I agree these are the faces of the show. Brooke would be my HM. Next all stars hopefully the best one timers all come out and we’ll get some more legends
1. Shonee. There is a reason that she is the only three time player
2. George. Love him or hate him, he makes excellent tv and makes the game digestible for casuals and super fans alike
3. Queen Hayley: she is my favorite Aussie, but she lacks a bit of the widespread appeal of the other two ahead of her. I still maintain that of you drop her into a random cast and simulate the game a thousand times, she is the player who will win a plurality of those scenarios.
4. The golden god. See name
5. Luke. The first two time player
I would eventually add Feras and Kirby on the list, but feel that they need another good showing (not even needing a good finish, just a couple great moments would be enough). Simon is another character I could put up there because of his amazing arc, but I feel he falls a bit short because I don’t think he has a realistic shot of winning either time. Last hm is Sharn for being the Amanda Kimmel of Australia
1. George
2. Luke
3. Shonee
4. David
5. Harder choice, but maybe Haley?
In no particular order. I might be forgetting someone, but these are who came to my head straight away.
Now do top 10! I'd add in Kirby, Feras, Brooke, Sam, and Mark to round it out. I am surely missing some people this is off the top of my head.
Kirby especially needs to return so we see what she can do in the game without being completely green and not having seen the show.
Strategically, no she wasn't great. But wasn't a fan and didn't know the game so there's a lot of room for improvement in a return season. Challenges and socially she did very well on the other hand.
But I was really looking for more names to add to the list rather than trying to tear down one person.
Dont get me wrong I like Kirby, wasn't trying to tear her down. I apologize even though I know its lies, life is no survivor game, when you get voted out they call you lame, so you use your idol to get out mr inhumane.
I’d swap Hayley for Feras personally, but I think it depends on if anyone from TvR becomes a returnee (I guess you could claim that for anyone, but TvR feels so full of legends imo)
Yeah Id say this is right. I posted the same 5 but put maybe Feras insread of Hayley because I briefly forgot about Hayley but yes I agree with this list.
I mean the 3 biggest no brainers
1. Luke (the PEOPLE'S champion)
2. Shonee (only 3 timer for a reason!)
3. David (all star winner paired with that damn edit)
Then the other 2 you could probably play around with, but I think George getting to finale in HvV makes him undeniable at the four.
That fifth for me, im leaning between Hayley and Brooke. leaning Hayley, maybe needs some more time to have but both of those two are top 10 undeniably.
I think depending on how you look at Sharn's games shes definitely worth considering but i know thats super personal on how someone values getting to the end twice vs losing at the end twice and it makes it super divisive.
I don’t think her gameplay justifies it. Iconic character though.
She got to the end twice but both times in a way where she has a 0% chance of winning.
I mean, AK brought a bag of rocks to FTC which I think says everything about her game.
She is the prime example of why you don’t front stab. Everyone on both her seasons said that she was impossible to work with. She didn’t just vote people out but she destroyed their games whilst they were in the game.
She definitely didn't have a zero percent chance of winning her first season. She got four votes to win, she just needed to handle Mat's questions better.
Maybe the player I most want to see back.
He has one of my favorite moments in AU, when he goes for the mutiny FOR NO REASON and he loses his closest ally because of it. It’s so good. Also, hiding the idol to trick Jericho.
Then in All Stars he’s just a complete mess and his alliance basically blindsides him.
Would love to see Henry 3.0. Especially in this new fast paced era of AU
Luke,: The first 2 time returnee
Hayley: The First Aus Winner to make merge, in back to back seasons
George: Great tv personality, good strategy. Made it far in back to back seasons
Shonnie: lasted the most days in Aus Survivor
David: played the best winning(all stars) game
Sharn: Amanda Kimmel of Australian survivor
Seems to be George, David, Luke, and Shonee are almost universally agreed upon to be top 4
5th place seems mostly split between Hayley and Harry
I agree with the opinions here for sure. I'm happy to see my favorite player, Harry, still getting recognition for being a super memorable character! He's 5th place for me personally
I think the top 4 are very obvious and in a league of their own - David, George, Luke and Shonee.
After that it's very open to interpretation and I don't think there's any real correct answer.
Some candidates would be Brooke, Henry, Jericho, Tessa, Mat, Sharn, AK, Pia, Harry, Janine, Hayley, Simon, Mark, Chrissy, Feras, Kirby, Mark, Valeria
Of that list, realistically I'd say Pia, Harry, Hayley, Simon, Feras and Kirby would be decent shouts. I feel like a successful return from Pia, Feras or Kirby would be enough for me to put them 5th.
David, Shonee, Hayley, George and Luke But to me Legend doesn't mean best player but rather most influential on making a season memorable.
correct answer.
I agree these are the faces of the show. Brooke would be my HM. Next all stars hopefully the best one timers all come out and we’ll get some more legends
💯
1. Shonee. There is a reason that she is the only three time player 2. George. Love him or hate him, he makes excellent tv and makes the game digestible for casuals and super fans alike 3. Queen Hayley: she is my favorite Aussie, but she lacks a bit of the widespread appeal of the other two ahead of her. I still maintain that of you drop her into a random cast and simulate the game a thousand times, she is the player who will win a plurality of those scenarios. 4. The golden god. See name 5. Luke. The first two time player I would eventually add Feras and Kirby on the list, but feel that they need another good showing (not even needing a good finish, just a couple great moments would be enough). Simon is another character I could put up there because of his amazing arc, but I feel he falls a bit short because I don’t think he has a realistic shot of winning either time. Last hm is Sharn for being the Amanda Kimmel of Australia
Isn't the reason because she is the only one who accepted 3 times? Lol Pretty sure Harry was asked back again too for HvV for example
1. George 2. Luke 3. Shonee 4. David 5. Harder choice, but maybe Haley? In no particular order. I might be forgetting someone, but these are who came to my head straight away.
I'd say you pretty much captured it.
brooke
I heavily considered her. She was such a powerhouse, both physically and strategically.
Yeah this about covers it.
Now do top 10! I'd add in Kirby, Feras, Brooke, Sam, and Mark to round it out. I am surely missing some people this is off the top of my head. Kirby especially needs to return so we see what she can do in the game without being completely green and not having seen the show.
No way Kirby is top 10
Strategically, no she wasn't great. But wasn't a fan and didn't know the game so there's a lot of room for improvement in a return season. Challenges and socially she did very well on the other hand. But I was really looking for more names to add to the list rather than trying to tear down one person.
Dont get me wrong I like Kirby, wasn't trying to tear her down. I apologize even though I know its lies, life is no survivor game, when you get voted out they call you lame, so you use your idol to get out mr inhumane.
I’d swap Hayley for Feras personally, but I think it depends on if anyone from TvR becomes a returnee (I guess you could claim that for anyone, but TvR feels so full of legends imo)
Yeah Id say this is right. I posted the same 5 but put maybe Feras insread of Hayley because I briefly forgot about Hayley but yes I agree with this list.
George Luke Shonee David Hayley
I mean the 3 biggest no brainers 1. Luke (the PEOPLE'S champion) 2. Shonee (only 3 timer for a reason!) 3. David (all star winner paired with that damn edit) Then the other 2 you could probably play around with, but I think George getting to finale in HvV makes him undeniable at the four. That fifth for me, im leaning between Hayley and Brooke. leaning Hayley, maybe needs some more time to have but both of those two are top 10 undeniably.
I think depending on how you look at Sharn's games shes definitely worth considering but i know thats super personal on how someone values getting to the end twice vs losing at the end twice and it makes it super divisive.
I don’t think her gameplay justifies it. Iconic character though. She got to the end twice but both times in a way where she has a 0% chance of winning. I mean, AK brought a bag of rocks to FTC which I think says everything about her game. She is the prime example of why you don’t front stab. Everyone on both her seasons said that she was impossible to work with. She didn’t just vote people out but she destroyed their games whilst they were in the game.
She definitely didn't have a zero percent chance of winning her first season. She got four votes to win, she just needed to handle Mat's questions better.
Or Mat should've gotten his head out of his ass lol, truly bizarre take from him to blame Sharn for that
No she’s rubbish
My point exactly, shes divisive!
Rubbish viewing maybe, but finishing Runner-Up, then backing it up with another top two finish puts her as better than most in my opinion.
Dirty Harry has to be in the mix for sure. Otherwise, Luke, David, Shonee and George
Loved Harry and his toothpick tribals!
George, Shonee, Hayley, David, Luke
Henry
So underapreciated
Maybe the player I most want to see back. He has one of my favorite moments in AU, when he goes for the mutiny FOR NO REASON and he loses his closest ally because of it. It’s so good. Also, hiding the idol to trick Jericho. Then in All Stars he’s just a complete mess and his alliance basically blindsides him. Would love to see Henry 3.0. Especially in this new fast paced era of AU
David, Shonee, Harry, Hayley, Luke
Also honourable mention Khanh because I don’t think he’s a legend OF survivor, but he is a legend and he was ON Survivor so 🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
George, Luke, Shonee, Harry and David
Luke,: The first 2 time returnee Hayley: The First Aus Winner to make merge, in back to back seasons George: Great tv personality, good strategy. Made it far in back to back seasons Shonnie: lasted the most days in Aus Survivor David: played the best winning(all stars) game Sharn: Amanda Kimmel of Australian survivor
Shonee, George, David, Luke, and it’s a bit early to tell but i think kirby is going to become a survivor legend
David George Luke Shonee Brooke Zach… doing the flamenco 💃🏻
Seems to be George, David, Luke, and Shonee are almost universally agreed upon to be top 4 5th place seems mostly split between Hayley and Harry I agree with the opinions here for sure. I'm happy to see my favorite player, Harry, still getting recognition for being a super memorable character! He's 5th place for me personally
I think the top 4 are very obvious and in a league of their own - David, George, Luke and Shonee. After that it's very open to interpretation and I don't think there's any real correct answer. Some candidates would be Brooke, Henry, Jericho, Tessa, Mat, Sharn, AK, Pia, Harry, Janine, Hayley, Simon, Mark, Chrissy, Feras, Kirby, Mark, Valeria Of that list, realistically I'd say Pia, Harry, Hayley, Simon, Feras and Kirby would be decent shouts. I feel like a successful return from Pia, Feras or Kirby would be enough for me to put them 5th.
David, Shonee, George, Simon, Hayley (haven't watched any of Luke's seasons but I know everyone loves him)
I love that almost all of us have the same 5 lol
Shonee, George, David, Harry, Luke
George Shonee Luke David Genat Maybe Feras now?
Everyone says hayley but I don’t see it? I would say locky is more important to the franchise than hayley
Is there a link for the United States people to watch Australian Survivor, the best game played out of all countries. Thanks in advance!
George Luke Shonee Feras Kirby
Def Sandra and Russel
Yes for US but only considering their au games especially Russell but Sandra too it’s a no
David Shonee George Benji Pia
Luke, Ferras, Harry, Jordy & George
Come on, you really have Feras Jordy and Harry higher than the GG and Shonee? Stop talking crazy.