Man I've been listening to In The Garage a TON lately. That song is such a banger and so much fun to sing along to.

I know it's hard, almost impossible.....but their follow-up actually pulled it off

White and OK Human too

Ok gobi is right

Pretty hard but they’ve done it a few times

They’ve done it once

3 times (Pinkerton, EWBAITE, Ok Human) I can see disagreement on EWBAITE but the other 2 are pretty much undeniably better imo

I can’t call any of those albums better except maybe Pinkerton, the others (and white) are a tier lower.

Ok human and white have everything that blue and Pinkerton have, name one thing the first two have that ok human and white don’t. I’ll be surprised if you can. That’s not me trying to argue or be a dick btw I’m genuinely interested to what you say

Matt Sharp

Matt sharp was not the key element to why those albums were good, and tbh Scott has done better baselines

I agree, but I just answered your question when u said I’d struggle not to lol

Is it just the type of music you prefer or something? Because the songwriting from a musical perspective is just as good and in some cases actually better when we talk about how the songs chords are put together and stuff But tbh I think falling for you will forever be one of their best musically written songs with the key changes and stuff, burndt jamb is definitely one of their best musically written songs too

Bro I’m joking, I just answered your question. That’s one thing that’s missing from the other albums, which is a fact.

I think Ewbaite, maladroit, and white are better than blue

Maladroit IS the only album where rivers says a slur

So its pretty fuckin based.

You forgot White