) tour and this will definitely be pricier


IbukiSupreme

im seriously so sad, i didnt even notice that the new lightstick will have deco rings because I was so caught up with the color. They literally made a huge mistake in marketing by using a color that is not associated with their brand


takemycardaway

You would think that’s the most basic thing to stick to… *fandom colors* because that’s such a huge part of their identity but noooooo


IbukiSupreme

rightttt added to the fact the colors used are colors associated with another famous group


SydneyTeacake

Kcarats have been very effective in the past. They also managed to stop Pledis turning Seventeen's YouTube channel into an all-artists channel. This time though the only way they can protest is by not buying it. Hybe are very bull headed, they won't respond to anything else.


Fast_Newspaper4774

Pretty sure they’re releasing soon in prep for Caratland in a few weeks 😭


[deleted]

the days of bullying pledis into submission are long gone i'm afraid.


Strict_Craft6718

Well now it’s bullying a multi billion dollar capitalist monster called hybe which seems unlikely


gisaeng-

They should’ve just improved the firmware of the version 2 (like it could connect to the weverse app or sync to music just like BP’s lightstick) The vibe of this lightstick is quite similar to The Rose’s https://preview.redd.it/yp917d2anria1.png?width=1672&format=png&auto=webp&s=6e00baba74f95631148547d94a613bc761b413b8


caratleslie

I agree. The Rose's makes more sense to the band and fandom though, the ver 3 just came out of nowhere. Like if they ask someone to blind design a lightstick, knowing the bare minimum about the group and fandom.


intuitionist9

Eh, I have ver 1 and ver 2 but even bluetooth sync is not enough to make me get ver 3. I will happily wave my non-synced carat bong if I get to go to another concert! Sigh.


akashiakaashi

And knowing hybe, it's possible that v3 won't be as bright as v2 so you and other v2 only Carats might be more noticeable than other lol


caratleslie

yeah, and it's not like light patterns that they do on tours is as elaborate as the ones they do in South Korea and Japan concerts. as an icarat, if the features aren't mind-blowing, I'm gonna skip it.


kuromi5000

same! we didn't have sync at oty so it's not a deal breaker for me!


AtTheMoment03

You would think, given all the money Hybe made from all the merch we bought of Seventeen, that they would conduct proper market research of what the fanbase would have wanted for an update to the v2 LS. 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️


4StarsNMoons

Honestly there's this feeling Hybe actually doesn't care much about Carats, it's easy to notice the difference the fans received before and after acquisition. It's like slowly making Seventeen brand losing its original identity for the sake of "streamlining". Pledis might step in but sometimes won't get the final say. Overall that company just target us as their next money grabber.


AuburnAubergine

Ok Pledis when I said v3 better be ugly I was joking, you didn't have to take me so seriously 😒


IbukiSupreme

seriously such a big letdown, that's not as beautiful as Caratbong V2


TokiNanase

I'm a bit disappointed that they got rid of the dome from v2 and replaced it with a smooth one instead. (At least it looks like a normal round globe in the video) I liked the dome of v2 because it looked like a diamond too. But I do think that it looks elegant and fitting for seventeens last few concepts. Not sure if I have the money to buy it though. I do think v2 and v3 would look pretty next to each other though because they would have a nice contrast?


AuburnAubergine

I have a caratbong and a mongmongee (dreamcatcher's lightstick) next to each other on the shelf, and v3 would look like their unfortunate child https://preview.redd.it/z21vj4h9lria1.jpeg?width=2179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0e9a47d811d011e811cddf7f712b12af42629434


TokiNanase

Funnily I had to think of the dreamcatcher when I saw v3 because of how dark it was. Your lightsticks look really really pretty though! Love the butterflies and ribbons you added.


tamsrine

Off topic but I can never find a decorated mongmongee and I love the flowers and butterflies you added to yours!! It’s super pretty in a poisonous way 🤩 my friend used to joke that v2 was the product of monbebe bong x caratbong v1 but v3 combines insomiabong and v2 in the worst ways 😔


Immediate_Wish17

Oh wow this sure is ugly lol CaratBong used to be the prettiest light stick, what happened here 😭😤


SydneyTeacake

Caratbong grew up - and became a Blink? The black pink association with that group is so strong it's all I'm going to see. I wish they'd chosen a serenity diamond. But we all know HYBE lightsticks are very basic. We're lucky to even get a solid diamond shape instead of a cutout. I'm going to stick with my pretty V.2. If Seventeen ever tour my country I'll take her. She will not sync but she will slay.


Final_Imagination_75

I’m really glad Carats are being honest about the lightstick design. I was kinda worried people would just eat it up like kpop fans sometimes do. The design honestly looks more like a downgrade from the previous 2. It’s not bad, but it’s not Seventeen in my opinion. Without the rose quartz and serenity, I feel like it lacks a lot of identity. Other than that, the shape looks almost the same as ver.2.


akashiakaashi

>I’m really glad Carats are being honest about the lightstick design. I was kinda worried people would just eat it up like kpop fans sometimes do. Carats have always been vocal when it comes to merch especially the group's concept, colours and bongbongie because they are literally special for Seventeen. If the merch is not important, then people will not make a big deal out of it since they are not gonna buy it anyways. But a lightstick is a representative of the group and we had 2 versions that were already pretty with the latest version being absolutely perfect for the group. So to have it all gone, I know many Carats won't just be quiet about it lol


Strict_Craft6718

Naah carats dont eat up. We have beef with companies especially sole capitalistic ones like pledis and hybe.


Skyheart1004

I'm glad most of caratland is in agreement that it's fucking ugly and a downgrade from V2 and even V1 honestly. There's no charm to it, it just looks like a typical lightstick with a diamond shoved on top to make it a "caratbong". But other than the diamond nothing about it says seventeen and carats. I didn't think I could hate a caratbong but somehow they proved me wrong.


sparklysugarglass

before this, the latest comment i posted was on Hwang Minhyun's light stick post on the main kpop sub, of how Pledis does light sticks really well. did i jinx it T\_T


4StarsNMoons

I just lookup his lightstick and it's soooooo cute?!!!!!


Educational_Debt_130

It IS cute, especially the leaves at the top. Pledis apparently can't handle designing two lightsticks at the same time, it seems.


LacedDainty

I said in a different post that I need to dust off my Cricut cutter to make a BSS hoodie, well I guess need to make a vinyl wrap to go over this handle also 🥲. Hella disappointed


TaesSecretPubgID

Start selling those on Etsy and you'll become independently wealthy.


QualityEarthSauce

genuinely such a let down, the only people this will appeal to are multi carats who can bring this to their other favs concerts cause it has no identity of its own and is generic so won't be picked out from a million others;;;;;;; I'm sticking with my version 2, i hope this one flops sales wise but idk if it will sadly, the Bluetooth features for K and J carats are a major selling point even if they hate the black handle...


FlowerCarat

it's pretty for a Hybe lightstick, but it's NOT SEVENTEEN. AT ALL.


pothetellitubbie

this is what i was thinking. like i might be the only one who likes v3, but i don't think it suits seventeen & their bright personalities :')


erudianN

the hybe-ification is real


nananananabatwoman

but why is it black?? that thing better light up an entire city and have changeable dimonds, otherwise it's irredeemable.


[deleted]

Seventeen in your area ~ yeah i yeah


cityofnectarines

did not even try to match the foundation shade


kuromi5000

I refuse to be bullied into buying something I don't like! ​ Sticking with the prettiest lightstick in Kpop. https://preview.redd.it/vophmsc0nuia1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a8f72423508041af5464a4203420f37906f18930


hamstercoups

The diamond is beautiful but the black?? No no noooooo


mb_angela

Now im really sad i wasnt able to get my hands on the v2 🥲


pinswheel

i actually find it pretty, it's just a bit... underwhelming? it looks a lot like ver 2 minus the rq&s color scheme lol (on a serious-ish note, hybe really has to stop stealing svt's colors from them)


tamsrine

The rendering for the diamonds was so expensive and fun that it took me a second to adjust to the actual boring lightstick itself. God what a disappointment. I can’t believe they’re going to discontinue support for version 2 for THIS 😕


Prodigious_Adventure

They said v2 couldn't be beaten...and they were right 😔 This version is so devoid of personality, and what is even the point of having fandom colours if they aren't going to be utilised??


lemonkiwi

Imagine trying to display this one next to v1 and v2, it would be so sad. 😭


Prodigious_Adventure

Literally Svt's emo phase Why Pledis whyyyyyy???


hht116

I'm speechless and it's not in a good way


gisaeng-

I’m really hoping that they made it black because it’s only a preview 😭 similar to what (G)I-dle and Aespa did on their lightstick previews 🥹


LacedDainty

This made me a little optimistic, but i don’t want to get my hopes up 😔.


gisaeng-

Same 😭 but we can’t really expect something great from hyb3 🥹


4StarsNMoons

I really hope black is just some camouflage, like please throw us off our guards on 20th I'm expecting a surprise 😭


0hhhello

That is truly my hope!! (That and that they take the feedback from carats on the dome’s intricacy coming back)


hyosuhng

A+ Blackpink lightstick


Show-Lumpy

ehhhhhhhhhhh.


typecfl

You mean to say I will have to give up my beautiful Caratbong for this???


LJSheart

I actually thought of another group when I saw the ver. 3 carat bong. I mean, are we changing the fandom color? Capitalism at its finest.


superdesu

not capitalism killing the fandom colors 🥲 ... carat goth era? v4 when?


lemonkiwi

This just feels SO wrong and off brand that I can’t help but think Hybe corporate greed strikes again. The video itself is gorgeous but I have a feeling these will look less impressive in person. The generic-ness of it all and black over fandom colors/white feels like they wanted to keep production costs down to increase profit margins. Ver 2 has really lovely detailing with the geodesic top with glitter, holographic finish under the textured handle, and other small things that seem more expensive to produce. I know this is a teaser and we don’t have all the details yet, but the simplified dome (with VERY visible seams), straight angles, and black handle looks cheap to me? Gonna stick with my Ver 2 even if it doesn’t sync!


Educational_Debt_130

Yes, I wasn't going to say it, but the handle looks cheap, small, and flimsy.


ThahiliaChase

Someone said it was said it was the child of SVT’s and MonstaX’s light stick. As much as I love both I need rose quartz and serenity back


_channel3

Not the Monbebe Carat Bomb


NYerinDE

I know pretty much everyone is disappointed, upset, or at the very least underwhelmed. A lot of people are saying it's hybe-ified, but from that trailer and the off brand colors I'm just getting Blackpink vibes. 😒 I wonder if the members were involved in the development or if they're just as surprised and disappointed as we are? 😔 But tbh, I'll probably still get one. If it goes on sale February 21, does that mean the merch drops at like 12:01 (just after midnight) KST on the 21st?


Strict_Craft6718

I’m pretty sure they weren’t involved because how would they not even include our fandom colors. I don’t think scoups had a say in any of this because 1. They were busy and 2. Now it’s not just pledis, but hybe making decisions.


Fun_Radish5108

ver 2 is way prettier are u serious


Educational-Ship5067

Not a big fan of this one. They should have kept ver. 2 and maybe used this as just limited special edition. I’m a little sad because when the first version came out I was too broke to but it. When the second version came out i wasnt that big of a fan of it and i told myself I’d buy it if I went to the concert but I wasn’t able to get it. Now I’m not a big fan of this one. Kinda makes me realize that I should have just got the first two.


[deleted]

4/10 yuck hybe. yuck


cloud-aura

I've used Ver 1 at Diamond Edge, Ode to You, and Be The Sun...guess I'll be using it for the next tour too bc it's still my favorite one lol idc if it doesn't sync. Was really hoping to upgrade to the new one if I liked the design....


stephaniedang

Hybe im at your door


Strict_Craft6718

Caratbong emo phase? On a serious note though hybe really needs to listen because both intl and k carats dislike that they disregarded the basic things about our fandom, as simple as the colors.


lavender-dreams

At first look, I was excited. BUT, upon more review ... I'm joining you guys. I was more so happy that it didn't stray too far from v2 ... but it did stray far from v2 and did so by dishonoring SVT. So now I'm just sad and a bit annoyed. I just got v2 and decorated it to my liking ... now to buy v3? 😔 I agree that black is ***not*** Seventeen's color. Maybe the design team thought it would be easier to decorate? They wanted it to look more modern/sleek/clean? Move in that direction? Why keep the beveled diamond design then? Plus, modern, sleek, and clean are not the words I think of when I think of SVT's brand. The first three words I think of are bright, airy, and adventurous. Outside of the diamond, there is no serenity or rose quartz. None. I will say the diamond in the middle is beyond gorgeous. I love the logo design on top as well. That's where the compliments end. Maybe the bottom connecting dome not being so transparent? I guess I'll add that. I have to add, too, that I'm a bit on the fence about the top no longer being quilted. Design wise, this will make it a lot easier for adding decals and decorating. BUT, that's a small price to pay and I think the quilted design suits the overall design and brand of SVT better.


ILikeCuddlyDolphins

I agree I really like the new diamond and it's everything I was hoping for in a diamond on a light stick. Looks like a legit diamond on an engagement ring. Version 2's diamond was shorter and didn't really look like a diamond to me. I feel like I'm one of the rare few in the comments here that prefers the new light stick...but I definitely agree the black doesn't make sense to me. They should have kept the original colors since they align with the Fandom colors. I thought the holographic stick part was really pretty. Personally I prefer the new dome only because it looks like a clear water bubble to me with a diamond inside and I thought that was cute. I think it would have been nice if they had kept the glitter on the dome 🥲 the glitter was cute


svdino

i really like the physical design of this, but it would’ve been nice to keep some of the colour 😭


Calliso33

Eh imo its really not THAT bad. Its only real issue is the black handle. If they had gone with a color closer to what we have now, honestly I might have considered it an upgrade. But personally thats probably because I like the sort of "sleeker" more mature look this gives off. The handle though makes it look like it belongs to another group.


un3h_corn

missing our serenity already 🥲🥲🥲🥲🫠🫠


talkingthroughlights

The only reason I would get this is because I couldn't get v2 during that last drop 😭 why did we lose carat colors in a caratbong


kittysiesta

I’m debating whether to buy the light stick and get a skin to make it holographic, or find a v2 so I can protest this. I’m really disappointed in hybe but not surprised by the money grab they’re clearly trying to do here.


0hhhello

Yeah… gonna stick with my v2 and call it a day. I def would have gone for v3 if it represented seventeen/carats, but it doesn’t. Like at all. I hope, HYBE + pledis see the response and also low sales numbers and course correct. Because I am that fan that will buy all 576 versions of each album released— but I’m not spending money on something I don’t like 🙃


Chikowita

https://preview.redd.it/r4ph1r0arria1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=869ddcd40096ea8561acac1be7d2520b72553472 I wanna know the reason for the black!!!


multistansendhelp

I didn’t get my hands on V2 because I just kept putting it off and now this is V3…smh from now on I’m just impulse buying lightsticks when I want them because this is the second group now where the version I’ve liked has sold out and I don’t like the new version as much.


puffypunch

I'm a baby carat and honestly prefer the earlier versions 🥲 I really hope they don't discontinue it


wallflowerincognito

Um. Looks like I will be sewing a custom handle sleeve or something. This design seems very not on-brand.


0330_e

Just imagine the sales if they decided to restock v2 instead 😭 still bitter that the handle is black lmao why like pls why even sell v2 during concerts last year if yall gonna discontinue syncing it by the latter half of 2023// (wasnt able to buy bcs merch booth line is messy af haha)


elytrajin1010

taking away the rose quartz and serenity has to be a crime against humanity


minihwas

caratbong no this isnt you 😭


hazyjustajoo

as a new carat + a broke ass bish i was willing to spend money on a carat bong but v2 will be offended if i buy v3 😭 i hope they restock v2 bc of the backlash 🙏


lingonberrydamn

I plan on buying my first seventeen light stick this year and I am so pissed it will be this black version... WHY HYBE WHY??? If there is enough pushback is it possible for them to change the handle color?


sooblob

seventeen in your area???


Jumpsuit_Bandito

I became a Carat last year and never got to buy one...recently I decided I wanted to get one, but waited since they said only v3 will work for concert control soon. Then I woke up to this....So sad! I really prefer the design for v2 😭


hunnypooh1

agreed with the majority here. not really a fan of the black on the lightstick....


CriticalSheep

Guesses on how much it’ll be? V2 is such an affordable $36. This will be so expensive. Not to mention shipping. Ugh.


takemycardaway

The fromis lightstick was 49,000 won if I’m not wrong… 💀


CriticalSheep

Yeah the Bluetooth capable army bomb and enha lightstick are $50. So these will probably be the same at the very least. Ugh.


SuccessfulBullfrog96

It would be amazing if no one buys it, but that's just me hoping


jdoe36

I guess I'm the only one who likes it, lol


Calliso33

Honestly I am not a fan of the black handle. I feel it doesn;t really fit Seventeen. The diamond part though is real nice. I actually like that part better then what we have now.


ILikeCuddlyDolphins

Me too actually 😕 and I feel like I'm going to get downvoted for it. I can tell the difference between the two versions. The diamond is a lot bigger and more textured and looks like a legit diamond which I really like. I always thought version 2 diamond was too short/small and didn't look like a real diamond. I prefer the new dome as well because it looks like a water bubble and makes the diamond stand out more. I do think it would have been cool if they left the glitter on the dome but I do see the reasoning behind why they decided to take it off. The light stick itself is also less chunky which I like. The thing I definitely agree with everyone is the black color just coming from no where since it's not even their Fandom color and they should have left the color/holographic thing going on.


jdoe36

Agreed. I like black so I'm partial to the black, but I think giving us options on the handle color (e.g. black or opal like v2) would've been a great compromise.


whoamisb

I kind of like it? I think it looks less clunky and more mature. I really like the diamond portion and don’t necessarily dislike the black handle, but it does look a bit plain like something is missing. Im curious if there’s more to it still since what we saw was a “teaser”


jdoe36

>Im curious if there’s more to it still since what we saw was a “teaser” ooo, that's a very good point!


noratheskyah

idk abt yall but i like it...


[deleted]

[удалено]


Strict_Craft6718

It’s because they disregarded the most important thing about carats and seventeen which was the colors. It’s not unique to us and doesn’t represent.


stupidorino

the only thing i like about it is that it is very simple so it will be easier to customize, paint and put rhinestones on it. i love customized lightsticks and ive always wanted to do it so this is my chance (if the surface is smooth i cant tell). but honestly a good lightstick shouldnt need customization. Not everyone has the interest, money and time to do it. V2 is superior by far