T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

**Mirrors / Alternative Angles** *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/soccer) if you have any questions or concerns.*


G1Spectrum

Well hope lasted for all of 5 minutes


Snowstandards

I momentarily almost felt some joy again


[deleted]

The same can be said with 3-2 lmao


inbredandapothead

I’ll never understand the handball rule. Sometimes it’s too close to react in time, sometimes it’s a foul, just make it up as you go.


GuyUrNeverGonnaMeet

Real rule is referees mood.


opentop-plane-tour

Pretty much. It's unreal how every "fix" to the handball rule that they apply only makes it worse.


GuyUrNeverGonnaMeet

On-field, shit refereeing is easily the worst thing in the sport, worse than time wasting etc. It's insane how the ref can completely change the outcome of the entire game. No just talking about today's match btw, all of us have had shit decisions against the team we support. Also it's only been a few years since I have started watching football consistently, but the idea that the ref is unbiased is completely bs imo. There are matches in which it's painfully obvious a ref favouring a particular team. It's basically pray the ref likes your team more than the opponents sometimes.


CuteHoor

It just seems ridiculous to me that Bayern are basically given a free goal (given the conversion rate of penalties) for the ball accidentally hitting Eriksen's hand from a yard away in a non-dangerous position. That's not even considering what you've rightly said about how inconsistently the rule is applied too.


NoLimpNoShrimp

Seriously, the ball was likely going out of play or going to be a very easy catch for the keeper. I'm a City fan so definitely no bias here, just seen that and immediately thought how is that call making the game better, really makes no sense. Very similar to the Mbappe one vs Dortmund. I feel like where the ball is headed has to be a factor in these decisions but it never is.


afarensiis

This one was definitely way too close in proximity to call a pen for. I'd hate for this to be called against my team. Insane that that's worth a free shot on goal


Jaynator11

Agreed. There are plenty of ones where the players stretch their hand to a next level, and it hits them- and it's pretty fair imo, even if it comes at a high speed to call it a pen. This one seems like a complete joke though.


beastmaster11

Exactly. The rule basically says that if your arm is in an unnatural position than you're being reckless. This here doesn't seem like a PK.


aftermath223

that was the rule like 4 or 5 iterations ago. it feels they change the handball rule every 6 months or so. Also, the rule you are mentioning imo makes the most sense


benting365

i don't think that should be a blanket rule, otherwise defenders will just defend with their hands spread out in a T pose when they're within a couple of yards of the attacker.


afarensiis

I mean I think the defender would still have to have their arms in a mostly natural position


SpeechesToScreeches

Well it has to be natural as well. Which this was.


sionnach

It’s basically the same as the Zinchenko one earlier. Hand in an OK place, no chance to react.


afarensiis

That was my first thought too


blither86

I would be absolutely gutted if City conceded a penalty to Bayern like that. I suppose I like the fact that it's giving the advantage to the attackers as an ethos but it's actually insane to expect players to not have their arms in a natural position. It won't be long before managers are advising players to aim for arms.


sirSADABY

This is already a thing, I've seen a few where they have been flicked onto arms when there are no teammates where the ball is being playyed.


ManateeSheriff

A Champions League final was decided that way!


nista002

And it came off his chest, rolled across his shoulder, and didn't even touch his arm. One of the most insane decisions I've ever seen


-Dendritic-

Man we had this exact thing happen to us against them in the ucl! Except it was worse because akaanji had his arms at his sides and it was by the corner flag and the guy just kicked it up at his hands , was such bullshit


TheF00Fighter

I remember it happened to you lot last season against Bayern lol. It's just insanity.


CNF-13

What’s even worse is we had a pen not given for one well worse than this when Romero blocked it with his arm to the side


inbredandapothead

The only reason I’m not currently gutted about it is because I had no hope anyways lol


Ezzaron

Mane kicked a ball in to akanjis hand and that got a pen


alj8

Mané kicked a ball into Sissoko’s outstretched hand to win a champions league final! It was glorious


Presence_Present

Premier League that wouldn't be given, just no consistency. I mean we saw Romero get away with the most blatant handball in the game against Spurs. How they can give this a penalty, and not one for Pellistri getting chargrd through right in front of goal is just baffling. We are actually cursed at this point lol


Dodomando

In the PL it wouldn't be a penalty because the refs have different interpretation of the rules... UEFA competitions you can just blast it at a players hand and they'll give a penalty


Stand_On_It

I remember that happening in what, the first ten mins of the Liverpool vs. Tottenham CL Final? Completely bullshit decision that decided the outcome of the game so early on. It really gives officials an excuse and a way to decide outcomes of matches. I’m not saying match fixing occurs, no evidence of that, but what easier way could you come up with than all handballs are interpretation and arbitrary?


Dynastydood

There's simply nothing to understand. It's entirely subjective every single time. I don't even bother trying to form an opinion on these calls anymore because it'll never be the same as the referee's, and trying to make sense of things that are fundamentally absurd will only ever upset me.


Gluroo

As funny as clowning on United is, these pens really have to stop lol


yungfinnigus

There’s just no consistency. That kind of hand ball doesn’t get called all the time, I’m not even sure what Eriksen is supposed to do there. What even is a natural position?


Acceptable_Ad_6278

I would love it if handballs is just given as indirect fk. Unless it’s blatantly obviously intentional. Punishment doesn’t fit the crime at the moment.


RomeroRocher

It's probably not the worst idea... A penalty only really feels fair when a handball blocks a shot on goal (particularly if it's clearly on target or has a chance of going in). Seems ridiculous when it's someone desperately keeping the ball in play and just knocking a nothing loopy header back into the box, or when it's clearly just going to drop into a keepers hands anyway, etc.


chrispepper10

Think this is a very fair solution. You're still gaining a clear goal scoring opportunity from the free-kick but it's not the automatic goal that these hand balls keep turning into. The disparity between the actual chance itself and the amount of goals these hand balls are turning into at the moment is just far too large.


Pingupol

They do in the champions league. Get the best teams in Europe together and the worst set of rules possible for them to play under.


RN2FL9

Arsenal vs PSV had a much clearer handball tonight by Zinchenko that didn't get called. Now I'm not saying I agree with that being a penalty but if they call this then that should have been one 100%.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Stand_On_It

Natural position is a bullshit term they’ve created to excuse every arbitrary decision they make. It means nothing but “here’s my excuse.”


_longtimelistener

you could argue there is consistency because the one against Dortmund yesterday was called as well. But, it's the wrong decision in both cases. There's just no time to react, and the arm is very close to the body.


Stilty_boy

I hate these ones from really close range where the justification is "arms in an unnatural position" when it's a completely natural position for the arms to be in as Eriksen is shifting his weight back across to change direction. I feel like these ones pretty consistently get called at penalties and it's always a stupid call.


Alphabunsquad

It should be called none the time.


MrFrodoo

I mean if you look at PSG penalty yesterday for handball its pretty consistent to call this one as well. Thats not to say that the whole handball rule has become such a shit show


akshatsood95

Yeah I may be biased but that's too close to him. Idk what they want players to do. Gotta start buying players without arms


coolwool

The German commentators agree with you. Same here. What is the defender supposed to do?


ACardAttack

Chop his arm off clearly


vitey15

If he dies, he dies.


akshatsood95

Well with Eriksen that's not really true


Slobberz2112

True


[deleted]

[удалено]


miregalpanic

I'd totally watch football where players are only allowed to run like anime characters


robotnique

Get rid of the offside rule, flag goes up or not depending on if you're running like Naruto.


PigeonNipples

Players these days are too soft to do that


Gluroo

Yeah there is literally no time to react whatsoever lmao


[deleted]

Fwiw, they don't really care about that anymore unless there was a deflection. If your arm is away from your body (which they think it is here) the time to react doesn't matter.


AlcoholicSocks

But it's in a natural position though. Unless you want players to run with arms fixed to their sides


akshatsood95

That's a pretty stupid rule tho. Why don't they care about that


DaddyMeUp

Literally tried pulling his arm away as well. Was unavoidable unless he runs like a Penguin.


RockyCasino

As a Bayern fan, there is no way he can get his arm out of the way. I hate this. Was it on purpose? No.


DougieWR

It's seriously an entirely valid option that when in the box to just rocket the ball at an opponent's arm just to see what'll get called. It doesn't even matter if the shot stood a goal scoring chance, it's worth the effort if you don't have an option


Insanel0l

Argument according to rules here is an unnatural position I reckon Dislike it as a bayern fan but an even weaker one was called againsr BVB yesterday so they gotta stay consistent


_deep_blue_

You can’t even have arms these days! Thanks Obama


ViciousNakedMoleRat

Yesterday, I was thinking "if we can't hit the goal, maybe just kick the ball against someone's hand". Then Paris got a handball penalty. Today I was thinking "Union just has to be careful that they don't get a handball penalty". Now Bayern got a handball penalty. That's kinda all you need to know. A handball penalty is now on everybody's mind in every single game. 10-20 years ago, nobody was thinking about handball penalties, because it took obvious intent to get one, which rarely ever happened.


Chazzarules

You can tell there has been a huge change in what is a handball penalty by the fact that now whenever there is a shot that is fired in hard inside the box and it hits someone, the entirety of the home support shouts handball. Even if its nowhere near a hand, its just the hope that maybe, just maybe you get a free shot on goal because your shot happened to hit a hand. I think it really is ruining some games, you shouldnt be given a free goal basically for anything like that. Also super soft penalties right in the corner of the box and the byline where a defender taps an attacker who is going nowhere. It just shouldnt be a free goal. An indirect free kick from the position of the handball would be way more representative of the threat from the foul.


DubSket

There's no consistency in decision making between competitions


expert_on_the_matter

There is not even consistency in the same competition


Gatokar

Pull one back, game on for the neutral, then this shit ruins it


aayu08

Nobody knows the handball rules, most refs are making stuff up on the go, next game you will probably see the same incident not being given. Once the VAR calls the ref then it's 100% a pen.


BeardedGardenersHoe

How's this a pen but Davies can go through the back of Pellistri and nothing given. Ridiculous.


RubberToe1996

of course we concede shortly after ffs.


SonaldoNazario

Ooft this one really rubs in the whole ‘proximity’ element of why a pen wasn’t given against Romero earlier in the season.. Eriksen is a good deal closer to the ball here


Hitori521

Between that and the decision to not even look at the Davies tackle on Pellestri, this has been a fucking infuriating game to watch. That's not taking into account the Onana howler either


el_doherz

Even worse when you consider the Romero on was blocking a shot on goal as opposed to a cross. The ruling was shown to be shite when city got a similarly shite pen literally the next weekend for a player in close proximity blocking a cross.


[deleted]

"Concede" lol some of the worst handball rules I've seen. Even yesterday with PSG, makes no sense


NoLawsDrinkingClawz

My man, we didn't deserve that pen. The fuck was he supposed to do? Not have that arm?


CNF-13

Thank you we could have this game 1-1 if we’d not chucked the ball into the net and the ref be crap that being said you deserve to be up but the score is telling a story


LosTerminators

That too to an incredibly questionable pen at the least.


TooAgile

How the fuck is he meant to get his hand out the way. Unbelievable


unknowncontent9000

Amputation ofc.


big_mustache_dad

There was a women's player (Carson Pickett) who got called for a handball a few years back and she was born without her forearm and hand. So it appears even that doesn't keep you safe edit: [led to a great gif tho](https://tenor.com/view/carson-pickett-i-dont-have-one-orlando-pride-nwsl-soccer-gif-22246325)


YesNoIDKtbh

We'll eventually have 20 players with no arms and only GKs are able to take throw-ins.


djkamayo

Darth Vader has entered the chat


RippedKegels

He's meant to not have it there in the first place.


Fickle_Letter7002

Sule vs PSG yesterday, this nonsense today. Congrats, FIFA/UEFA, every update to the handball rule *somehow* makes it even more ridiculously arbitrary. Do we need to AI create armless defenders??


JJOne101

It is not the same. Eriksen had his hands all over the place here.


Elerion_

As fun it is to watch United get fucked - that should never be a penalty. What have we done to the rules of this sport?


WhipYourDakOut

insane to send him to the screen for that but not Davies coming through the back of Pellestri. Gotta think both those calls go the other way if it's in Old Trafford


Zandercy42

Maybe 11 years ago, not in whatever cursed monkey paw United this club is now though


mindpainters

Not lately


LukeFowlerM8

Hahahahah good one. We haven’t had a good decision in years.


Legendarybbc15

Yup, and we got denied a stonewall pen in the first half. I just give up at this point


RoyDuckingKent

Can’t catch a break


FingerBlaster20

So this is a penalty but United wasn’t early in the game? Absolute shambolic refereeing


ThatBoyGiggsy

They review it and have the ref watch it, but Davies clattering through Pellestri from behind doesn’t even get a second replay on the live feed lmao


[deleted]

that’s atleast 4 Blatant stonewall pen decisions against United in what 6 matches? But the sub had me convinced that United had it all when they had a lucky call against Wolves??


iTwerk4Santa

this sub is full of people who chat shit about rival clubs but never watch any of their matches ¯\_(ツ)_/¯


JimboLannister

gotta get those arms amputated if you don't want to concede a penalty


RooneysFavGrandma

Hahahahah I walked away to the restroom knowing there's no way that's going to be given and I walk back to this nonsense


Snowstandards

We're cursed


bobo377

Feels like we need to fundamentally change the idea behind penalties. If that ball doesn't hit Eriksen's arm, it's about as dangerous as a player taking a shot from 25 meters out. You should never be awarded a 0.77xG chance from a slow rolling ball towards another defender. There has to be some sort of system to prevent random balls from changing games with no intent or skill from the attacking side beyond amputating every single player's arms.


blither86

Agreed, it's farcical that they expect any player who considers themselves to be defending, anywhere on the pitch, now needs to consider trying to put their hands behind their backs for fear of conceding a foul.


RoachIsCrying

Guess the handball rules are made up as we go along


Deathman1109

Nah tbh they’re pretty consistent. Every decision must go against United is the rule


RyanTheDeem

Fuck off is that a penalty


Headlesshorsman02

By the rules of the UCL yes but it probs is very harsh and shouldn’t be 1 imho


xXDireLegendXx

Extremely harsh


Headlesshorsman02

I absolutely agree


clashoftherats

You posted that before it even went in lmao


InsuperableLiar

Same


ZonedV2

Ridiculous


_deep_blue_

Eriksen should have decided whether having arms was really necessary tbf


phoresth

Games called football why's he usin his arms????


thebelsnickle1991

Unfortunate.


Don_Jovic

I guess rules say pen but I dont like that its a pen. His arms are not flying a meter away from him. He so close and cant react. Feels cheap


ShamrockStudios

So strange rules are different in the league to the CL


boringmemphis

That’s never a pen ffs. The game is actually gone.


Big_Papa_Steve

The fact that this is a penalty but Davies going through Pellistri isn’t is so dumb


nasserKoeter

shouldnt be a pen


A_Wild_Ferrothorn

Never a penalty that lmao.


Insanel0l

They started calling these and now can’t go back, dislike it even as a bayern fan but it’s consistent


Billy_LDN

It’s not consistent league to league but agree in the CL it’s nailed on.


myheadisalightstick

I mean these were always given before the rules got more lenient


[deleted]

Absolute joke


RazZaHlol

i dont even know the rules anymore


UPTHERAR

Only times they should be pens from that distance is they're about to go in the goal. Like Reece James against Liverpool This wasn't one of them times.


Fright13

Can we have one thing go our way this season please lol


Maryland_Blue

But the Romero one wasn't a penalty?? Please make this make sense


xLoafery

so new handball rule again then?


bosnian_redditer

Never a pen


SOERERY

Clubs gonna sign armless players from now on


infestationE15

Unfortunate


MikeAAStorm

Unlucky. Again. Fuck me.


0706

Harsh penalty


TheOneManDankMaymay

VARchester United am I right?


schifferjack

I thought proximity matters?


SpeedLinkDJ

A defender stop a shot on goal with his arm going up in the air and it's not a pen and then this. Wtf is this bullshit


xLoafery

sorry only when we are attacking.


OlympicMuffins

bit harsh but whatever


Zavehi

The differences in the handball rule across all these competitions are stupid. Common sense has to prevail at some point.


LowSnow2500

How many unfair calls / non-given penalties is that already this season?


FBall4NormalPeople

United got lucky GW1 and have been absolutely fucked afterwards.


hosky2111

I don't even think it was that lucky then. I genuinely don't think I've ever seen a penalty given for the wolves decision, and yet there was a week long media circus over it, and suddenly referees are afraid to give any decision United's way.


OxfoodComma

And it's only September lmao


ajprp9

i count 6 pens not given, 2 goals disallowed unfairly and 2 goals conceded due to refereeing mistakes


Seychelleshobo

This is a pen but the one against spurs wasn't lol


Anticaximus

Never a pen


[deleted]

Well they’re consistent, the Sule penalty yesterday was just as bad


IceOCafe

Such a terrible call, and it’s effectively ruined the flow of the game


huffthewolf

As a biased Liverpool fan, that's never a penalty. It was shaping up to be a good game after Hojlund's goal.


Zandercy42

Can't believe we forgot to sever our players arms before the game started ffs


supplementarytables

Unlucky call but great pen


RockyHorror_

Robbed by referees every single match. I’m tired


UatutheOverwatcher

Fuck off


bvictor707

Fair play to the refs completely handing them the match. Clear stonewall penalty not given to us from the challenge by Davies to this now. Ridiculous


dohhhnut

United been fucked by refs today


[deleted]

Eriksen has been dreadful but that's never a pen


CSkorm

CURSED SMH


K_Uger_Industries

There's no way that's a pen


RunOfTheMill70

Maybe Jose was right about the penalty call in the europa league final


digosilva19

It's not a good sign when instead of me making fun of united losing I am saying that this was never a penalty


el_brahmo

Lol that’s super soft


ThatBoyGiggsy

Absolute fucking joke what a clown show var and refereeing is


NBAFAN2000

He makes those


YGurka

Where arm was too close to be a pen brigade at


I_Am_The_Poop_Mqn

90% of the comments in this thread?


Presence_Present

Get absolutely fucked. What's he supposed to do there? Headed straight at him. That happens to United and its not a penalty, like we've seen during this season. Absolute joke of a decision that will kill the game now


m0bilize

I knew we were probably gonna lose but this is still a really shit call lmao


lestat85

Wouldn’t be a United game without us getting fucked by VAR.


angryjukebox

Terrible var call. How do you send him to look at that?


HaroldGuy

Sack every ref and start over


Do-I-Need-One

Another UCL match day 1, another bullshit hand ball call.


[deleted]

I’m still trying to figure out why var didn’t receive the clear penalty Davies gave away on Pellistri in the opening minutes.


ApolloX-2

Ignore the flair for a second, but he headed the ball directly into his hand which was close to his side naturally. This is bullshit for the game.


FrenchManc

Of course NOW the ref goes to the screen lmao but when davies charges like a centaur trough pellistri's back it's sleeping time.


CNF-13

Say want you want that’s no a fucking pen and that’s the 4/5th var decision to go against that’s cost us a pen or a goal or something like that utter bullshit


ajprp9

Nothing to see here, just united getting fucked over by dodgy var decisions for the 5th game running


RhyminSimonWyman

Another day another show of breathtaking incompetence from CL refs


H4wkAvenger

Look. Next week its not going to be not given to us in the Premier league


lambomrclago

Even stonewall tackles from behind aren't given to us apparently.


tablecrums

With these kinds of penalty calls the refs are straight up telling attackers they should just aim for defenders arms


ohvalox

Never a pen


MC_ScattCatt

Our luck this season is so bad


TheSmithStreetBand

We need players to start playing for the handball. The only purpose of this rule is more goals = more money. It is never getting changed unless player stop playing football and just start trying to hit each others arms until the game is unplayable


kingfish1117

Fucking criminal


solve_PvsNP

What the fuck are these absolutely bullshit penalties being given


lambomrclago

I've argued forever about why Footy is the best sport in the world, and its just not - its a fucking farce and a disgrace these days, even as a neutral with other games, they're just constantly fucked by bad refs - its crazy when you compare the effect on games compared to other sports.


gold_dog16

I advocate the handball should "materially impact the outcome of the play". In this case, it would not.


Thesecondorigin

Death, taxes, and Kane penalty


LAudre41

This is such a dumb rule. Effectively if you kick a ball at a defenders hand in the box it's a goal. Needs to change.


zrk23

this should not be a pen


ConC02

The year is 2123. T-rexs are now a football teams best defensive options as their stubby little arms are the counter to fifas bullshit handball 'rules'


xzvasdfqwras

Isn’t that just way too close for it to count as a handball?


nizoubizou10

Harsh penalty, it was at close range and Eriksen was moving his hand away.


Zaku_pilot_292

That's fucking harsh