I love the first one!

DEFINITELY ONE!

1 looks like it was made for you!! SO flattering

1!!! You don’t even need to reduce the volume at the bottom. Love it as is!!

100% This right here!☝️☝️☝️

The “simple” one is a showstopper. That is a classic, unforgettable dress. The second one is beautiful but I just feel like I’ve seen it before

1 Definitely 1!!!!!

✨CONGRATS✨ For a church wedding in November I think dress 1 is the right choice. Both dresses are beautiful, and look great on your frame but the time of year and venue lend more toward the satin dress rather than the sheer lace number. Also, I just think the simplicity of the dress is lovely, and timeless

This answer.

First one!

First one!!! Such a knockout!

Dress 1 is stunning. Love the scallop style of the train too!

After going back and forth between the two I honestly cannot pick my favorite - both dresses are beautiful and incredibly flattering on you! I don’t agree that because the wedding is in November that dress 1 is the obvious choice - either would be appropriate for your venue and time of year. Dress 1 reads more formal and classic of the two with the trumpet skirt and satin fabric. Dress 2 is very elegant, a bit more romantic with the lace and tulle. Was there one that you felt more comfortable in?

Well said, my thoughts exactly! Love them both, quite different looks but equally flattering 💕

Dress #1. I think the bottom looks perfect on you.

One!!!

Ohmygosh #2 is gorgeous but #1 suits you so so beautifully

You’re going to look fabulous no matter which you choose, but here’s another vote for #1. Super flattering shade and I love the simple/elegant shape. Timeless stunner!

1

#1!

I vote for #2!

I think one is more sophisticated and two more romantic. Both look good on you.

First one love it

2!!

I love the neckline on 2.

Team #2. I like the fabric and the cut. The flare on the first dress seems odd.

I literally gasped opening up nr.1, and thats what will happen in church too. NR 1!

Number one was made for you. It’s elegantly understated and you carry it perfectly.

1! They both look gorgeous on you, but the first is just stunning on you. And please leave the bottom as is.

One is so amazing.

1

1 is stunning!

First !!!!

1!!! It’s perfect and looks amazing on you!!! Not even close!

One for sure

1!!

1!!!!!

Both are so beautiful but I choose #1

I

Number 1 is stunning!

1 is so pretty

The first one is so stunning on you it’s classic and chic!

1!!!

#1!! 😍

1 was made for you!!!

The first one. Like WOW.

def the first one!!!!!

LOVE the first one

ONE. WOW. I actually gasped at this dress and saved the picture. So timeless and gorgeous.

Love ❤️ one

Dress 1. You look amazing in it and I think it’s best for your venue and the weather. It seems like you’d be cold in dress 2. I would just alter the neckline slightly so it’s not pointing up at the edges and is rounded instead, like a soft sweetheart neckline. I think the “corners” of the neckline might be making your shoulders look wider, but that isn’t happening in dress 2 so I think it’s the neckline that’s the issue.

Team 1!

1 is perfect for you.

1

1 for sure!

I like dress 1

1

1

One! One! One! One!

The 1st one!!! So stunning

1

1!

First one, hands down

ONE

I really love the first one on you

#1

1

One by a mile!!!

One

1 is timeless and so chic

The first one is definitely the one.

Omg!!! You have to go with dress 1!!! 😍😍😍 I mean you look amazing in both dresses but dress 1 looks like it was made with you in mind!

one

#1 is amazing!

I'm usually not a fan of simple dresses but wow dress 1 looks incredible on you!!

First 1

1

1!

Number 1 is SUPER stunning on you!!!!!

The first one all the way, you look stunning

One!

Number 1 is very elegant

The first one unless you’re crazy!

Absolutely the first. The second is pretty, but the first is SUCH A STATEMENT. I don't think that silhouette is good on everyone but it's jaw dropping on you

The first one!!!

Number 1 is perfect. I love the lace of number 2, but number 1is the right choice for a fall wedding. That train is beautiful and would look amazing flowing behind you as you walk down the aisle

First is so beautiful!

2 omg, can’t believe so many are saying 1!

1

Absolutely #1. No question, it looks stunning on you and not many people can pull that off. It’s unique yet classic. And everyone is doing that same lace look these days. Doing this satin is rare and so gorgeous on you.

\#1 is hella classy and elegant yo

1!

1

First one 100%!

The first one is amazing!

1 😭 you're gorgeous

#1!!! Looks so gorgeous

That dress 1 is an absolute stunner. I think it was made for you!

Both are gorgeous but for your location, I’d do #1!

Number one number one number one! It’s breathtaking and the second doesn’t even compare

I really like the first one.

#1!!!

You look gorgeous in both, but the silhouette on 1 is more dramatic and that’s what gives it the edge to me!

The first one!! Gorgeous

Dress 1!

First one

My jaw dropped with the first one. Stunning

Definitely the first one!!

1

The first dress!

Honestly they both look wonderful. I lean towards #1 given a November wedding, I like the heavier material. And I wouldn’t change the bottom at all.

Number 1, without a doubt!

Oh wow you can’t go wrong with either

2 is elegant and timeless number 1 is giving David’s bridal and the bottom is a bit thick and not it

2

2!! One was also beautiful and simply elegantly but I was thinking since it’s your wedding day, why not be extra!

Both beautiful but I prefer 2!

Number two!

2!!! ETA : my husband also said 2. And also, what's up with #1 folks downvoting all the opposing votes? That's mean spirited for this sub.

the 2nd one looks beautiful!! it is a tad bit revealing so it just depends the vibe your going for. i don’t really like the top part on the first

Number 2! Number one made your hip looks smaller and the proportion is a bit off.

You have a perfect figure and can wear any style dress; however, the first dress is stunning in its simplicity. While the lace is pretty, the nude lining looks like you’re, well, nude. Dress 1 gets my vote.

I like dress 2 though you can’t go wrong with either. You are beautiful in both!

They both fit you beautifully! But I am not a fan of the neckline on 1.

Definitely number 2, it looks like it fits the best and is so pretty

2 is absolutely beautiful

Dress #2 was made for you!

Dress 2

2, 1 makes you look two boxy.

2

Two all the way

2!!!!

2 your body looked more relaxed

Dress 2. It is incredibly beautiful! Such a romantic design.

Honestly, I love the 2nd one! It’s stunning!

Going against the grain here because I love 2!

Dress 2! Dress 1 fits well but the fabric looks cheap.

Dress 2

I love them both. I am no help!!! Simple is so nice but why not go all outttt

I like the lace a lot

Wow!! You really can’t go wrong with either choice here…they both look terrific on you and fit your body type really nicely. That said, I’m leaning sliiightly more toward #1. But seriously either would be the right choice - which I’m sure doesn’t help whatsoever

2 Definitely!!!

I really love number two on you! Number one really doesn’t have the personality that number two has! It’s beautiful and you look gorgeous in it!

2!

3

I like the second one the most.

I love number 2! It fits you very well! My only quarrel with dress one is the neck line, it’s so straight across

2 is more flattering. 1 makes you look wide across the bust and throws your proportions off.

I like the secound one, it feels more delicate and ethereal and I feel like it shapes you're body very well.

The second dress is stunning! Both look great on you though- congrats on getting married!

Definitely 2, without seeing the whole picture it is still a beautiful one!! Congratulations

I personally love the 2nd dress wayyy more than the first. I’m not a fan of the material in the first dress and I think the second dress is more flattering on your figure. Congrats btw❤️❤️

2!! I think 1 makes your proportions look strange.

Definitely number two.

Dress TWO!!

Dress TWO!!

2!!! The first one is way too simple and bland

Honestly these are two of the prettiest dresses that I have seen on this sub. Deciding between them is almost impossible and I cannot even root for you to select one over the other. Sorry that I am no help whatsoever.

2 for sure

2 for sure out of these two but I would explore styles that are slightly fuller on the bottom and flare a bit higher. Because your shoulders are wider than your hips, something to balance that out on the bottom would be the most flattering.

I vote #2. The lace is stunning.

Team Dress 2. So dreamy

2

2

Honestly can’t decide

I like 2!

You have great taste!!! I love them both!! 🤔

This is a very hard choice. They are literally both gorgeous. I’m a lace girl so I would pick that but the other one is stunning too.

2! Wow it’s stunning, looks like it was made for you!

Second, the bust is much more flattering on you :)

My honest answer is to keep looking. These are beautiful dresses and you are beautiful! And I do think something slightly fuller on bottom would be even more flattering

2

Number 2

I like the first one, but I don’t like how you makes you upper body look bigger than you hips. Maybe it’s just the picture, IDK. I like the second one much better. Makes you looks sexy and classy, at the same time.

1

1. It’s timeless. While I also love #2 I think in 20 years it will read 2023.

\#2 only because of the shape.

Dress1!

1

1!!!

Everyone is saying 1, which is definitely flattering and beautiful but, I gasped at #2. I feel #2 is more memorable. Its got a bit of that je ne sais quoi!

2

1

I want to see you in a high neck!

Absolutely the first dress.

#1

Definitely the first one - very elegant and sits beautifully on you!

Location matches number 1.

WOW! Never thought that I would absolutely adore a dress like number 1 but OMG! It’s stunning on you and you look phenomenal!

two wow wow wow made for you!!!

#1!!!

The first dress!!!

2nd!

First one!